The winter meetings have come and gone, and the Pirates have still not addressed their shortstop situation, which is clearly their most glaring hole.
Yes, they still need another starting pitcher, but they always seem to find pitchers late in the offseason and they are also flirting with the idea of an opener.
I’m confident that Neal Huntington and company will address the open pitching spot and, frankly, given that it is a fifth starter spot and the rotation is strong, it isn’t that pressing of a need at this point.
Shortstop, however, is a much different issue because the Pirates don’t have a legitimate one on their roster. They currently have two shortstop options in Kevin Newman and Erik Gonzalez. Newman was the Pirates’ first-round pick in 2015 and was brought up to the major-league club last season. He looked like a rookie who still has a long way to go to be an everyday shortstop on a contending team. Newman hit .209/.247/.241 and wasn’t a steady hand on defense, either.
Gonzalez played in 81 games for the Indians this past season and hit .265/.301/.375. Huntington said of Gonzalez: “Erik was a very talented, blocked player who we believe will be a good regular shortstop.”
That’s a nice way of saying Gonzalez, who was acquired in a trade for Jordan Luplow and Max Moroff, was Francisco Lindor’s backup shortstop. Gonzalez is a better option than Newman and might grow into a starting shortstop at some point. The problem is the Pirates don’t have the luxury of waiting around for him as they try to get back to the playoffs in 2019.
Read More
They need to go find a proven shortstop because they aren’t far away from being a contender. This is pretty clear to anyone who looks at the roster — well, anyone except Huntington, apparently.
“We’ll keep our mind open and our eyes and ears open in the free-agent and trade markets to see how things evolve,” Huntington said. “But we do like what we have at shortstop right now. If something better comes along, we’ll entertain it. But between those two [Gonzalez and Newman], we like where we’re going at shortstop.”
Pirates beat reporter Bill Brink explains why this is not a good plan as well as anyone.
Brink wrote: “The issue with entering the 2019 season with Gonzalez and Newman at shortstop is the lack of proven production on a team that could use more consistent offense. Last year, in limited playing time, Gonzalez and Newman combined for minus-0.3 Wins Above Replacement. Gregory Polanco will miss opening day because of shoulder surgery; the Pirates should know more about his timeline, Huntington said, when he begins throwing in January. They have no idea what to expect from Kang, who played only three games last year after missing the entire 2017 season. Chisenhall, signed to help cover Polanco’s absence, has hit when healthy but missed significant time in recent seasons because of calf injuries.”
That’s exactly the point — the Pirates’ offense is inconsistent and lacks power. Polanco’s injury is the wild card in it all because he is one of the Pirates’ best power hitters. He could be out as long as two or three months, and without him, this offense looks relatively pedestrian. The Pirates are not a team that can afford to have a shortstop that doesn’t provide anything on offense.
The trade of Ivan Nova was actually smart because it freed up $8.5 million. Nova was a fifth starter at best and for a small-market team it was money that could be better used elsewhere. That lowered the Pirates’ estimated opening day payroll to somewhere between $70 million and $73 million. That was exciting because it should have meant that there was money in the budget to spend on a shortstop, a pitcher and perhaps a good hitter for the bench — until Huntington made it clear that the Nova money has almost all already been allocated to sign Jung-Ho Kang, Lonnie Chisenhall and Jordan Lyles.
The Pirates are a small-market team and must be shrewd in the way they do business. There is no question that they have some limitations in their budget and have to be careful not to get into bad contracts. There comes a point, however, when a team is just using that as an excuse not to spend money that they clearly have. And the Pirates, with a payroll of $72 million or so, clearly can afford to spend some money to shore up a position of obvious need.
It is early in the offseason and there is still about 10 weeks until spring training begins, so there is time for the Pirates to make a move for a shortstop. If they do, it speaks volumes about their desire to contend. If they don’t, it is fair to question whether winning is truly their priority.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.