Mike Tomlin might be in the midst of his best season as the Steelers’ head coach. He has worked hard to keep this team engaged through a tough start. He has had a steady hand in guiding the defense back to respectability (and beyond, actually). He also fought through a lot of off-field foolishness — not to mention the loss of Le’Veon Bell as a weapon — to help the team get into position to win the division.
Ben Roethlisberger also might be having his best season as the Steelers’ quarterback. He has been freed of Todd Haley and is on his way to setting a number of personal and team records. He has thrown for 3,664 yards, 24 touchdowns and 12 interceptions. He is on pace to throw for more than 5,000 yards and 35-plus touchdowns.
Tomlin should absolutely be in the discussion for NFL Coach of the Year. I’d say Sean McVay, Sean Payton and Bill O'Brien all have strong resumes, but there is a great case to be made for Tomlin given all the Steelers have overcome.
The same can be said about Roethlisberger as the NFL’s Most Valuable Player. It is a tougher case to make for Roethlisberger because the field of candidates is top heavy, but it isn’t delusional to put him in that discussion. He has been special at times this season and has often carried the offense.
It is wonderful that both men have been great at their jobs this year. It has been a great story so far and it has been an incredible ride. But it will all be for nothing if the Steelers don’t get to the Super Bowl. I might even say they need to win the Super Bowl, but the NFC has some great teams that might just be better than the Steelers.
The AFC, however, does not. The Steelers are the best and most complete team in the AFC. There isn’t another AFC team that can boast the Steelers’ combination of offense and defense. The Steelers have a Hall of Fame quarterback and receiver combination and a number of other weapons, so they have enough firepower on offense to match scores with anyone. Their defense, meanwhile, has improved greatly over the course of the season and is now ranked No. 6 in the NFL.
Read More

Kansas City’s offense is grabbing headlines and Patrick Mahomes is a rising star. He hasn’t been through the grind of the playoffs yet and the Chiefs are still coached by playoff-underachiever Andy Reid. More importantly, though, the Chiefs’ defense is atrocious (ranked No. 30 in total defense and No. 28 in scoring), and that’s where the Steelers should have an edge if these two teams meet in the playoffs.
The Patriots finally look like an old dynasty that is running out of gas. Tom Brady is still a great player, but he isn’t a miracle worker and he doesn’t have a lot to work with. The Patriots’ two best offensive players not named Brady are Rob Gronkowski and Julian Edelman, and they both have had injury issues this year.
The Chargers are an excellent team on both sides of the ball, but Philip Rivers has never won a thing. DeShaun Watson has made the Texans relevant again, but they have mostly feasted on an easy schedule. The bottom line is there just isn’t a team in the AFC that you could say, “Well, if they beat the Steelers in the playoffs it is because they are better.”
No, this is a year where the only standard that Tomlin and Roethlisberger should be judged by is whether or not they get to the Super Bowl. The fact that they will win the division and make the playoffs is not particularly meaningful. They should win their division and should win it with little trouble because the AFC North stinks. The Ravens have won a few games in a row to get back into the playoff chase and the Steelers split with them. The Browns are, well, the Browns, and the Bengals are a dumpster fire playing out the string for what looks a lot like a lame-duck coach just waiting to be fired.
Tomlin and Roethlisberger have been a formidable duo in the regular season for as long as they have been together. They were a formidable duo their first four years together in the playoffs, too, as they won five of their first six postseason games together. That hasn’t been the case recently, though, as they are just 3-6 in playoff games since the 2010 AFC championship game.
They have played in the AFC championship game only once since the 2010 season and have not been to a Super Bowl since they lost to Green Bay in Super Bowl XLV. They have only three playoff wins together since 2010, and only their win at Kansas City in the 2016 playoffs was impressive.
Tomlin has compiled a lot of regular-season wins of late and has done a brilliant job this season. Roethlisberger has always given the Steelers a chance to win and he has compiled a lot of yards and touchdowns. All of it is impressive, but none of it will matter if they can’t get over the hump this year and get back to the Super Bowl.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.