Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lawrence McCutcheon and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
BrutallyHonestGamer, @BHG_Gaming: Will James Washington ever catch a pass?
Starkey: You mean catch another pass, Mr. BrutallyHonestGamer? No, he won’t. Not at this rate. Not when he turns a pitch-and-catch down the right sideline into a dive, roll and drop.
Have I gone nuts, or was that ball perfectly catchable with no dive? I keep looking at the play, and it appears, on a 1-to-10 degree-of-difficulty scale, that Washington turned a 3 into an 11.
Earlier in the game, a ball bounced off his hands, and it was hard to tell whether it was lost in the sun, off-target or just a flat-out drop. Weird things seem to happen when Washington is targeted, that’s all I know, and his rookie season is not getting better. It’s getting worse.
I’m not ready to label him Jarvis James just yet, but when Al Villanueva has better numbers with fewer targets in a given game, something is very wrong.
Read More
These are the facts: Washington has caught roughly a third of the passes thrown his way and has just eight receptions for a paltry 77 yards on the season. JuJu Smith-Schuster beats that on one play. Washington was supposed to be a deep threat, a jump-ball artist — but those jump balls are a lot tougher to win against elite NFL athletes with money on the line than in the Big 12 or in the NFL’s preseason.
And what does it say about the Steelers’ confidence in Justin Hunter that he cannot crack the lineup, given Washington’s struggles? (Hint: not much.)
This offense has plenty of weapons, but in order to keep up with, say, Patrick Mahomes, they could sure use one more. Washington has gotten every opportunity. If he gets another one Sunday, he best take advantage of it.
Tyler F, @TyStik87: is Ben Roethlisberger elite?
Starkey: Yes, Tyler, he is — but he throws too many interceptions. He is tied for second in the league in picks (12), and even though part of that can be traced to sheer volume of pass attempts — he leads the NFL with 472 — it’s still too many. What’s more, this is the second consecutive year he threw a killer end-zone pick late in a key game, one that could have major implications on playoff seedings.
Both throws — last year against New England and Sunday in Denver — were born of questionable decisions. You have to admire Roethlisberger’s go-for-broke demeanor, but sometimes it’s better to live for another play.
Last year, he could have settled for a game-tying field goal instead of rushing a play against the Patriots. On Sunday, he could have thrown it away and tried one more play, instead of throwing a pass that was ill-fated even if Denver nose tackle Shelby Harris didn’t leap to pick it off. Chris Harris Jr. was in front of Antonio Brown with a great chance to snag the ball, as well.
As I wrote Sunday, somebody named Harris was going to make that play, and it wasn’t going to be Franco — who was, unbelievably, standing outside the Steelers’ locker room after the game (he was the only Steelers player who didn’t commit a turnover).

Robert Bible, @bibtone: Here’s a question, is a 7-7 record for Pitt with a division championship a success? This with a 3-game losing streak to end the season.
Starkey: Now THAT’S a question, Mr. bibtone. I commend you. It is at once well-stated and provocative.
Thinking … thinking … thinking.
OK, here is what I’ll say: Winning a division championship makes the season a success — but if you finish on a three-game losing streak and go 7-7, it’s a mild success at best. Especially if the Clemson game gets ugly.
Patrik, @Steelfrmblawnox: Next Pittsburgh team to win a championship?
Starkey: How about Pitt women’s volleyball, Mr. Steelfrmblawnox? They’re 29-1 and a 12 seed in the NCAA Tournament. They open against Iona at 7 p.m. Friday at The Pete. If they win, they’ll play the winner of Michigan-Navy the next night. You never know how far this might go.
Incidentally, my favorite athletes from Iona, Michigan and Navy:
• Iona: Jeff Ruland. Underrated center. Extremely consistent on that little 12-foot banker.
• Navy: David Robinson. I feel like he should have gotten more minutes on the Dream Team.
• Michigan: Campy Russell. I copied his over-the-head shooting technique in Nerf basketball and later told him about this in person. He seemed rattled.
Brian, @samspopguy: How much is too much to put on Clemson -25.5.
Starkey: Here’s the thing, Mr. @samspopguy — Pitt has a chance to shorten the game with that running game. Problem is, I wonder if that running game is the same without Jimmy Morrissey in the middle. That was a wicked blow. And if Miami’s defensive front can dominate as it did, Clemson’s can.
On the other hand, Pat Narduzzi and his staff have now had some time to adjust. I have a weird feeling Pitt will keep this game close. I’m not sure I’d bet on it, though.

BishopMemorial, @BishopMemorial: Is the ceiling for the Steelers now 9 wins? If so, will that be enough to hold onto the division?
Starkey: The Steelers will go 10-5-1 Mr. BishopMemorial. They will beat Los Angeles (37-27), New England (30-26) and Cincinnati (100-0) and will lose to Oakland (19-18) and New Orleans (41-31).
You’re welcome.
Tim Shady, @timmshady: If you trained for a year straight, which of these would be more possible (for you):
A.) Dunking a basketball
B.) Hitting a home run
C.) Throwing a football 50 yards
Starkey: I could train for a century and not be able to dunk a basketball, or even a Tic Tac, so strike that one. Throwing a football 50 yards sounds easy until you’re standing at the goal line trying to do it. Forget that.
Hitting a home run? You didn’t say at which park. Give me 365 days, a metal bat and steady steroid regimen, and I might hit one out of Wild Things Park — 320 feet down the left-field line. But probably not.
OK, definitely not.
But if the question is which one could I come closest to? Probably that.
Thank you kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.