Pitt’s big win at Virginia last Friday set up an even bigger game Saturday at Heinz Field against Virginia Tech. The winner will have the inside track to the Coastal Division title, though the Panthers could finish in first even if they lose to the Hokies.

The thing is, the minute the Virginia win was in the book, many Pitt fans began to panic about the prospects of a big game at home. The Panthers are traditionally much better at playing the spoiler than in meaningful games.

I saw a Pitt fan on social media compare the fan base to Charlie Brown and the Panthers to Lucy. It seems every time Charlie Brown/Pitt fans get really interested, Lucy/the team pulls the football away. It is kind of a funny analogy — but it also speaks to the self-loathing nature of the fan base.

The truth is, though, as pessimistic as Pitt fans can be, when it comes to big home homes, the post-2000 reality is a little less bleak than the perception. For this exercise’s sake, my definition of a big game is one that puts Pitt in position to win a conference championship.

Advertise with us

Some would put Penn State games in that category. I understand, but I disagree. Those games are less important than any league game, but if you must count them, Pitt is 2-1 against Penn State at home since 2000.

This Virginia Tech game, though, is far bigger than any against Penn State since 1982 and the Panthers’ biggest home game this late in the season since 2010 when they hosted West Virginia. The Panthers needed to beat the Mountaineers to take control of the Big East race with one game to play. West Virginia, though, came into Heinz Field and blew Pitt out, 35-10. It turned out to be the final blow for Dave Wannstedt, as he was fired a little more than a week later.

Pitt played Cincinnati in 2009 on the final Saturday of the season. The winner would get the Big East title, a BCS bid and a trip to the Sugar Bowl. Pitt led by 21 points but lost in heartbreaking fashion, 45-44. That was probably the beginning of the end for Wannstedt.

Pitt, however, did have success in 2004 against the Mountaineers with the Big East title on the line. The Tyler Palko-led Panthers upset Boston College at home in October to put themselves into the conference championship discussion then beat West Virginia, 16-13, at home to take control of the conference with one game to play. The next week they won at South Florida, 43-14, to clinch their trip to the Fiesta Bowl.

In 2003 the Panthers beat Virginia Tech late in the season at home to set up a first-place showdown with Miami. In that game, so big “ESPN Gameday” came to Heinz Field, the Panthers needed a last-minute touchdown by Lousaka Polite to win. A few weeks later, though, the Panthers hosted Miami with a trip to the Orange Bowl on the line and got beat 28-14 in a game that wasn’t nearly as close as the score.

Advertise with us

Pitt also needed to pull a huge upset of Virginia Tech at home — 38-7 — in 2001 for an opportunity to clinch a winning record and a bowl game. No championship was on the line, but it was huge for Walt Harris’ future. Had the Panthers lost, they would have had no chance to finish with a winning record, and there was a good chance Harris would have been fired. He wound up staying through the 2004 season.

That is a bit of a history lesson, but it shows the Panthers are more successful in these big home games than it seems. Their record is 4-3 if you count 2001 Virginia Tech, 3-3 if you don’t. Throw in the three Penn State home games and Pitt is either 6-4 or 5-4.

None of this actually matters Saturday; none of these Pitt players have faced a home conference game this big. None had anything to do with the 2010 or 2009 losses, nor the successes in 2004. Many Pitt fans, however, have the Panthers’ history on their minds, and it is easy to understand why. However, the truth is Lucy hasn’t pulled the football away from Pitt fans nearly as much as they think — and that should at least give them some reason to be optimistic.

Editor’s note: Paul Zeise’s son, Elijah, is a scholarship athlete on the Pitt football team.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com, Twitter: @PaulZeise