Robert Casto had just one request for Mike Herndon when he saw his former star player a couple weeks ago, as the two decided that the football coach at Riverheads High School in Staunton, Va., would walk Herndon onto Heinz Field for senior day this weekend against Virginia Tech.

Casto, admittedly a longtime West Virginia fan, wouldn’t mind wearing Pitt memorabilia for this occasion, but he had his sights on one specific piece of gear.

“Look, Mike, I want one of those red Pitt hats,” Casto told Herndon, one of the best to wear that same color in Casto’s powerhouse program. “Your coaches [on the sideline] wear a red Pitt hat. I don’t want a blue Pitt hat, I want that red one.”

“I can’t find one,” Herndon reported back. “I can’t get one.”

Advertise with us

Casto just chuckled and told Herndon it’s OK. It’s probably the only time Pitt’s redshirt senior right guard has ever let him down.

One of those stereotypical gruff football coaches, a guy who doesn’t even have a cell phone let alone social media, Saturday might get the emotions flowing even for Casto as he accompanies Herndon for pregame festivities. Herndon, who turns 23 next month, already has endured more than a lifetime’s worth of sorrow, though he rarely talks about it.

“Well, you knew what was happening,” Casto said from his office Wednesday. “You just tried to listen to him, and let him talk. We didn’t spend a whole lot of time on it. If Mike wanted to talk about it, we talked about it. I don’t get into a whole lot of his personal life and the things that we’ve done with him.”

But Herndon recently opened up to the newspaper in his hometown. His father died when he was 6, and his first stepfather took his own life before Herndon was 10. Herndon’s mother, Patricia, later remarried, and she and her husband blended their families. In 2014, Patricia Herndon Whetzel died at the age of 58, shortly before her son graduated from high school. In September 2016, David Whetzel, Herndon’s last remaining parent, died at 74.

“I was kind of used to death,” he told the Staunton News Leader of losing his mom.

Advertise with us

The 6-foot-4, 310-pound, Monopoly-loving Herndon has teammates who respect him for his constant willingness to contribute, often flipping back and forth between defensive and offensive line until settling at guard and starting every game so far this season. But a couple days after he was named the ACC’s offensive lineman of the week — “I’m not, like, an outstanding player or anything, but it’s awesome,” the humble Herndon said — it became clear he’s revered in Pitt’s locker room for more than meets the eye.

“He really might be one of the most mentally strong guys I’ve ever met in my entire life,” said George Aston, a close friend, former roommate and fellow senior from Western Virginia. “He’s been through some things in his life that nobody could really imagine being in that position. The way he carries himself, the way he goes about each day, whatever he’s doing, you’d never know. I really look up to him.”

Senior linebacker Oluwaseun Idowu called Herndon one of Pitt’s most consistent players, and one who never complains.

“It’s the same face every day, the same Mike you get every day,” Idowu said. “He’ll fool around with you once in a while — he’s a cool dude — but he really comes with the same consistent attitude every day, no matter what he’s going through; physical pain, mental pain, whatever it is. I don't think I’ve ever seen him in a moment where it’s like, ‘You’re not yourself today.’ ”

Pitt coach Pat Narduzzi once summed up Herndon as “he doesn’t say boo,” but as his college career winds down, Herndon’s beginning to get nostalgic. Sure, it helps to make things fun when Pitt’s ground attack is dominating games, but Herndon admits he misses playing defense, and he’ll feel a twinge of sadness when it hits him that he’s on his home field for the last time with the other senior “hogs,” Alex Bookser, Connor Dintino and Stefano Millin, not to mention sophomore center Jimmy Morrissey.

Advertise with us

On the bright side, he’ll have a crew of high school friends and teammates in town for the game, and of course his old coach, who also appreciates the chance to see Herndon bump heads with the in-state Hokies.

“Virginia Tech offered Mike, then they kind of shut the door on him,” Casto recalled. “We haven’t been too happy with that whole situation.”

Ah, now that sounds like the blunt personality of a sideline veteran, one who will defend his guys and stand by them — in this case, literally — until the very end.

“Mike’s a very private person. We both are,” Casto said. “Mike doesn’t ask for all this stuff. He doesn’t want someone to feel sorry for him. He’s been dealt this hand. He understands it. He’s been able to handle what most people can’t handle. He doesn’t ask anything for it. Just give him an opportunity, which is all he ever asked for at Pitt.”

Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.

Advertise with us

Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.

Matchup: Pitt Panthers (5-4, 4-1 ACC) vs. Virginia Tech Hokies (4-4, 3-2), Heinz Field.

When: 3:30 p.m., Saturday.

TV, Radio, Internet: ESPNU; KDKA-FM (93.7), WatchESPN.com, Sirius Channel 108, XM Channel 194, Internet Channel 956.

DYK? The past four meetings between Pitt and Virginia Tech have been decided by a touchdown or less, with both teams winning two of those by a combined nine points.