The Pirates had an opportunity to pull to within five games of first place and pick up a game in the wild-card race Wednesday night. Instead, they got hammered by the Cubs, 9-2, and as a result will go into the weekend seven games out of first.
Starting pitcher Nick Kingham didn’t have his best stuff Wednesday so the game was probably destined to go the wrong way for the Pirates, anyway. Kingham needed 51 pitches to get through the first inning and by the end of it the Pirates trailed 4-0. That would be the only inning he pitched, but at that point, the damage was done.
Kingham’s performance notwithstanding, the Pirates didn’t exactly put their best foot forward with their starting lineup, either. The Pirates had three players — Sean Rodriguez, Jose Osuna and Jordan Luplow — in their lineup who are hitting less than .180. At this point in the season, that’s absolutely unacceptable.
Yes, the Pirates are short-handed right now as both Corey Dickerson and Josh Bell are on the disabled list. That is even more of a reason for the Pirates to make sure they put their best lineup on the field every single night. The Pirates have no margin for error at this point, and they need to win every single game they can in order to have a chance to get to the playoffs.
There are times when the Pirates have built in days off for players. That is an overrated concept to begin with but especially in August, in a pennant race and the day before the Pirates are off. The Pirates were off Monday and they are off Thursday. That means there is no reason to give anyone a day off Wednesday in a game against the team you are chasing for the division title.
There is also the righty-lefty thing, which might explain some of the decisions. That would make a lot of sense since the Pirates were facing a tough left-hander in Cole Hamels. This is why it made some sense to play Sean Rodriguez, despite how poorly he has played this season. He does hit lefties better than a number of the other options as he has a .442 slugging percentage and .807 OPS against lefties.
Read More
That’s why it was OK for Rodriguez to be in the lineup, even though he made a crucial error and is in the midst of a terrible season. He shouldn’t have been at second base, he should have been in left field. That’s because Jordan Luplow, who played third base, is one of the Pirates’ worst hitters (.158/.238/.316) against lefties.
Fans were chanting “D-F-A” at Rodriguez during last at-bat because they are frustrated with him. He has been awful at the plate — 58 strikeouts in 146 at-bats — and has struggled in the field as well. He does have some value, though, perhaps as a pinch hitter against lefties. I don’t have as much of a problem with Rodriguez being on the roster as some, but as soon as Dickerson and Bell are back, he should not start another game.
The Pirates should also have given Francisco Cervelli his first try at first base Wednesday night. That would have enabled them to play Elias Diaz at catcher and those two moves would have strengthened the lineup significantly. Diaz is the best hitter the Pirates have against lefties (.386/.407/.632) and the fact he wasn’t in the lineup was puzzling.
Adam Frazier is a left-hander but he still should have been in the lineup at second base. That’s because he hits lefties (.235) much better than Osuna (.176) and Luplow. Frazier hit lefties well enough that he shouldn’t ever have to sit out, especially since he is a more viable option as the leadoff hitter than Luplow.
These moves don’t seem like a big deal but over the course of a long season they matter. There is never a reason to start Luplow or Osuna at this point in the season until they both prove they can hit better than they have. Luplow, like Rodriguez, should never start a game once Dickerson returns unless there is an injury.
The Pirates don’t have the luxury of giving their best players a night off any more. They are in a pennant race and they are behind, so every game matters. That’s especially true in games against teams from their own division.
Again, Kingham didn’t give the Pirates a chance Wednesday night, but neither did Clint Hurdle and whoever he consulted to put together the lineup. The Pirates have made it clear they believe they are in contention for the playoffs with the moves they made at the trade deadline. Hurdle now needs to make it clear by putting the best lineup possible on the field every night.
Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.