It has been a long time since Pitt, Penn State and West Virginia have all three had compelling seasons.
That’s why the upcoming college football season could be special for fans in Western Pennsylvania. This could be the first year in quite some time that all three teams are legitimate contenders for their conference or division titles. All three teams appear to have depth, experience and head coaches who have been around long enough to build the roster they want.
But most importantly, all three teams seem to have excellent quarterbacks in place. Penn State’s Trace McSorley and West Virginia’s Will Grier could end up in the Heisman Trophy discussion. And while less proven, Pitt’s Kenny Pickett showed flashes at the end of last season, and that has Panthers fans excited 2018.
Let’s take a look at all three:
• McSorley is probably the best of the three, and he plays on the most high profile team. He isn’t always the most polished passer, but he has grit and is one of the best in the country when the game is on the line. Penn State will have a few tough battles along the road to the Big Ten title, and McSorley with the ball in his hands and a chance to win the game will always be the Nittany Lions’ edge. The best example of this came last season at Iowa when McSorley, who struggled the entire game, drove the team down the field and threw a touchdown pass on the final play.
McSorley is more than winning drives and playing well under pressure, though. He puts up big numbers, too. Last season he threw for 3,570 yards and 28 touchdowns, and he rushed for 491 yards and 11 touchdowns. His ability to run makes him a nightmare to defend.
Read More
There is a legitimate concern that McSorley without Saquon Barkley in the backfield will be far less effective, but I don’t buy it. James Franklin has been a recruiting machine, and the Nittany Lions have talented players at all the skill positions. Miles Sanders, a Woodland Hills graduate, played behind Barkley last season and showed he is capable of becoming a big-play running back as well.
• Grier is the most talented and physically gifted of the three. Some NFL scouts think Grier may be the first quarterback taken in next year’s NFL draft. Grier is 6-feet-2 and has a strong arm. He is also, at least according to scouts, excellent at reading defenses and making good decisions.
The Mountaineers have had a bumpy transition from the Big East to the Big 12, but this season they finally could be a factor in the Big 12 race. They are picked to finish second behind Oklahoma, but the Sooners will have a first-year quarterback, and Grier could provide the edge for the Mountaineers to beat them.
• Pickett is the most intriguing of the three. He was on his way to a redshirt last season when he had to play one snap against Syracuse. When starting quarterback Ben DiNucci struggled, Pickett got his shot against Virginia Tech and nearly led the Panthers to a come-from-behind win.
He then led the Panthers to a 24-14 upset win over undefeated and second-ranked Miami. Pickett didn’t throw for big numbers in the game (193 yards), but he was clearly in control of the huddle. He also ran for 60 yards and two touchdowns and showed poise that very few freshmen have in their first start. Pickett seems to have the “it” factor, no doubt, but how that translates to the field for an entire season is still a mystery.
The most important positions at Pitt, Penn State and West Virginia appear to be in great hands, and that’s a perfect place to start believing all three are headed for special seasons.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com
Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.