Neal Huntington still believes the Pirates are in playoff contention and has used his radio show the past few weeks to fight off rumors that they are going to be sellers at the trade deadline.
He has apparently gone to the Bill Clinton school of spin and taken a page right out of the popular former president’s campaign playbook. The more Huntington repeats something as fact, no matter how untrue or delusional, the more people will begin to believe it. And eventually they’ll not only believe it, they will begin to recite it as truth.
The problem Huntington has is that Clinton was, for the most part, well-liked and extremely charismatic, so people wanted to believe him even when they knew some of his talking points were utter nonsense. Huntington doesn’t have that luxury, though, as his condescending approach has hurt his credibility.
Yes, there’s some truth to what Huntington says. There’s time for the Pirates to make some noise. This 11-game homestand before the All-Star break is huge in that regard. They play six games against two teams ahead of them in the wild-card race (the Phillies and Nationals), then five games against the NL Central-leading Brewers.
But the Pirates will have to do something special — like 9-2 or better — to make themselves even temporarily relevant. Anything less than that is not going to mean a whole lot other than delay the inevitability of their third lost season in a row.
The Pirates not only have a talent problem, they have a math problem, too. They’re 40-46 through 86 games, with 76 games left. That’s a lot of games in theory, but because of the fickle nature of baseball, it isn’t. The Pirates would have to go on an unbelievable run to have any prayer at the postseason, and frankly it still might not be enough.
Read More
Let’s assume a team needs 95 wins to clinch the NL Central, a likely conservative estimate because the Brewers (52-35) are playing at a better pace. The Pirates are 11½ games back in the division. To get to 95 wins, they will have to go 55-21 in their final 76 games.
The wild-card outlook isn’t much better. The Colorado Rockies, the second NL wild-card team in 2017, won 87 games. The Pirates would have to go 47-29 in their final 76 games to get there. Six teams currently sit between the Pirates and the second wild-card team (the Phillies).
It’s probably time for Huntington to stop trying to sell people on the idea that the Pirates are a playoff contender. They are not. And quite frankly, they are not even close.
Huntington could gain some good will by admitting this team wasn’t built to contend. He could do even more by pledging that he is going to build upon the Pirates’ young core by adding some veteran free agents in the offseason. The Pirates have some reasonable pieces in place, but they don’t have enough overall talent. Huntington and the Pirates’ front office need to stop being so delusional and acknowledge this.
The Pirates’ season technically isn’t over, but it will be by the All-Star break is something special doesn’t start Friday night.
Can’t get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?
Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.