Three quotes come to mind as I consider the 2018 Pirates just past the halfway mark …
“We’re not horrible.” — Clint Hurdle
“We’re not rebuilding.” — Neal Huntington
“We have made a tremendous amount of progress.” — Bob Nutting
I should probably add Hurdle’s, “This place is going to explode when we win it all,” but I’m pretty sure he was talking about 2096.
Hurdle’s other quote — “We’re not horrible” — actually has some merit. Here’s the thing: When you’re in the Pirates’ position, you’d rather be horrible than bad. That was the rationale behind razing the roster when Hurdle and Huntington arrived, remember?
Read More
It worked, too. But only for a short time.
If the idea was to construct a system so strong from top to bottom that Huntington could refresh, replenish or refurbish (notice I didn’t say “rebuild”) whenever the situation warranted, then it’s becoming apparent he failed and should be feeling some serious heat if things don’t suddenly turn.
Of course, he won’t, because Nutting signed Huntington, and Hurdle, to four-year extensions — FOUR YEARS! — in September of last season and would rather do a live news conference than pay somebody to not work.
It was on that day last September, incidentally, that Nutting delivered the following quote (via press release, of course):
“While we all know there is still much work to be done and goals to accomplish, we have made a tremendous amount of progress under their tenures. I believe that Neal and Clint continue to be the right leaders to push us forward in our goal of bringing postseason baseball back to Pittsburgh.”
Wait a second. I just noticed that last part. Shouldn’t the goal be to bring a World Series championship back to Pittsburgh?
How about the first division title since 1992?
How about finishing ahead of the freakin’ Cardinals for the first time since 1999?
Anyway, let’s focus on the notion of “tremendous progress.” Nobody would argue that by 2013, the Huntington-Hurdle regime had made incredible strides by snapping the franchise’s 20-year losing streak and “bringing postseason baseball back to Pittsburgh.” They kept moving, too, all the way to 98 wins (tied for team-best since 1909) three seasons ago.
But then the bottom dropped out. The Pirates didn’t just regress. That would have been understandable. They disintegrated in a sea of arrogance (”We can remake any pitcher on earth, even Ryan Vogelsong”), stinginess and player malfunction, not to mention the rotten returns on Huntington’s drafts.

They had seasons of 78 and 75 wins and are headed toward that neighborhood again as they enter a weekend series against the Philadelphia Phillies. The promise of that fast start and the vigor behind all the I-told-you-so’s — team President Frank Coonelly claimed it was media criticism that fueled these upstart Pirates — has faded. The Pirates are just 2½ games out of last place in the NL Central and a logical candidate to jettison multiple veteran players by the July 31 trade deadline.
But it’s way more than that. This team, through a series of penny-pinching moves and repeated references to your role in helping them pay for players — listen, we can only do so much if people don’t buy tickets — has alienated the fan base to the point where the “PNC” in PNC Park could stand for “Pretty (Much) Nobody Comes.”
The place is often emptier than Gregory Polanco’s head as he tracks a fly ball. I have never seen this fan base so dispirited. It’s as if getting a taste of how good it could be has only doubled the misery of descending into another multiyear losing streak.
And Nutting is selling progress? (cue the Allen Iverson rant) Progress? We’re talkin’ ’bout progress?
If you’re in terrible shape and lose 50 pounds, then gain it all back, have you really made progress?
I mean, you did. You looked great for three months. Or in this case, three years. But look at you now.
I don’t want to get crazy here. I wouldn’t trade the whole team. I actually wouldn’t consider trading anybody other than Ivan Nova, Francisco Cervelli, Josh Harrison, Jordy Mercer, Starling Marte, Gregory Polanco, David Freese, Sean Rodriguez, Corey Dickerson and Felipe Vazquez (why have a closer when you’re rarely winning in the ninth inning?). And anybody else another team calls about.
That is not meant as a criticism of all those players — many have been exemplary performers here — but rather a reflection of the Pirates’ place in the standings and a nod to the obvious: A lot of those guys are in their 30s, making good money (in Pirates’ terms) and nearing the ends of their contracts. That would make them trade candidates if the team was winning, never mind careening toward last place.
I included Marte and Polanco because it is becoming clear they are not the franchise centerpieces the Pirates hoped them to be.

You might remember that when Huntington finally finished detonating the 2009 club, he said, “We don’t feel like we’ve broken up the ’27 Yankees.” Well, the 2009 team started 40-50; this one is 40-46 and not exactly brimming with elite young talent.
The farm system is better than it was 10 years ago. That isn’t saying much. But Huntington’s first teams, bad as they were, had some interesting pieces from the previous regime.
Those included a rising superstar (Andrew McCutchen), a legit power hitter and former Rookie of the Year (Jason Bay), a recent batting champ (Freddy Sanchez), a hometown hero (Neil Walker) who would soon become one of the better second basemen in the National League, and a prospect (Marte) who would soon have everyone excited.
What do these Pirates have that excites people? Not a whole lot, if ticket sales are any indication.
The ’09 Pirates were second-to-last in the NL in attendance. These Pirates are, too, and averaging fewer fans per game.
Those Pirates needed to be torn up to pave the way for something better. It is becoming apparent these Pirates do, too.
And the question that would then arise might be the reason why Huntington is so reluctant to use the word “rebuild.” The question then would be this:
How many times should the same people get to rebuild the same franchise?
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.
Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.