The NCAA is often an easy target for harsh criticism, and most of the time the critics are correct. The organization often makes decisions that make it more difficult, not easier, for student-athletes.
That is changing. The NCAA has finally begun to understand it has to change or it will become extinct. There have been a number of lawsuits brought against the NCAA on behalf of student-athletes in recent years, dealing with every subject from eligibility to licensing and merchandising fees and rights.
The NCAA exists for student-athletes, and now the organization seems to be operating like it. This began a few years ago, when the organization essentially allowed for a stipend (the full cost of attendance) for student-athletes. It wasn’t quite paying players, but depending on what school and what sport, student-athletes get a certain amount of money above and beyond their scholarship. That helped take care of one issue as student-athletes from poor families now at least have money in their pockets to use as they need or want.
Wednesday, however, the NCAA took another step by passing a rule that allows student-athletes to transfer without permission from their current school. The process is now simple — student-athletes inform their school of their desire to transfer, or at least consider a transfer, and the school must put their name on a national database within two days.
Once the athlete’s name is on the database, coaches from other schools are free to contact them. They no longer need a “permission to contact” release, and they no longer need a release from their scholarship.
This is a great step forward because it finally takes the power out of the hands of the schools and coaches and gives it back to the student-athletes. Coaches can no longer hold players hostage or try to dictate where they can or cannot go. This wouldn’t be necessary if coaches used common sense, but there are far too many horror stories of vindictive coaches not releasing players to schools of their choice.
Read More
It probably isn’t ideal that players can now transfer easier because it does seem to create a system of free agency. There isn’t a better way to do it, though, and as long as coaches can leave without penalty or permission, players should have that right as well. I don’t think the transfer culture and epidemic of the past few years is necessarily a good thing, but the NCAA doesn’t exist without student-athletes, and that’s why they should have the power to control their own careers.
There is a stipulation in the rules that conferences can still make more restrictive rules than the NCAA, but good luck with that. A conference can try to put in a rule (the Big East, for instance, doesn’t allow basketball players to transfer within the conference) like that, but I can’t imagine it will hold up in court. All it will take is one player with a lawyer who wants to challenge it and that will be all she wrote for that conference rule.
Lawyers, lawsuits and threatened lawsuits are why the NCAA is seemingly becoming so enlightened with regards to student-athlete rights. I don’t know if I will go as far as to say Cam Johnson is the reason this transfer rule has changed, but he is one of a number of athletes whose challenge to the system has helped change it.
The other rule that was passed and announced Wednesday was that players can now play up to four football games in a given season and still redshirt. This rule is important because it will protect the eligibility of players who are thrust into action late in a season due to an injury. A fifth year of eligibility is important in football, probably more than any sport, because a lot of freshmen aren’t physically ready to play a whole season at that level. They need a year to develop physically, but they can now gain some game experience in situations and not jeopardize a year of eligibility.
These rules are two more steps forward for the NCAA as the organization continues to try to respond to the needs of student-athletes. There is a long way to go and a lot more work to be done, but at least there is progress being made and for once the organization seems to be using a common-sense approach to passing rules.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.