Pitt coaching searches always seem to turn into a punchline, and this current search for a basketball coach is quickly turning into one. There are many reasons why this has happened in the past, but this time around it’s because Pitt has no idea what it wants the men’s basketball program to be.

This whole process would be a lot easier if everyone in positions of power got on the same page.

No program can conduct a successful search for a coach until it figures out these questions: Does Pitt want its program to compete at the highest level? Does Pitt want its program to fight for ACC championships and NCAA tournament success? Does Pitt want a program that regularly produces NBA players?

If the answer to those questions is yes, then Pitt needs to continue to shoot for a coach who is likely to deliver that. If this is what Pitt truly wants, then chancellor Patrick Gallagher needs to personally call Sean Miller, similar to what chancellor Mark Nordenberg did in 2004 to bring Dave Wannstedt home. Miller is that level of a coach and one of the few Pitt probably has access to.

Advertise with us

He isn’t the only one, though. Their top target, Dan Hurley, is at that level. There are others with plenty of experience, who have proved they can win in a top league. How does anyone know if Pitt has a chance to hire those coaches unless Pitt picks up the phone and pursues them?

That’s not to say this level of success can’t be achieved by taking a flyer on a young, hungry coach like Nate Oats. However, Pitt shouldn’t be in position to gamble on a young, hungry coach yet. There are plenty of experienced coaches it should pursue before that, if it truly wants to compete at the highest level of the ACC.

Pitt could decide it’s fine with winning just enough, being competitive, hanging around the middle of the ACC and living on the NCAA tournament bubble. The kids graduate, there is an occasional NBA player produced and the players never embarrass the university. A great comparison would be Florida State — a football school that is happy with a program that fits the profile of what I just described.

If that’s what it wants, though, there was no reason to fire Kevin Stallings. Given a few years, Stallings would have had Pitt in that category somewhere near the middle of the ACC. That’s what he did at Vanderbilt for 17 seasons.

If this search ends up with a safe hire like Mark Schmidt, it will be an expensive waste of time. Schmidt is basically a less successful version of Stallings — a grinder who would put together a competitive program that would likely have as many NIT trips as NCAA trips.

Advertise with us

The money Pitt paid to make Stallings go away and offer a job to Dan Hurley suggests Pitt wants to be better than the middle of the ACC. It suggests Pitt believes it can be Virginia, rising up and annually battling with the heavy hitters in the conference. If that’s the case, Pitt needs to continue to search for a coach capable of that level of success. If not, Pitt should hire Schmidt and be happy with a program that wins more than it loses and competes for NCAA bids.

Pitt needs to decide what it wants to be, though, or this search almost assuredly will end up with a coach nobody is happy with a few months after he’s hired.