The NCAA tournament begins Tuesday night with two of the First Four games in Dayton. The winner of the first game, between LIU Brooklyn and Radford, will play Villanova on Thursday at PPG Paints Arena.

I’m thinking the Farce Four is a much more accurate name for the First Four. The expansion from 64 to 68 teams was supposed to enhance the NCAA tournament and increase access to mid-major teams. All it has done, though, is water down the field with more mediocre power conference teams that don’t belong. It also hasn’t increased access to mid-majors. In fact, it has ensured two tournament champions from one-bid leagues are punished.

Adding four teams has simply been a money grab for power conferences. It hasn’t helped the mid-majors get more top teams in the field. It’s ridiculous that teams like Middle Tennessee State and Saint Mary’s are in the NIT while Syracuse, Arizona State, Oklahoma, Texas and UCLA are in the NCAA tournament. Syracuse is awful, and Arizona State and Oklahoma have seemingly not won a game since December. None of those three teams has any business being in the NCAA tournament.

Middle Tennessee State should not be in a field of 64 teams, but there is no question it should be in a field of 68.

Advertise with us

The most egregious thing about the First Four is that it includes four conference champions from low-major leagues. The two losers will be deprived of the true experience of going to the NCAA tournament. Teams that win their conference tournaments shouldn’t be forced to go to Dayton and, in effect, earn their way to a site of the real NCAA tournament.

Players from those one-bid league teams deserve the opportunity to go straight to the site where all of the top seeds are. They deserve the opportunity to line up opposite teams like Duke and North Carolina and take their shot at pulling an upset. They deserve the opportunity to be treated like the big boys, if even for just two days, until they lose.

That experience includes open practices with a lot of fans in the stands and news conferences with major national media members asking questions. There is a buzz in the air the first few days of the NCAA tournament, and it is wrong that two low-major conference champions will miss out on it because they lost in Dayton.

The 68-team NCAA tournament is here to stay and it isn’t ever going back to 64. We know that. The NCAA isn’t going to shrink the field. There have actually been discussions about expanding the field even more, which is absurd. Given that’s the case, let’s hope the NCAA takes a look at the current format and at least improves the First Four format to make it something more reasonably fair.

The first step is to make sure no automatic qualifiers end up in Dayton — ever.

Advertise with us

The eight teams sent to Dayton should all be the final eight at-large teams in the field. The committee also should consider saving the final two spots in the field for the top mid-major teams not already safely in the field. That would spread the wealth a little bit more and reward a team like Middle Tennessee State for having an excellent season.

The First Four is an idea I wish would go away, but it’s here to stay. The NCAA should at least make some changes to the format so that it actually benefits low and mid-majors a little more and makes more sense.