Every year, a few trendy picks for NCAA tournament upsets emerge. You might want to follow the herd and find that popular 10 seed to pencil into your second round.

Don’t do it. At least not for that reason.

While it’s true that some upsets are likelier than others, most lower seeds are still less than 50-50 propositions according to predictive models like the ones produced by FiveThirtyEight.com. For that reason, most popular upset picks have a point of diminishing returns because they’re unlikely to happen but still appearing on many of your competitors’ brackets anyway. Even if you nail the pick, you’re not making up ground on too many people.

Those are the ones where you’re probably better off playing it safe and sticking with the favorite.

Advertise with us

There are also matchups where the predictive models give the lower seed a legitimate chance even though few analysts are hyping them as possible upsets and pushing action onto them. Those are better scoring opportunities because if you nail the picks, it’s more likely most of your competition did not.

With that in mind, here’s a look at overvalued and undervalued upset picks using user pick data from Yahoo! versus predictive data from FiveThirtyEight. (You can read more about the methodology here.)

Overvalued upsets

●No. 7 Texas A&M vs. No. 10 Providence. Yahoo! users: Providence, 55%. FiveThirtyEight odds: Texas A&M, 58%. 

The Aggies struggled with injuries and stumbled to an 0-5 start to Southeastern Conference play. Like South Carolina last year, however, they’re one of the most efficient defensive teams in the nation, which is a good indicator of durability in the tournament. Just ask the Gamecocks, who went from a popular pick to get upset in the opening round to appearing in the Final Four as a No. 7 seed. You might not want to ride A&M that far, but it’s a safer first-round pick than many are giving it credit for.

Advertise with us

●No. 7 Rhode Island vs. No. 10 Oklahoma. Yahoo! users: Oklahoma, 51%. FiveThirtyEight odds: Rhode Island, 58%. 

Trae Young is awesome. The Sooners freshman captivated hoops junkies almost from Day 1 by averaging 27.4 points per game this season. That said, he couldn’t save his team from losing 11 of its last 15 games. The Rams, meanwhile, play a lot of seniors and know how to turn up the defensive intensity themselves. They weren’t immune to late-season struggles either — they lost four of their last five. But the data suggest too many people might be falling in love with Oklahoma’s one-man show.

●No. 8 Seton Hall vs. No. 9 N.C. State. Yahoo! users: N.C. State, 59%. FiveThirtyEight odds: Seton Hall, 63%. 

Most 8/9 games are such toss-ups that they wouldn’t be worth including in a list like this, but the Wolfpack is getting way more love than it probably should. While N.C. State did post a surprising 11-7 record in the rugged ACC, it was vulnerable on the interior beyond 7-foot sophomore Omer Yurtseven. And it just so happens that the Pirates have a double-double machine in center Angel Delgado, who averaged 13.3 points and 11.6 rebounds per game. If the Yahoo! data are any indication, he could do damage to a lot of brackets in addition to his Tobacco Road opponent.

Undervalued upsets

Advertise with us

●No. 6 Miami vs. No. 11 Loyola Chicago. Yahoo! users: Miami, 68%. FiveThirtyEight odds: Miami: 60%

Only three double-digit seeds have better odds of advancing than the Ramblers, but the user popularity isn’t following them. That’s understandable considering this is their first appearance in the tournament since 1985. They’re something of an unknown quantity. That said, Loyola is a veteran-laden team with five players averaging double-figure points per game. That’s the kind of depth that can make a difference at this time of year. Miami finished a strong third in the ACC, so it’s going to be a tough out. But few people seem to be realizing how vulnerable the Hurricanes are.

●No. 4 Auburn vs. No. 13 Charleston. Yahoo! users: Auburn, 90%. FiveThirtyEight odds: Auburn, 80%. 

If you’re looking for a moonshot, give this game a look. The Tigers are a media darling after coming out of nowhere to share the Southeastern Conference’s regular-season crown with Tennessee. Consequently, they’re riding that hype to a pretty strong position in the user data. FiveThirtyEight thinks the Cougars are a 1-in-5 proposition, though, making them easily the strongest No. 13 seed in the field. And with three players averaging more than 17 points per game, they’ve got the horses to put Auburn on its heels early. It’s not an upset pick for the faint of heart, but if you’re feeling brave, you’ll be backing the team with by far the best odds of taking down a top four seed in Round One.

●No. 5 Clemson vs. No. 12 New Mexico State. Yahoo! users: Clemson, 72%. FiveThirtyEight odds: Clemson, 62%. 

Advertise with us

This one will pit two of the nation’s 14 most efficient teams defensively, according to KenPom.com, so it’s likely to be a slug fest. That will play into the Aggies’ hands, as it means the Tigers are unlikely to run and gun their way to a big lead. And if the game is tight late, New Mexico State can turn to one of the most mature players in the tournament, 25-year-old Zach Lofton, who’s averaging 19.8 points per game this season. A 12-seed usually picks off a No. 5 somewhere, and this is probably your best bet.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.