Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. This feature will run each Wednesday, so you have a whole week to submit questions.
Let’s get started:
Matt Dicicco, @DiciccoMatt: With the Pirates resigning hurdle and Huntington are they doomed to be the Bengals of baseball? Occasionally make the playoffs but never win.
Zeise: I think the Pirates would sign up to be the Bengals of baseball, to be honest, right now. The Bengals have gone to the playoffs in six of the last eight seasons and have won three division titles in that time. That is a pretty good record, and without looking it up, I’d be willing to bet they are part of a very small group of teams that have six playoff appearances over the last eight years. That’s the reality to me — people make fun of the Bengals, but they are far better than they used to be and far more successful than a lot of other teams. Baseball playoffs are a crap shoot, and any team has a chance to win. The Pirates can have a breakthrough if they get back to a period of sustained success.

Grandpa Paul, @GrandpaPaul3: Do you agree with the Pirate coach and GM extensions both from a fan and owner perspective?
Zeise: Yes. Both men have done a really good job, despite their faults, in a situation that is tough to win. People can nitpick some of Huntington’s moves and complain about some of Hurdle’s strategy but they have proven they can win under owner Bob Nutting. That doesn’t seem to be an easy thing to do. Consider those two have been together for seven years and have never had a payroll that ranked above No. 23 in MLB. They have managed to win three out of those seven years; that’s pretty impressive.
Read More
Egon Schield Law, @huffakingit: Why is it called a hit and run play when really it's more of a run and hit?
Zeise: That’s a great question because run and hit is more accurate. I tried to do some research on the origins of the phrase “hit and run” and couldn’t come up with much. The play was first used by Baltimore Orioles manager Ned Hanlon in 1894. As for the actual name of the play, well, I can’t help, but if anyone out there is a baseball expert and would like to answer this, email me at pzeise@post-gazette.com

Wesley Miller, Altoona: Paul do you see any way that Pitt can beat Penn State Saturday?
Zeise: I covered Pitt for 13 seasons or so and did not miss one game during that time. My son is a Pitt player, so I’ve been to almost every game of Pitt’s over the past four seasons, too. The only time I ever walked into a stadium for a Pitt game and said there is no chance one team or the other has a chance to win was in 2007 in Morgantown. Pitt was a 28½-point underdog to No. 2 WVU, and it seemed like an awful matchup for the Panthers. I, and everyone else in the press box that day, could not come up with a single scenario that had Pitt winning the game. It just didn’t seem possible, absent of a ridiculous run of turnovers and lucky bounces, and even then it seemed that WVU could still overcome all of that. That’s why I learned to never say never. That being said, Pitt faces long, long odds as Penn State appears to be a machine on offense, and Saquon Barkley is one of the best, if not the best, players in the country. This doesn’t appear to be a good matchup for Pitt, which is young and needs experience.

Trace Franks, Akron: I am huge Steelers fan stuck in Browns country. I have read a lot about the Steelers strengths. They look like a Super Bowl team on paper. What are some of the things that you see will hold them back from winning the Super Bowl?
Zeise: The obvious flaw is the secondary. There are just too many variables: Artie Burns is still learning. William Gay and Coty Sensabaugh are both very average at best. Mike Mitchell is questionable and has been injured for the entire preseason. Haden hasn’t played at a high level in at least two years. That is a lot that has to come together. That could be the undoing of the Steelers, though I think an increased pass rush will help the secondary.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.