Pirates owner Bob Nutting said Monday the Andrew McCutchen situation is complicated because he has been such a good ambassador for the Pirates, but they may have to part ways with him.
“If there were a way to keep him, clearly it would be wonderful to see him in a Pirates uniform,” Nutting said. “He loves Pittsburgh and Maria loves Pittsburgh, and we love Andrew.”
That’s code for, “There is no way Andrew will be here beyond his current contract.”
I would agree that this situation is now complicated, but that’s only because Nutting and Neal Huntington have botched it with the way they have handled McCutchen this offseason.
They should have traded him; instead, they told him he is no longer good enough to play center field. When they couldn’t pull off a trade, they tried to say the trade rumors were part creation and speculation.
“There was more smoke than fire” was Huntington’s exact phrase, but there was an inferno surrounding the Pirates’ attempt to make a deal with the Nationals.
Read More
McCutchen has had a great run here. He has been a great player and was the centerpiece of the Pirates resurrection and return to the playoffs after 20 years of frustration.
But his run is almost over. Nutting knows it, Huntington knows it, the fans know it and McCutchen knows it.
The Pirates are not going to sign a long-term deal with a 30-year old who, by their own metrics and actions of this offseason, is clearly on the decline.
Sure, they keep saying the bat is going to bounce back and the move to right field is going to “add some years to his career,” but they don’t really believe that, and we know they don’t really believe that.
That’s why the Pirates should have made a deal with Washington even if it (as reported) fell apart because the Nationals didn’t want to include top outfield prospect Victor Robles.
They would have gotten a couple of good young pitchers back and opened right field for the eventual promotion of Austin Meadows.
Instead, they are stuck with this awkward and complicated situation where a star player has essentially been demoted and knows he is just playing out the string until his contract expires or he gets traded.
And there are only two things that can happen here:
The first is that McCutchen returns to that MVP-caliber player he has been for much of his career. This is what the Pirates are rooting for because it means he will help them win games and increase his trade value.
But it will also increase what he is worth on the free agent market after next season, and the Pirates are not in the position to pay that kind of money (say $18 to $22 million per year). The pressure would then be on Huntington to trade him, but with only one club option left on his deal after this season, it could be a challenge to get a deal as good as the Nationals were reportedly offering.
The second is he continues to struggle as he did last year both in the field and at the plate and the Pirates have a hard time finding anyone willing to part ways with anyone of significance to get him. They would then be forced to dump him for very little at the trade deadline or just let his contract expire and then not pick up his option.
Obviously, the first scenario is the best case for the Pirates, and the second is a disaster, but it is almost assuredly now a long shot that they get a package as good as the one the Nationals were reportedly offering.
And either way, the Pirates are not going to extend McCutchen because he will either be too expensive or he will be a declining superstar who is still be worth more on the market than they are willing to pay.
That’s why the Pirates needed to make a trade, and why it is their fault this really simple situation has become “complicated.”
Yes, the Pirates do sometimes sign their pending free agents and do so for decent contracts (Russell Martin, Francisco Liriano), but this is not a similar situation to those.
As a result, McCutchen’s Pirates career will probably end in the same clumsy manner of both Neil Walker (a desperate trade that brings back a stiff like Jon Niese) and Pedro Alvarez (let him go for nothing).
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.