Whatever the Pirates get for Andrew McCutchen isn’t going to satisfy a large chunk of the fanbase. We’ve established that.

The reality of the situation, though, is that he’s more likely to get dealt by the minute. The Pirates are the aggressors here, as Stephen J. Nesbitt reported on Wednesday, and specific names are starting to get attached to the speculation. The most interesting one so far comes from Fox Sports’ Ken Rosenthal.

Realistically, Robles probably represents the high-water mark of anything the Pirates would get back for McCutchen. At the end of the season, MLB.com had him as the Nats’ second-best prospect, 10th overall and third among outfielders.

After OPS-ing .864 with Low-A Hagerstown, Robles finished 2016 with High-A Potomac. In 41 games there, he hit .262 with three homers and a .354 OBP. Given his age, that’s impressive.

Advertise with us

At midseason, Baseball America had him as their 13th overall prospect and called him “one of the most dynamic prospects in the game” with “the potential to be a true five-tool player.”

From MLB.com after the season:

Robles is a potentially special talent who showcases all five tools along with elite athleticism on a daily basis. He shows the makings of a plus hit tool, thanks to his compact but explosive swing and feel for using the whole field, and scouts rave about his advanced approach and strike-zone judgment. A plus-plus runner, Robles' speed enables him impact games on the bases as well as in center field, where he has range for days in all directions and arm strength that's among the best in the Minors at the position.

Beyond the athleticism and physical tools, the Nats love Robles' makeup and overall baseball aptitude, both of which make him a leader in the clubhouse. He might still be a few years away from reaching the Major Leagues, but there is reason to be excited about the kind of player he could become.

From The Washington Post in July:

“He’s a very high-energy kid, very hyper,” Vice President of International Operations Johnny DiPuglia said. “He loves to play, to the point where I had to tone him down a little bit because he was so high-energy.”

He also gets hit by enough pitches — 68 in 218 career games — that it concerned the Nationals. Sounds a little like Starling Marte, yeah?

So, in short, Robles sounds like an ideal centerpiece. He’s young, universally well-regarded, with speed and the sort of frame that adds power with age. He’s also far from a sure thing (like any prospect) and at least a few years away from the majors.

Advertise with us

Mix in a decent starter like Gio Gonzalez or some of the Nats’ mid-level starting prospects (ie, “not Lucas Giolito”) and you’ve probably got the start of a return that wouldn’t directly lead to angry mobs converging on the North Shore.

Instead, it’ll be depressed mobs converging on Twitter and talk radio, where they’ll wonder how a 98-win team has punted on a season and traded away an MVP for a 19-year-old over the course of a calendar year. That’s better, right?

Sean Gentille: sgentille@post-gazette.com and Twitter: @seangentille.