Pirates manager Clint Hurdle announced Sunday that Andrew McCutchen will no longer be the team’s center fielder and that he will be replaced this season by Starling Marte.

That was not a surprise. Hurdle and general manager Neal Huntington made it pretty clear at the end of last season that this was going to happen.

When I first heard about it, I thought it was great news — until I read the fine print and realized McCutchen was moving to right field, not Marte’s position, left field. I loved it when it I thought it was a straight exchange of McCutchen to left and Marte to center. I’m not so sure I love it as much now that all three outfielders are going to be changing positions.

Hurdle said in a statement that this move would help the Pirates maximize their outfield production and said all three players are on board and are happy to help the team improve defensively. I know that’s the plan, I’m just not so sure moving Polanco from right to left is the best way to achieve a better defensive outfield.

Advertise with us

McCutchen’s move is not surprising given how much his defense has slipped over the past three seasons, and I do think Marte in center will make the Pirates a better defensive team. But I’m not sure I like the idea of moving all three outfielders around, and I wonder if the Pirates are overthinking this one just a bit too much.

Polanco is an amazing athlete. He is slowly but surely becoming a star at the plate but still was trying to get completely comfortable in right field. Think about the number of times he made plays not because he got a good jump or played an angle right but because he has freakish athletic ability and a 6-foot-6 frame with a long wingspan. At times last season he still looked lost out in right and still misplayed or misjudged balls, and he wasn’t always able to make up for it with his speed or ability to be seemingly 11 feet tall when he stretched out his glove. Now they’re are asking him to move to left, which, given the size of left field at PNC Park and that “notch” in left-center, is a tough position to play.

I know why they’re putting Polanco in left. I get it, at least on paper. He is faster than McCutchen, so he can cover more ground in that huge left field. He also has a better arm than McCutchen and can theoretically hold hitters to singles even when they hit one in the corner. That throw from the corner to second base was a Marte specialty, and now that they have Marte in center, he should be able to cut down more runners at home than McCutchen did. But I worry about Polanco adapting to a new position, his ability to pick up balls off the bat at a different angle and that taking his arm out of right will mean a lot more runners going from first to third on balls hit to right.

Let’s also not forget the Pirates will play 81 games in parks that don’t have a huge left field, which is why many teams choose to put their best arm in right to make that long throw to third. McCutchen still is fast enough to cover ground in left field, and while he isn’t likely to make as many throws to second to hold runners to singles, his arm is strong enough to throw runners out at home from left. He also is enough of a veteran to make the move and do so seamlessly, so the Pirates are correct to believe he can make the move without much of an issue.

Ultimately, the key to this move will be Polanco, who was moved from center to right in the minors to prepare for his promotion, and whether he is able to adapt quickly to left. I think he can, but it might come with some growing pains. I’m not sure he will ever be the polished outfielder Marte is, so this move isn’t without risk. If he adapts, the Pirates will have an excellent outfield. If he doesn’t, it could be a disaster because there’s a lot more room for balls to fall in left at PNC Park than there are in right.

Advertise with us

Of course, McCutchen’s defense was only half of his problem last season. He also struggled at the plate, which begs the question: If he struggles early again, does this position move suggest the Pirates will also have no issue moving him down in the lineup?

That’s a different discussion for a different day, I suppose.

Pirates start migration to Bradenton