A lot of people say there has never been a college football championship won on the first Wednesday of February so the hype surrounding national signing day is ridiculous.

I agree with the second part, mostly because I’m becoming a crotchety old man and could live without all the bells and whistles, hat ceremonies and slick shows produced these days. The first statement, though, while technically accurate, is absolutely false.

Every college football championship has been won on a signing day because teams that win generally have the best players. Oh sure, there are exceptions to every rule. There are 5-star busts and 2-star superheroes, but for the most part the teams that win signing day end up winning on the field.

I can’t help but laugh when people, mostly older, crotchety sports reporters — hey, wait, didn’t I just describe myself as that? — dismiss rankings from scouting services, saying they don’t know what they’re talking about. These people find the Le’Veon Bells of the world (a 2-star recruit who turned out to be pretty good) and use it as definitive proof that signing day is overrated and recruiting rankings are meaningless. My answer to that is always this: Give me a roster of 85 5-star recruits against your roster of 85 2-star recruits, and I assure you my roster would win 90 times out of 100, if not all 100.

Advertise with us

Don’t believe me? Take a look at the Rivals team rankings for the past four or five years and notice how many of the same teams who are annually in the top 25 in the recruiting rankings are also annually in the actual top 25. Again, there are exceptions, but for the most part there is a reason it isn’t a coincidence that Alabama is almost always No. 1 or No. 2 in the recruiting rankings and has become the most dominant program in the country. It certainly isn’t an exact science, and there are some flaws in the methodology — too much weight given to the size of a class — but the reality is, in general, the recruiting rankings are a very good guide as to which teams are doing the best in recruiting.

I could point to some important recruiting wins for Pitt in the 2006 and 2007 classes that led to the teams that should have won (but choked away) the Big East title in both 2009 and 2010. Pitt under Dave Wannstedt was ranked first in the Big East in recruiting almost every year from 2006-2009, and it isn’t a coincidence those teams produced by far the most NFL players of any team in the league in that period.

Here are three good articles that really break down these numbers more and explain why national signing day is such a huge factor in determining college football program success. The numbers, facts and data back up my point that national signing day, when stripping away all the unnecessary showbiz nonsense, is probably the biggest factor in a team winning a championship.

I hate what this day has become. I hate the ego involved with it from coaches and prospects. But I understand why it’s such a huge day for programs and why calling it overrated is flat-out silly.

Recruiting matters, period.