Steelers assistant coach Joey Porter certainly celebrated the team’s big playoff win against the Dolphins in grand fashion Sunday night because any party that ends with a ride in a cop car must have been good.
If Porter were a player, this column would be a little different, but he isn’t. He’s a coach, and therein lies the problem. Coaches are and should be held to a higher standard than their players. As such, what to do with Porter should be the easiest decision Mike Tomlin, Kevin Colbert or Art Rooney make this week leading up to Sunday’s game against the Kansas City Chiefs.
Porter should be suspended without pay for this week. The details of this case, unlike with a player, shouldn’t matter. It also shouldn’t matter that Porter isn’t charged with a felony and that it doesn’t sound like he is guilty of much more than getting drunk and acting foolish at the door of a bar. We don’t need details to know that Porter was drunk in public, acted up and ended up in jail. That’s not the way Steelers coaches — or coaches of any team — should conduct themselves.
This isn’t a court of law and there’s no players’ association protection, so innocent until proven guilty doesn’t apply to how the Steelers should treat this incident. Porter should be disciplined for using poor judgement and embarrassing the Steelers. Porter is no longer a 22-year old fresh out of college, so there is no acceptable excuse for this. He is 39, finished his playing career, has a family of his own and is a coach, which means he is supposed to be a mentor and role model for young men. If he was a player, I’d still lean towards a suspension, but it isn’t nearly as black and white because the standard of conduct for players is not as high as it is for coaches, nor should it be.
Players absolutely need to be held accountable for their actions, but a player who gets a little drunk and unruly at a bar is probably a situation that should be judged on a case-by-case basis. The actual details of the incident would then really matter as would the facts about how many times the player in question had been in trouble off the field. That’s players, though, and Porter is a coach.
I don’t think Porter needs to be fired. This isn’t a felony, and Porter has been a big part of an organization that has a track record of giving second chances and trying to help people through rough times. But he can’t coach this week. He needs to have time off to re-evaluate his life choices and understand just how quickly he can lose a nice career by acting like a drunken 20-something on a Friday night on the South Side.
Read More
Porter faces charges of assault, resisting arrest, trespassing and disorderly conduct. That isn’t and shouldn’t be relevant. The mere fact he was charged is enough for the Steelers to take action. He is guilty of bad judgment, embarrassing the Steelers and providing a distraction at a time when the team is trying to win its most important football games of the year. That’s why a one-week suspension seems more than appropriate. It makes clear that the Steelers won’t tolerate this but it also doesn’t blow a guy out of the water for what is, at the end of the day, likely to be knocked down to a summary offense that results in him paying a small fine.
If nothing else, the Steelers should suspend Porter for his own good because a week off might be enough for him to re-evaluate some of the choices he makes in his personal life and could spare him from being involved in further incidents with far greater consequences and/or charges in the future.
Porter is a high-profile member of a high-profile organization, and if the Steelers don’t quickly take action they’re sending a very bad message about what they expect from their employees and what they are willing to tolerate.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.