Frank Coonelly was asked by a fan at PirateFest last weekend whether the Pirates truly are interested in winning. The team president’s answer was an emphatic “yes,” and he even called it insulting that people would even ask.

“I’m so tired of that narrative,” Coonelly said. “As these gentlemen [manager Clint Hurdle and general manager Neal Huntington] can explain to you, as my wife sitting out there can explain to you, there’s nobody more competitive than the three men up on this stage. And there is nothing more that anyone can do for you — not for us — than to win a World Series championship here in Pittsburgh. That’s why we do what we do. That’s why I get up every single morning — to do that.

“It’s not about profiting. It’s about putting together a winning team, allocating resources to the major league team to win a championship here in Pittsburgh. I get it. It’s a long winter. I can’t wait until spring comes. We need — in the media and otherwise — to talk about a lot of things. But the narrative that we don’t care about winning is just flat wrong. It’s offensive, too, but that’s another matter.”

I believe Coonelly and Huntington want nothing more than to win a World Series. I do not believe owner Bob Nutting places winning a World Series at a high priority, and I’m starting to think it isn’t even really on his radar.

Advertise with us

There’s an old saying that goes “hope is not a strategy,” and that’s why the 2016 Pirates were doomed. Just trying to get to the playoffs and seeing what happens is ridiculous. The teams that advance to the World Series aren’t lucky; they’re good enough to win in the playoffs. The Pirates have been good in the regular season, but the idea that they’re good enough to win the World Series because they won 98 games is silly. You know how I know? Because they didn’t even come close. Teams good enough to win the World Series don’t get blown out in the wild-card game at home.

Coonelly answered with conviction, but it’s insulting that he doesn’t think it’s a fair question after the decisions that have been made since the end of the 2015 season. Over the past 14 months or so, the Pirates have not acted like a team that prioritizes winning the World Series. They won 98 games in 2015 and got blown out in the National League wild-card game. That was the third year in a row they made the playoffs and didn’t get past the division series. That should fuel an organization that places winning the World Series at its highest priority to push a little more.

The Pirates lost significant players from 2015 and did so for monetary reasons, selling the idea that they were giving themselves financial flexibility and building a foundation for the future. Maybe that’s OK. There’s nothing wrong with putting a competitive team on the field that can win a few wild cards yet is a great business model and always operating at a profit. I don’t begrudge anyone from making a profit, and I would agree with Coonelly that Huntington has done a masterful job of identifying talent and finding productive players at deals that make sense and fit within the budget.

But here is what Nutting needs to do between now and the start of next season: Don’t send your underlings to feed the masses about wanting to win, claiming these narratives are false and that winning 98 games a few years ago shows how much you want to win. Just go prove it.

I don’t expect the Pirates to spend $200 million. I don’t expect them to operate like a big-market team or get reckless and start overspending. But an organization that places winning a World Series as its highest priority should stretch itself from time to time, spending a little more than its comfort level and trading a couple of top prospects.

Advertise with us

Until that happens, this question will continue to be asked of Pirates management by fans and the media, and the only insulting thing about it will be the tired narrative from Coonelly and Huntington. People have been paying attention, and now that Coonelly has called them idiots for thinking that winning a World Series isn’t the highest priority for the team’s owner, they’re going to pay even closer attention.

In the meantime, the Cardinals spent big money on an outfielder, even though they’re a budget-conscience team. But they understand what it takes to win a World Series because they’ve done it and understood they weren’t good enough so they stretched to get better.

Hopefully Bob Nutting was paying attention. However, I’ve seen no evidence that he’s willing to stretch on any front to try to win a World Series. Teams that want to win big are willing to do what it takes. They don’t try to do the minimum and then hope the ball bounces their way once they do.