The four teams that should have an inside track to the College Football Playoff heading into the final weekend of the regular season and conference championships are Alabama, Clemson, Washington and either Penn State or Wisconsin.
Period.
I know, Ohio State’s body of work is very strong, with wins against three top 10 teams and a bit of a fluke on the road against a top 10 team for its only loss. And yes, I know, Michigan has wins against Penn State and Wisconsin and one against Colorado as well. All of that is wonderful, and Urban Meyer and Jim Harbaugh deserve a pat on the back. One of them should get a nice consolation prize of playing in the Rose Bowl.
But unless Clemson or Washington loses — both play ranked opponents in conference championships — neither Ohio State nor Michigan deserves to be in the playoff if the selection committee wants to maintain credibility.
I keep hearing people say it has to be the best four teams, and I agree to an extent, but that is such a subjective standard. There has to be more definitive criteria to figure out which team belongs and which does not.
Watching the games the past three weeks, there is a strong case to be made that USC is one of the four best teams right now, but the Trojans have three losses that came early in the season before they settled some quarterback issues. I have no doubt that if USC played Clemson right now it would have a great chance to win. The Trojans beat Washington on the road a few weeks ago. But you can’t discount those three losses. They happened and are a part of the objectivity of figuring out which teams deserve to be in the playoffs.
Ohio State, which should be the first non-champion considered, should only be considered if a couple of the champions lose. Penn State, if it were to beat Wisconsin, would be 11-2 by beating Ohio State and Wisconsin and winning the best conference in football. Should they win, the Nittany Lions should be in the playoff field. They’re already a top 10 team and will have added another top 10 win and conference championship to their resume. There is no way the committee should even consider taking Ohio State over the champion — Penn State or Wisconsin — of the Buckeyes’ own conference.
Washington is 11-1 and set to play in the Pac-12 Conference Championship against another top 10 team, Colorado. If the Huskies win, they should be in ahead of Ohio State as well.
USC is the best team in the Pac-12, and Ohio State is the best team in the Big Ten, but neither did enough to make it into their own conference’s playoff, so why should they get to go to the national playoffs?
If Clemson loses, there is a very strong case to be made for Ohio State over Virginia Tech, but I’d still lean towards the Big 12 champ. Regardless if it’s Oklahoma or Oklahoma State, it will be a top 10 team with only two losses. That’s why I’d even say Colorado should get a look ahead of Ohio State if they beat Washington because Colorado is a top 10 team and may add a top 10 win and conference championship to its resume.
Maybe I’m putting too much weight on winning a conference championship, but again, if winning a conference championship doesn’t matter, then disband all the conferences. That will never happen, so the playoff committee should strongly consider making sure that winning a conference championship is treated as something special because it’s hard to pull off. How do I know this? Ohio State and USC were the two best teams in their respective conferences and neither could pull it off.
Any team that enters conference championship weekend in the top 10 and wins should be ahead of any other non-conference champion regardless of how many good wins it has. That means Penn State, Wisconsin, Colorado, Oklahoma, Oklahoma State, Washington and Clemson should all be ahead of Ohio State in the minds of the committee.
I’m not saying that’s what will happen — we all know Ohio State probably is going to get into the field — but that’s what should happen if conference championships are as important as the committee claims they are.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.