The Detroit Red Wings won back-to-back Stanley Cups in 1997-98, and that was the last time there was a repeat champion in the NHL. Taking that a step further, since then, only twice — the 2001 New Jersey Devils and 2009 Red Wings — has the defending champion even reached the Stanley Cup final.

It’s hard to repeat as champions of any sport, but that’s especially true in the NHL era of the salary cap and free agency. If you look at the league before 1995, the year free agency was adopted, repeating as Stanley Cup champs was actually a common occurrence.

The Flyers did it in 1974 and 1975, the Canadiens won four in a row (1976-79), as did the Islanders (1980-83), and the Oilers won in 1984 and 1985 and again in 1987 and 1988. The Penguins won 1991 and 1992 and were favored to win it again in 1993. They won the Presidents’ Trophy with 119 points that year but were stunned by the Islanders in the second round of the playoffs ending their quest for a three-peat.

Only one team since those Penguins won back-to-back titles about a quarter of a century ago has repeated as champs, so recent history suggests the odds are against it happening this year. However, these Penguins appear to be about as well-equipped to pull it off as any others since the 1998 Red Wings.

Advertise with us

The team, for the most part, returned intact — including two Stanley Cup-winning goaltenders — and still has an excellent blend of youth and experience. The main difference is the rookies and younger guys. Those players have more experience and understand what it takes to win a Cup.

Coach Mike Sullivan installed his system on the fly when he was hired 28 games into last season, and it fit their personnel. Now, they’re more comfortable in it and understand exactly what he expects from them. Sidney Crosby has a concussion, but based on his own words, it appears to be a short-term injury and he will be back soon. So, for the most part, the stars are healthy and appear ready to go. The Penguins are built on speed and probably still are the fastest team in the NHL player-for-player. Their offensive ability and relentless attacking style will make it a nightmare to deal with on most nights. There is absolutely no question they have the ability to and are good enough to repeat as Stanley Cup champions. They are, no doubt, the best team in the East.

Some might say they should repeat as Stanley Cup champions, and I agree, they absolutely should repeat as Stanley Cup champions ...

... but they won’t.

History doesn’t lie, and there are some very clear reasons why teams don’t often repeat in any sport, but especially in the NHL.

Advertise with us

First off, there are probably six or seven teams legitimately good enough on paper to win in every league, every year, but only one team actually wins it. Often that’s because there is a little bit of luck involved in winning a championship. I’m not saying champions are lucky, I’m saying that in order to go from one of the best teams in the league to the last one standing you need a lot of things to break your way. When I look at last year’s Penguins, every move seemed to work out, starting with firing Mike Johnston and hiring Sullivan. The good fortune of that move and many others is very hard to duplicate.

Other teams with talent are now hungrier than the Penguins. They will be gunning for the Penguins, and the Penguins won’t sneak up on anyone this year.

The Penguins clearly are one of the best teams, if not the best team, in the NHL, and they are more than capable of winning the Stanley Cup. But the best team doesn’t always win, and that will be the case again this year.

Whether it’s Tampa, Washington, Dallas or Chicago, some team not named the Penguins will win the Stanley Cup this year, and it won’t shock me if — like 1993 — they lose in the playoffs to an inferior team.

That’s reality in the modern NHL, and, as always, I deal in reality.