Pavel Datsyuk accomplished a lot during his 14 seasons in the NHL.

He helped Detroit win the Stanley Cup in 2002 and 2008. Earned three Selke trophies as the league’s best defensive forward. Picked up four Lady Byng trophies for his gentlemanly and effective play.

And was part of a team that nearly managed what has become all but impossible: Winning the Cup in consecutive seasons.

His Red Wings beat the Penguins in six games in the 2008 final, then took the Penguins to seven games before losing the following season.

Advertise with us

That’s the closest any club has come to claiming back-to-back Cup titles since Detroit did it in 1997 and 1998.

The Penguins, coming off a six-game victory against the San Jose Sharks in the 2016 final, are the next team to have a chance to match that feat.

Precedent makes it clear that will be extremely difficult, and Datsyuk, who has returned to Russia to play, believes there’s no mystery about why.

“There are lots of good teams,” he said recently. “That’s why it’s tough to win.”

Parity, however, isn’t the only issue. The salary cap introduced in 2005 makes it almost impossible to hoard good players, and the physical demands of winning the first Cup mitigate against doing it again 12 months later.

Advertise with us

Especially when there is another high-stakes competition, such as an Olympics or a World Cup, shoehorned between those playoff runs.

“You need so many things to go right to win,” Penguins center Sidney Crosby said. “Obviously, a team has to be at the top of its game and, on top of that, you have to stay healthy and you need some bounces along the way.”

Based on the past couple of decades, that is a tough trifecta to hit.

Recognizing long odds isn’t the same as meekly accepting them, though.

“Just because nobody’s done it doesn’t mean you can’t,” Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford said. “That’s the message we have to go by.”

Advertise with us

GM knows the deal

This won’t the first time Rutherford has tried to win back-to-back titles.  His first attempt didn’t go well.

As general manager in Carolina, he built a team that captured the Cup in 2006. The Hurricanes were not able to repeat the following season. Their 40-34-8 record wasn’t even good enough to get them into the playoffs.

Of course, as Rutherford was quick to point out, that was a different team, in a different time.

“The hurdles there [were] different from here,” he said. “We have the resources to keep much of our team intact.

Advertise with us

“In Carolina, we lost key players. [Mark] Recchi and [Doug] Weight, and guys like that. I can’t compare the two.”

Familiar cast can help

Significant personnel turnover in the offseason is a given for most NHL teams, particularly those that have won a Cup.

Free agents are looking to be paid for their contribution to the team’s success, and there’s only so much room under the salary cap.

But the Penguins, through a confluence of sound management and good luck, have returned virtually their entire team. Defenseman Ben Lovejoy, right winger Beau Bennett and goalie Jeff Zatkoff were the only players to depart via free agency over the summer.

Advertise with us

“The fact we have a good chunk of our team back … hopefully, that’s something that can help us,” Crosby said.

Rutherford made a conscious decision to not overhaul his roster — “I like the fact that we could keep as many guys as we have” — but acknowledged that teams occasionally go stale if there isn’t enough turnover.

“If we need fresh blood, we’ll deal with it,” he said. “I like where we’re at now, but we’ll have to watch to see if, in fact, that carries over.”

Not surprisingly, Rutherford’s players see that roster stability as a plus.

“We really like our group, and we’re pretty fortunate we have almost the entire group back,” center Matt Cullen said.

Advertise with us

Crosby feels the benefits of limited turnover on the roster should outweigh any negatives.

“I’ve seen both,” he said. “I’ve seen a dramatic change in [the number of returning] players and that has its challenges, and then I’ve seen where you barely lose anyone.

“That has its advantages, as far as everyone understanding their role and making sure you’re on the same page, right from the start, understanding what the coach is expecting.”

Defenseman Kris Letang noted that, while the Penguins roster didn’t change much over the summer, it hasn’t been intact for all that long.

“We only came all together at the [trade] deadline,” he said. “We had what, like a month-and-a-half and then two months of playoffs to glue together? Imagine what one year [together] can do.”

Advertise with us

The fatigue factor

Marian Hossa knows all about playing for the Stanley Cup.

He was was with the Penguins when they lost to Detroit in the 2008 final and on the Red Wings squad the Penguins beat a year later.

After those disappointments, Hossa moved on to Chicago, where he won the Stanley Cup in 2010, 2013 and 2015.

He has appeared in 19 or more playoff games in six of the past nine seasons, so he’s familiar with the grind that goes with competing for a championship. And, more to the point, its lingering effects.

Advertise with us

“It’s not easy, because you go through the extra two months [of playoff games] when you win the first Cup, then it’s such a short summer,” he said. “Then you go again, and teams are ready for you.”

The Penguins were a popular choice to win the Cup in 2010, but Jaroslav Halak’s goaltending and the collective fatigue rooted in their playoff runs the previous two years, as well as the 2010 Olympics, helped to make it possible for Montreal to upset them in the second round.

“I would say there was a little fatigue that set in,” Crosby said. “That being said, it’s something a lot of teams have had to deal with. It’s just one of those things that you try to manage and be aware of.”

Of course, there are variables that can’t be predicted, such as the concussion with which Crosby was diagnosed Monday.

Ultimately, then, it wouldn’t be prudent for the Penguins to enter the season focused on winning another Cup. Their goal is simply to elevate their game to the level required to win a championship, and hope they are healthy and lucky enough to get into a position to do it.

Advertise with us

“We have to look at it the same way we would any other year,” Crosby said. “Make sure we get a good start and we’ve got to build and get better as the year goes along.”

Dave Molinari: dmolinari@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.