Gregory Polanco has become a superstar in front of our very own eyes.
He’s the new face of the franchise, even if people don’t want to admit it. He has become the team’s best player, and at the ripe old age of 24, he is just now starting to scratch the surface of his potential.
It wasn’t that long ago that Andrew McCutchen was the young, up-and-coming superstar of the team and he quickly became the face of the franchise. Economic realities seem to be pointing in the direction of McCutchen being traded before the end of his contract — perhaps as soon as this offseason if the right deal pops up. It would be a shame if the Polanco era comes and goes, like the McCutchen appears to be, without the Pirates winning a World Series or even playing for one.
Polanco, who leads the Pirates in home runs, RBIs, slugging percentage and OPS is signed through 2023 — with club options in 2022 and 2023. That means the Pirates will have one of the best outfielders in baseball in his prime for at least the next seven seasons, if they choose. They also have some very good young pitchers in place for a long time. Unlike when McCutchen got started — and the team was in the midst of an ownership change, front office shake-up and a lot of losing — Polanco has begun his career on a winning team that has a lot of hope for the future.
The Pirates, at least so far, haven’t been able to get over the top in the McCutchen era — I think they could have taken a few more risks the past two years to try, but it’s debatable — but if they fail in the next seven years, it’s a crime.
There’s a lot that has to fall into place in order to win a championship. There’s a little bit of luck involved, and the other teams have something to do with it, too. The Pirates have a good plan and their slow and steady approach has helped them become one of the best franchises in baseball. There’s also the Bill Cowher theory of if you knock on the door enough times, eventually it will open. That’s why it took him 15 years to win the Super Bowl. But all of that is mostly pie in the sky. Championship teams are championship teams because they go after it when they’re close enough to smell it.
Read More
The Pirates aren’t close this year, and frankly, the best thing that could happen is avoiding slopping into another wild card berth. That would give them a false sense of how close they are to winning a championship. Next year and the year after, though, given what they already have locked up in terms of talent, the Pirates have a shot to make a long, deep run into the playoffs. But they’re going to have to, at some point, make a commitment to going outside of their comfort zone financially once or twice in order to get over the top. That doesn’t mean doing what the Cubs do, making $250 million in acquisitions in the offseason, but it does mean going to get a real pitcher — not a reclamation project — to solidify a rotation that is already pretty close to being complete. It may mean trading a top prospect or two at the trade deadline to bring a player back to fill a need and help put the team in position to win a division title.
Those are things the Pirates have been reluctant to do. Although you can’t predict how any moves are going to turn out, you also can’t be conservative in every move because there is often no reward unless there is first a risk taken.
Polanco appears to be a once-in-a-generation talent who can carry the load offensively and defensively. The Pirates understand this, which is why they refused to trade Polanco when he was still a prospect, and that’s why they worked so hard to get him locked up long term.
The Pirates need to capitalize on a superstar like him and make sure they aren’t looking up near the end of his time here — like they are with McCutchen — still in search of a World Series ring. The plan is in place, and the next great star is in place. Now, it’s up to the Pirates to make sure they leave no stone unturned in trying to give him opportunities to lead them to the promised land.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.