The Pirates are 62-60 this season.
Since All-Star break, they are 16-17; in their last 30 games they are 15-15; 10-9 since the trade deadline; and they are 5-5 in their last 10 games.
They are seventh (out of 15 teams) in team batting average, ninth in the National League in runs scored and ninth in the NL in OPS.
They are eighth in the NL in team ERA, 11th in the NL in batting average against and 10th in the NL in WHIP.
If you look at the NL leaders, there are no Pirates in the top 10 in hits, home runs, RBI, batting average or OPS, and they have no pitchers in the top 10 in innings pitched, ERA, WHIP or wins.
At what point are we allowed to just concede this is a painfully average team by just about every measure and stop trying to over-analyze the peaks and valleys of this season?
Read More
At what point do fanboys and Huntington haters unite and concede that these numbers do not lie, that there is a large enough sample size to suggest that this is a team that has strengths but also has some glaring weaknesses?
You know what teams go 5-1 on the West Coast against two of the best teams in baseball, then return home and promptly lose four in a row, including getting swept by a team they are competing with for a wild-card spot who is playing without its best player?
It really isn’t a mystery. That’s what teams that are average or slightly better than average do.
I don’t know if this team is going to make it into the playoffs or not, but to be honest, that has a lot more to do with what the teams around them do as opposed to what they do.
I mean, they have 40 games left, and if you look at all of the numbers I have posted, isn’t it reasonable to think they are probably going to go somewhere between 22-18 and 18-22 in those games?
And even if they go 22-18, that leaves them at 84-78, which would be about right considering what this team is this year — slightly above average.
My guess is 84-85 wins will fall just short of the wild card, but if the Pirates can get a little bit hot and get to, say, 86-87 wins, that may be enough.
But again, that likely has a lot more to do with the Giants, Dodgers, Marlins and Cardinals than the Pirates, because those teams could also get hot and maybe two of them get to 89-90 wins and then it becomes a moot point.
I don’t think that this is a bad team, but I also don’t think it is a great team. I think it is a slightly above average team, and that’s why I don’t get giddy when they win a few games, nor do I get outraged when they lose a few.
This was supposed to be a bridge year to a bright future with all the younger players. That’s the way the team was put together in the offseason, that’s what the Pirates’ trade-deadline moves suggested and that’s how they have played.
Given that, the next time the Pirates win a few games in a row or lose a few games in a row, don’t get excited or angry. Just realize that if you give the team a few days, it will do the opposite.
I know this because that’s what mostly average teams do.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.