Imagine the Cubs get hot again, or the Giants keep rolling in the second half of the season and make a run at, say, 110 wins and the best overall record in baseball. Then, they cruise to the World Series. Their reward will be a Game 7 on the road against a team with a worse record.
That is the idiocy of this ridiculous All-Star Game format that once again could come into play in a much bigger way than it should.
The American League won Tuesday night, which means an AL team will get home-field advantage in the World Series.
I don’t want to rant or be that angry guy, but there are a few pet peeves that hit me like fingernails on a chalkboard. The ridiculous “55-foot timeout” in the NBA and the even more ridiculous “live-ball timeout” are two of them. The extra-point format in the NFL is another. Referees swallowing the whistle for the final period and overtime of playoff games in the NHL is yet another. But none cooks my grits more than this nonsense where an exhibition game determines home-field advantage for the World Series.
I’ve heard all of the arguments about how rare a Game 7 is in the World Series — though the home team wins most of the time when it does — but that isn’t meaningful. Nor is it meaningful that home-field advantage used to be determined by the year as the two leagues alternated.
The system is better now than it was, but the fact it used to be dumber is not relevant. You don’t fix something unless you fix it the right way. Creating a bad system that is slightly better than an awful system is not fixing things. This is so simple, too. Determine the home team for the World Series by the best record, like they do in the Stanley Cup Final and NBA Finals. This way, the team that has the home-field advantage has actually earned it by having the best season of the two teams still standing.
Read More
If MLB is going to determine home-field advantage by the All-Star Game results, start playing it like a real game. If I was managing, I’d play my best eight position players, pick my best pitcher and basically play it like a regular-season game. That might mean 20 guys get a free vacation to sit on the bench, but that wouldn’t be my concern. I’d be concerned about winning a game. That would mean the practice of using pitchers for an inning and position players for one at-bat wouldn’t happen.
If I have, for instance, Jake Arrieta from last August, why wouldn’t I let him throw eight innings, then pick my best closer to finish the game? And why wouldn’t I want, say, Kris Bryant and Bryce Harper to get four or five at-bats? I’m sure MLB would hate it because the whole thing is a marketing event anyway, but it’s the system the league created and should have to live with.
You can’t have it both ways. Either the game counts and teams should play to win, or the game is a fan event and both teams should use 30 players like they did Tuesday night. As it is now, it’s the equivalent of counting preseason football games towards the regular-season standings.
It’s simple. Either change the rule or change the format of the All Star Game to play like a real game. As it is now, it just isn’t working.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.