Yesterday, Antonio Brown probably was on his phone with his agent, with a little music in the background and doing a little dance and in his best Rod Tidwell voice saying “Show me the money!”
If he wasn’t, he should have been. Brown had to love the news that Seattle signed Doug Baldwin to a 4-year, $46 million extension that includes $24 million guaranteed.
For those counting at home, that’s an average of $11.5 million per year for Doug Baldwin, a good receiver but not in the class of Brown.
The Steelers have often balked at signing receivers to big money deals, but the Rooneys better get out their check book before walking into any meeting about a contract extension for Brown.
If Baldwin is worth $11.5 million per year, and Alshon Jeffrey is worth $14.6 million, what is Brown worth?
Here is a list of the top paid receivers in the NFL, which shows that the highest paid guy right now is the Bengals’ A.J. Green.
Green signed a 4-year, $60 million deal last year, and that included $26.75 million guaranteed the day he signed it. If I’m Brown, I don’t take a dime less.
That’s a lot of money for a receiver, I know, but the Steelers have no choice. They have to pay it because Brown is their best player.
More importantly, do you trust Martavis Bryant to stay out of trouble enough to blossom into that superstar receiver? And we don’t know enough about Sammie Coates, yet, either.
Regardless, you could make a very strong argument that Brown is the best player in the NFL.
Some would be hesitant to sign Brown because of his age (27) with two seasons (including the upcoming one) left on his current contract, which means he will be 28 going on 29 when he hits the free agent market.
That might seem like over the hill, but, at least according to this study, elite receivers have their prime years from ages 26 to 32.
That means Brown, with a four-year deal similar to Green’s, will be 29, 30, 31 and 32. Quite frankly, the Steelers should just rip up the final year of his current deal, so he’d be 28, 29, 30 and 31 in the four years of his new deal.
There’s a question whether the Steelers should sign Brown or Le’Veon Bell to a big extension, and I don’t even think it’s close.
Bell is a great running back, but the average shelf life of running backs is the shortest in the NFL among positions (about 3.11 years).
There’s plenty of evidence to show that good, or productive, running backs are almost a dime a dozen in the era of passing.
I don’t want to minimize the value of a star running back, but teams have proven they can win with a running back by committee.
In general, I agree that putting big money into a receiver can be tricky, but Brown is a special talent and a guy who changes his team dramatically.
Bell is a great player, but the Steelers probably can’t afford to keep him and Brown if they take their market values.
The Steelers have an elite quarterback, so they should be focused on maintaining their passing game. That means they need to sign Brown to a four-year deal.
Ben Roethlisberger may not have four years left at that elite level, but he will play that long. Even when he is a notch below what he is now, he still will be very good.
However, he will need weapons, and the most dangerous weapon in the NFL is Brown. That means the Steelers need to show Brown (not Bell) the money.
The Steelers are good at knowing when to say no to big extensions and have proven they will pay the money to keep their best players in the fold.
That means they will do everything in their power to keep Brown around — even though, as the market for elite receivers continues to rise, so does Brown’s price tag.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.