The Pirates have been active at the trade deadline in recent years, and while they have not made the big splashy moves that fans desire, they have tried to find pieces to add to improve their chances of making the playoffs.
This year, they should again be active, but not looking to add players; rather, looking to trade Mark Melancon and maybe a couple other players to try and get better for the future.
The Pirates may or may not be good enough to earn one of the National League’s two wild card spots, but they aren’t good enough to win the World Series, the NLCS or even the NL Central, and they aren’t a couple of moves away from changing that.
Now you want to tell me they are going to offer the farm to try and get a stud starting pitcher or two and a home-run hitting bat, well, maybe that’s a different conversation. But the Pirates won’t do that. That’s not how they operate.
That’s why the best course of action — especially since the Pirates conceded this would be a “bridge year” by their offseason moves and the words of the general manager — is to sell at the deadline, get some prospects and also create some room on the roster for your next wave of players.
And it wouldn’t be giving up on the season because they still may be good enough to slop together a wild-card run, especially if the young pitchers come up and are as good as advertised.
Read More
Melancon is the most logical player to move because he is a free agent at the end of the season and the Pirates aren’t likely to sign him, as they were not exactly enthused about paying his $10 million price tag for this year.
He is one of the best closers in the game, and at the trading deadline, the Pirates should be able to get something from a contender for him even though he would be a straight rental for someone.
The Pirates could then make Tony Watson their closer for the rest of the season and look to rebuild the bullpen for next year, and that is an area at which Neal Huntington has been pretty good.
Melancon is the obvious and best chip the Pirates have, but they should also look to try and get something for Matt Joyce, Jonathan Niese and even David Freese.
I’m not saying teams are going to line up for any of those three, but there would be a market for them, especially from contenders who are looking for some punch off the bench and/or starting pitching depth.
Joyce is a left-handed hitter with some power who is hitting around .300 and has been very good as a pinch hitter. He might be attractive to a contender looking to bolster their bench or because of injury, desperate for an outfielder.
Freese is only here for a year, and while his value may be higher to the Pirates as a bench player than as a trade chip, he is hitting well and has pedigree of being a good playoff performer.
And Niese might bring something in return from a contender desperate for an experienced starter — like the Pirates were last year when they made a last-minute deadline deal for J.A. Happ because A.J. Burnett went down with an injury.
None of these moves would make the Pirates great for the future, and none of them would destroy their chances this year, either.
But they would do two things — bring a few prospects or some cash back to the organization and open up some room for the next wave of Pirates to start to gain some experience.
With Niese gone and Juan Nicasio to the bullpen, the Pirates rotation could be Gerrit Cole, Francisco Liriano, Jameson Taillon, Tyler Glasnow (or Chad Kuhl) and Jeff Locke.
The Pirates could use either Kuhl or Glasnow (whoever isn’t in the rotation) out of the bullpen (think David Price in 2008) if he doesn’t fit in the rotation, and there would be room for another pitcher down there with Melancon gone.
True, that pitching staff might blow up and maybe those three rookies will prove they aren’t ready. But the flip side is they all have high level stuff and are more likely to get better as they get more experience.
And frankly, they can’t be worse than what the Pirates have gotten from their veteran pitchers to this point (Niese has the second best ERA among the starters, and it’s 4.74). And even if they are, there is at least a lot of reason to believe they will get better.
First baseman Josh Bell is another Class AAA player that has seemingly been on the verge of coming up to the major league team for quite some time.
By moving Joyce you create a spot for him at first base because John Jaso can fill Joyce’s roll as a left-hander off the bench.
Jaso doesn’t have Joyce’s ability to hit homers, but he is a good hitter and he would be valuable as a pinch hitter/utility guy. I’ve read many places that Bell isn’t quite ready with his glove as he transitions to first base but that he has gotten much better and continues to improve.
The bottom line is the Pirates aren’t going anywhere special this year and that was somewhat by design because Huntington and company wanted to open up some roster room for some of the top prospects in the system to be promoted.
And if that’s truly the case — that this was a bridge year — it won’t make sense unless they spend the second half of the season committed to their top pitching prospects, Bell and even Alen Hanson, too.
Maybe they go into the tank, maybe they continue to tread water and get hot enough late to make a run at a wild-card but that shouldn’t be the primary goal this year.
The primary goal this year should be to get those young guys experience, let them taste some success and some failure and let them get some of their learning curve out of the way.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1720 and Twitter @paulzeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.