The Penguins were dead and buried and in the midst of a coaching change in December. At that point many people thought they would struggle just to make the playoffs.
Tonight, they will raise the Stanley Cup for the fourth time in franchise history.
There, I said it.
The Penguins will win tonight for the oldest and often most overlooked reason in sports — because they are better than the Sharks.
Not because it is “their time” or this is some “magical season” or any of that other nonsensical sentimental crap, but because they are flat out better than the Sharks in just about every category.
Once they win tonight’s game, it will be the culmination of an improbable championship season considering all that happened and how things began.
That got me to thinking about where this one will fit among the most improbable championship runs in Pittsburgh sports history.
First, some ground rules: I kept it to major sports — hockey, basketball, baseball and football. The 1975 Pittsburgh Triangles overcame a rash of injuries and upset the No. 1 ranked Golden Gaters for a World Team Tennis title, but it isn’t relevant to this discussion.
And second, improbable to me takes a lot of factors into consideration, which is why I don’t put the 2009 Penguins’ run as high on this list as some.
They were struggling early, but they had a young core of superstars that many considered the best in the game, and they had just come off a season when they were in the Stanley Cup final and pushed the Red Wings to six games.
So here we go: Let’s take a look at the five most improbable championship seasons in Pittsburgh history — and where I would rank this one that the Penguins are on the verge of winning.
1) The 2005-06 Steelers — The Steelers were coming off a 15-1 season, but a rash of injuries and some bad luck left them at 7-5 after 12 games and very much in doubt of making a playoff spot. But they rallied to win their last four games (and needed a little bit of help) to earn the sixth and final playoff spot. It seemed at one point to be a bit of a long shot that they would even make the playoffs — but it was an even longer shot that they would get to the Super Bowl because they faced three consecutive road playoff games against division champions. They got a break in Cincinnati in the first round when Carson Palmer was knocked out of the game, and they came from behind to win. They then pulled off one of the biggest upsets in playoff history when they went into Indianapolis — where they had been blown out, 26-7, in late November — and upset Peyton Manning and the top-seeded Colts. They then won at Denver and beat the Seahawks in the Super Bowl. It was an incredible turnaround for the Steelers and even got a bow tied on the end, as it was the final season for Jerome Bettis and he got to retire in his hometown, Detroit, as a Super Bowl champ.
2) The 1960 Pirates — This team was very good all season long. They won the National League by seven games, they had Dick Groat, Bill Mazeroski, a young Roberto Clemente and a host of other great players. They weren’t the little sisters of the poor, but come on, they get this spot because of their World Series win over the Yankees, who were heavily favored and dominated the Pirates for most of this series. The Pirates were outscored 55-27, outhit by 31 hits, were shut out twice by Whitey Ford and until Game 7 had one home run. But yet, they won. In fact, this is the only time the World Series MVP came from the losing team. This Pirates team was very good. They weren’t as good as the Yankees, and they were even outplayed for most of this series — but somehow, they won it.
3) The 2015-16 Penguins — OK, they haven’t won it yet, but I already called that shot. Yes, they have star power in three of the best players in the world, but let’s face it, they had become known as playoff underachievers since 2009. They were pounded by the Rangers last year in the playoffs, and they looked like a roster of misfit parts. And then the season started, and Sidney Crosby looked disinterested. The team was so bad Mike Johnston was fired just two months into his second season. And the solution was a coach from Wilkes-Barre who wanted to bring a bunch of his guys with him and two trades for misfit parts from other teams. But somehow it fell into place and worked out. Sullivan has been a puppet master and a genius at figuring out who works well with whom and getting the most out of every one of his players — from the stars to the fourth-liners. They then had to go through the Presidents’ trophy winners and the defending Eastern Conference champions just to get to the final. It has been a wild and improbable ride.
4) The 1979 Pirates — Yes, the Pirates won 98 games and were clearly the best team in the NL. But this was a team that proved great chemistry, grit and hustle can elevate a team to play above the sum of its parts. But that’s not why they are on this list. They were very good and had some legitimate all-stars. However, in the World Series, they fell behind Baltimore three games to one and needed to win three games in a row to win the World Series — two of which would take place in Baltimore. But Bert Blyleven and John Candelaria both pitched strong games (Baltimore scored a total of one run) in Games 5 and 6 to tie the series, and then the Pirates won Game 7, 4-1. It is still one of the most beloved teams because of its cast of characters. It is also the last time the Pirates won a World Series.
5) The 1974-75 Steelers — Finding a fifth was difficult to be honest. The 1909 and 1925 Pirates were by far the best teams in the major leagues. The 1971 Pirates were good the whole season and on the short list from early on as a legitimate World Series contender. The 1943, ’44 and ’48 Homestead Grays were loaded and considered among the best teams in Negro League history. The 1935 Pittsburgh Crawfords — the only edition that won the outright NNL title — is considered by many to be THE greatest Negro League team of all time. The 1968 Pipers were pretty dominant and didn’t have much of an issue blowing through the regular season or the playoffs. Neither of the two early Penguins Stanley Cup teams — 1990-91 or 1991-92 – were a surprise or improbable, and the only reason they didn’t finish first in the conference is Mario Lemieux missed stretches of both seasons with a back injury. It was pretty clear when he was healthy, though, that the Penguins were a serious Stanley Cup contender, and that much became clear in the playoffs. The 2008 Steelers were one of the best teams in franchise history and had the No. 1 ranked defense in the NFL — and had a relatively easy path to the Super Bowl title (San Diego, home against Baltimore and 8-8 Arizona). I also think that the 1975 and 1978 Steelers teams were both pretty heavily favored to win the Super Bowl. So that leaves us with three teams to choose from — the 2009 Penguins (started season with one coach, ended with another), the 1974 Steelers (before the Hall of Famers became Hall of Famers) and the 1979 Steelers (after the Hall of Famers started to show their age). I’m giving the nod to the 1974 Steelers over the 2009 Penguins, just because all of those guys were still trying to prove themselves and show that they could win the Super Bowl.
So there you have it, my list of the most improbable major sports championships in Pittsburgh history and where I think this Penguins team fits — once they win it, of course.
What are your thoughts on this list and where this Penguins team would fit?




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.