From Bob Prince to Myron Cope to Mike Lange, broadcasters have always held an important place in the Pittsburgh sports landscape.

They come into our homes, cars and bars most nights of the year. They teach us their games and provide the soundtrack to our teams’ greatest moments and victories.

So following Lange’s retirement last year, the Post-Gazette sports staff set out to answer the question of which current play-by-play and color men do their jobs best.

Below is the result of voting among our committee of five reporters: digital sports producer Adam Bittner, Pirates beat writer Jason Mackey, Pitt beat writer Craig Meyer, Steelers beat writer Ray Fittipaldo and high schools beat writer Brad Everett.

Advertise with us

Each ranked the radio and TV announcers for the Penguins, Panthers, Pirates and Steelers on a 1-12 scale. Announcers with the fewest points were rated best.

In a fun twist, there was a tie for the top spot on our list. So we turned to you, the Post-Gazette’s readers to break it. So without further ado, here is what we found. Commentary is from Adam Bittner unless otherwise noted.

1. Phil Bourque

In a sport that can be stodgy in many other corners of the world, Bourque excels at focusing on substance over style. On highlighting the X’s and O’s without getting bogged down in cultural and generational divides. He notices all of the little things, too, and explains their importance in a way that the average fan can understand and learn from. Combine it with his enthusiasm for the team, and it’s a potent package.

“Penguins fans likely don't realize how good they have it with the ol' 29er. He's honest, accurate and personable. Major points for Bourque's willingness to call it like he sees it.” — Jason Mackey

Advertise with us

2. Pat Bostick

A Pitt man through and through, Bostick has all the on-air energy of someone who could be doing something else — like his day job as the athletic department’s director of development and major gifts — but can’t keep himself away from his passion of talking Panthers football. It’s infectious. And because he played so recently, you almost feel like he’s still there in the huddle with the guys on the field, reading Kenny Pickett’s mind. Add it all together and he evokes the great Tony Romo in the booth. Certainly not a bad thing if you’ve seen the latter’s paycheck lately.

“E.J. Borghetti. Dave Wannstedt. Aaron Donald. All great ‘Pitt men.’ Bostick is right up there with them. He’s become very good at his job, too, and teams with Hillgrove to give the Panthers an excellent one-two punch in the booth.” — Brad Everett

“One of my favorite traits for any broadcaster is a genuine, palpable sense of passion for what they do and the sport they call. It's always evident with Pat, who mixes that excitement over games with the insight of a former quarterback and a deep knowledge of someone who played for the program. He works for the Pitt athletic department, which you have to weigh with some of his insights and commentary, but he helps bring alive a game in a way that is notable.” — Craig Meyer

3. Bill Hillgrove 

Advertise with us

Even at 81, his fastball for the big moments is still the best in the game, as he showed during Pitt’s run to the ACC championship this past year. His excitement oozes through the microphone, but he doesn’t overdo it. He knows how to let the moment breathe and allow his color commentators to cook. He does make some mistakes. And he can get a little myopic about the refs, particularly during Pitt hoops games. On the whole, though, no one defines “pro” quite like him. Here’s hoping he has a lot of years left.

“Hillgrove will begin his 28th season as Steelers play-by-play man, which will equal the number of his predecessor, Jack Fleming, who was behind the microphone on Steelers radio broadcasts from 1965-93. Hillgrove took over in 1994 and has called eight AFC championship games and four Super Bowls. He’s still going strong.” — Ray Fittipaldo

“The man's an institution, having called Pitt games since 1969 and Steelers games since 1994. While he's in the later stages of a decorated career, I've always been impressed with how he has been able to effectively balance the responsibilities of being the voice for three teams, one of which comes with the onus of being the soundtrack to the region's biggest source of civic pride.” — Craig Meyer

4. Josh Getzoff (tie)

Replacing Hall of Famer Mike Lange has got to be the hardest broadcast job in town right now, but he’s done a great job. He’s been smart not to try to imitate his predecessor in the obvious ways. He knows no one needs a new batch of catch phrases or anything like that. Instead, it’s the more subtle things like his cadence that feel so familiar and homey on a cold winter’s night.

Advertise with us

“If you get Mike Lange’s approval and support, you’re doing something right. And Getzoff — in addition ditching Philly for Pittsburgh — does that a lot. A terrific combination of talent and work ethic.” — Jason Mackey

4. Steve Mears (tie)

“Mears is decidedly not his predecessor, which probably shapes how you feel about him. If you like an unapologetic homer in the booth, then you probably miss Paul Steigerwald. But if you prefer a more even-handed approach, then Mears checks all the boxes. He’s well prepared and erudite. His cadence is smooth. And he never gets too high or too low. For many, that’s a welcomed change, even if it’s not for everyone.

“Aside from being a fantastic play-by-play man with sturdy announcing chops, Mears' impression of Mike Lange is stunningly good.” — Jason Mackey

Honorable mentions (in no particular order)

Advertise with us

Greg Brown

His voice on a summer night just feels like home, and only Hillgrove rivals him in genuine emotion about the action he’s watching. Sometimes that can creep into over-enthusiasm, but that’s far from a criticism. Often, his exuberance for the rare bright moments amid this team’s natural state of futility functions as a necessary coping mechanism. He also has an older-school mentality about the game that can come across as preachy at times. But what’s home if not a place for some good-natured generational banter?

“Brown's use of language is terrific, while nobody can doubt his excitement. What Brown rarely gets enough credit for is his vast baseball knowledge and feel for the game.” — Jason Mackey

“Raise the Jolly Roger! Pirates fans haven’t had a lot to be jolly about over the last few decades, but they all should raise a glass of their favorite beverage to Brownie, a pro’s pro who is dynamite at his job. Bonus points to him for being a fellow Point Park graduate.” — Brad Everett

Joe Block

Advertise with us

A three-hour or so broadcast with Block is a tour de force in preparation. No one adds more stats and factoids to the broadcast. You know so much more for having listened to him. And even though he’s an outsider, his excitement comes across so authentically that he almost always gets he big moments right. He just maybe needs to cool it with cherry-picking numbers that paint this bad team in a good light. It comes across as unvarnished apologia.

Craig Wolfley

No one wanted him to grow past his repartee with the late Tunch Ilkin under these circumstances. We should have had at least another decade of the former calling the latter “chalooch” from the sideline in between indistinguishable blocking jargon. Alas, he’s made the best of a sad situation and brought the same fun-loving energy to the booth that Ilkin and Myron Cope did before him, giving fans good reason to continue the tradition of turning the TV volume down to listen to DVE on game day instead.

“The Steelers love to have former offensive linemen provide game analysis, and Wolfley is entering his second season as color commentator. He succeeded his good friend Tunch Ilkin, who passed away last summer. Wolfley’s signature is his unique catch phrases and vocabulary to describe the action.” — Ray Fittipaldo

Bob Walk

Advertise with us

He’s so good at walking the tight rope of authoritative commentary mixed with wit. You’ll never find him over-analyzing a pitch in an 8-1 laugher. He’s more likely to be telestrating some goings-on in the stands and ribbing his colleagues gently. He’s kind of the John Madden of Pittsburgh in that way. Like Brown and Wehner, he can sometimes get in the weeds with old guy stuff. But that’s more than offset by the way he never takes the game too seriously, which is such an underrated skill for someone who has to enter fans’ homes every night for half the year.

Curtis Aiken

Stepping in between legends like Hillgrove and Dick Groat is an unenviable task, but Aiken did so with so much grace and class a few years back. When he shared the mic with Groat, he was great at gently steering his teammates back to the action when they’d start to go overboard in grousing about a ref’s call. And since Groat’s retirement, he’s proven so capable of breaking down a play that his listeners couldn’t see. He’s been a perfect addition at the perfect time.

“Replacing someone as long-tenured as Dick Groat was never going to be easy, but Curtis has done an excellent job with it. His analysis is sharp, he's not afraid to be critical of what he's witnessing, and he and Bill Hillgrove have already established a strong on-air rapport. It only means so much when ranking broadcasters, but he's also one of the kindest people you'll come across in local sports.” — Craig Meyer

John Wehner

Advertise with us

He gives it to you straight, which is so refreshing when the team stinks like this one does. He doesn’t toe the gentler company line the way others tend to. He’ll analyzes a play or pitch on its merits and goes from there, whether that reflects poorly on a player for the home team or not. Of course, he can go old school pretty hard at times. Think the Derek Dietrich controversy of a few years back. But that moment also represents the best of his no-nonsense style that evokes his hard-working Carrick roots.

“Breaking down baseball nuance can be hard. Doing it in a relatable way is even more difficult. Wehner handles both with ease.” — Jason Mackey.

Bob Errey

Hockey can be monotonous at times through the course of an 82-game schedule, but Errey never allows a broadcast that he’s a part of to become mundane. He has a curiosity about every play of every shift that grabs you and makes you pay attention just as you’re drifting off into a day dream. Sometimes it can be a little much if you’re just trying to relax. But most of the time, that exuberance is a welcomed balance to his more neutral broadcast partner in Steve Mears.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.