There is certainly no scarcity of documentation for it — whether in Pittsburgh’s rich and garrulous oral history or on any media platform old or new – and still it’s become nearly impossible to get the feel of it, to get some emotional understanding of the time Billy Conn first fought Joe Louis for the heavyweight championship of the world, 75 years ago this month.
Blessedly, we still have Mary Louise, Billy’s widow, still impossibly beautiful at 93, and still, as her fighter was all his life, very much in the moment.
“It doesn’t feel like 75 years ago; I can still just feel it happening,” she was saying in her room at Little Sisters of the Poor nursing home in Brighton Heights this week. “It’s very clear.”
What happened the night of June 18, 1941 at the Polo Grounds in New York was, in the end, not a lot more complicated than Louis’s thundering right hand, which essentially floored The Pittsburgh Kid near the end of the 13th round.
Conn lost, but he won, mostly because everything leading to and from that fight, that night, was so authentically human and deliciously complicated.
Mary Louise was at the Waldorf that night, with her Aunt Helen, and it was not where they were supposed to be.
“We told my father we were going to Atlantic City,” she said.
She was 18. It would not have been a good idea to tell her father, legendary Pittsburgh agitator Greenfield Jimmy Smith, that she was headed to a suite on Park Avenue to meet Billy Conn on the night he’d attempt to take the world title from an indestructible champion not likely to surrender it passively.
Conn was from a family of East Liberty street fighters. Billy was light-heayweight champion and had beaten reputable heavyweights, but as boxing writers of the time loved to point out, his brother Jackie was probably tougher. If boxing rings were made out of cobblestones, the saying went, Jackie Conn would be champion of the world.
“Billy saw Jackie in the Waldorf, asleep in the lobby, with his mouth wide open,” said Tim Conn, sitting with Mary Louise and his younger brother, Billy Jr. “He orders a seltzer bottle from the bar, sticks the nozzle in Jackie’s mouth, and shoots it right into him. Jackie jumps up, grabs my father, throws him the floor, and they’re rolling around on the floor. This is the day of the fight!”
While that was going on, a chartered passenger train rocked its way through the Pennsylvania countryside toward Gotham, jammed with fight fans and gamblers taking what they called the Ham & Cabbage Special, serviced by Pittsburgh Restaurateur Owney McManus.
But Mary Louise would not be joining them at the Polo Grounds. When the bell rang for Round 1, she was still at the Waldorf.
“I was in the bathroom, and I stayed in there the whole fight,” she said. “Aunt Helen was listening on the radio. I’d only come out between rounds, and she’d tell me what was happening. Then I was in the bathroom and I heard a scream, and then Helen came into the bathroom and put her arms around me and she started crying.
“’Billy won,’” she said. “’He won the fight, but he lost.’ See, nobody from Greenfield was every going to admit that a Pittsburgh guy lost.”
He lost, but he won. He won, but he lost. There was a screaming dichotomy about the whole thing that wouldn’t go away.
Ahead on all three judges’ cards through 12 rounds, Conn had delivered damaging blows to Louis’s head in the 11th and 12th. In his corner before the 13th, he informed manager Johnny Ray that it was time for Louis to go, that he was going to knock him out. Ray pleaded for sanity, instructing his fighter to instead just stay on course for an upset that would rattle the world.
But nobody could tell Billy Conn what to do.
Nobody.
Outweighed by 30 pounds, Conn walked right back into Louis’s kitchen, only to find that the great champion was done accepting damage. Now he would deliver some. With two atomic right hands, he sent Billy to the canvas for good. Conn admitted later he should have taken a nine count after the first and allowed himself to recover. Two seconds before the 13th ended, referee Eddie Joseph stopped the fight.
In his dressing room, Conn wept as writers pressed him on strategy. Finally he laughed. “What’s the use of being Irish,” he snapped, “if ya can’t be dumb?”
Twenty-minutes later, Billy started walking toward the Waldorf. What the hell, it was only about seven miles. Walked right through Harlem, waving and thanking people in the street who applauded as Billy passed.
“Then he was back,” Mary Louise said, “and the look on his face, it was happy, happy to see me, but a little sad, a little disappointed. He said, ‘Matt I did the best I could.’ He called me Matt, from one time when my hair was matted.
“But you know, he didn’t brood. He just wasn’t like that. He didn’t feel like he’d lost the championship. It just wasn’t in him to feel like that.”
He lost, but he won. He won, but he lost. He cried and he was happy, but a little sad and disappointed. It was complicated.
Billy and his girl got up the next morning and drove back to Pittsburgh, but were back on the road again in a few days, looking for a priest of all things. They drove first to Brockway, Pa., then turned east, eventually to Philadelphia. They wanted to be married.
“So,” I said, “You just drove around the state looking for a priest who would marry you?”
“Mm-hmm,” she smiled.
And right then you could feel it, finally, how that must have seemed to them like the most true and real and natural thing in the world in the summer of 1941.
Married in Philadelphia that July, they were parents by the following April, when Tim’s arrival precipitated a party at the home of Mary Louise’s parents. It went swimmingly until Greenfield Jimmy started in on Billy about in his role in his new family, about how, in this family, Billy was going to do what he was told.
Billy Conn? Seriously?
“And by the way,” Jimmy finally said, “Champion or no champion, I can beat the hell out of you anyway.”
It was Tim telling this story.
“And I guess,” Tim said, “that’s was all my father needed.”
So that fight, in another kitchen, got broken up by party guest Art Rooney, but not before Billy broke his right hand landing in on Jimmy Smith’s head. That forced a postponement of the rematch with Joe Louis, scheduled for September.
World War II began in earnest, the fighters went to the service, and everything turned upside down. Conn and Louis met again in 1946, by acclimation a terrible fight, and Louis won by knockout in the eighth round at Yankee Stadium.
Billy lost, but of course, he won.
In that complicated kind of way and for the rest of his life, Billy Conn never lost. He laughed. He smiled. He had Matt. A winner until he died in 1993.
Mary Louise sits surrounded by their photos and her clear-as-day memories, and when anyone asks she says, “I’m great!” She still smiles like she’s 18.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.