Was 2015 a tipping point for women’s athletics? That was the question keynote speaker Nicole LaVoi posed Thursday at the second Girls and Women in Sports Symposium hosted by Robert Morris University’s School of Education and Social Sciences at Sewall Center.
LaVoi, who played tennis at Gustavus Adolphus College and later coached at Wellesley College, is co-director of the Tucker Center for Research on Girls and Women in Sport at the University of Minnesota, where she earned a doctorate degree in kinesiology in 2002.
Her answer to the session’s central question: Let’s look at the data.
“I don’t have to say, ‘This is what I think.’ Because this is what I know,” LaVoi said, explaining her data-driven mentality. “I let people digest the data for themselves. I find that is the best way to shift opinions and create social change. When people look at the data, it’s hard to refute.”
In her research, LaVoi constantly collects data to combat the “false narrative” she hears that there’s no interest in women’s sports. Some of the data points: Concentration and nature of media coverage, mainstream social-media and marketing campaigns, the number of women in power positions and, especially, participation and viewership numbers.
By many metrics, 2015 was a landmark year.
Serena Williams’ chase to win all four grand slams captivated more than just the tennis world. At UFC 193, Ronda Rousey and Holly Holm were the first female mixed martial arts fighters to lead a fight card. More than 22 million viewers watched the U.S. women’s national soccer team — Pine-Richland graduate Meghan Klingenberg included — defeat Japan in the Women’s World Cup final, the most-watched soccer match in U.S. history.
Other anecdotal examples of progress: The Arizona Cardinals, Buffalo Bills, Sacramento Kings and tennis star Andy Murray hired female coaches. Sarah Thomas became the NFL’s first female referee. Jessica Mendoza debuted on ESPN’s Sunday Night Baseball and earned a full-time analyst role.
Participation opportunity is up at all levels, LaVoi said, and 43 percent of all athletes are female. But as the percentage gap between male and female participation has thinned since the 1970s, the lines haven’t converged, and some media coverage isn’t helping.
According to the Tucker Center’s research, women’s sports receive less than 4 percent of all sport media coverage, and female athletes are much more likely to be painted, sometimes literally, in a sexually provocative light, potentially sending hazardous body-image messages.
LaVoi’s team has released a report card each of the past four years grading 86 Division I Football Bowl Subdivision institutions on what percentage of their women’s teams have female head coaches — above 70 percent is an A, under 24 percent is an F.
Since 2012, the average has climbed slightly from 40.2 percent to 41.1 percent. Among 10 failing grades given this year is West Virginia, which has one female and 10 males coaching its women’s teams. Penn State earned a C (40 percent), Pitt a D (30 percent).
“Until this year, we had as many A’s and B’s as F’s,” LaVoi said. “Now, for the first time, we had more A’s and B’s than F’s, which is good, but we still have 10 F’s.”
Teresa Conn, Pittsburgh Passion co-owner and co-head coach, joined a panel to discuss marketing women’s sports. Riding a 22-game winning streak, Conn said she’s still learning best practices for building brand loyalty and a devoted local following of women’s professional football.
“I’m the eternal optimist,” Conn admitted. She hopes women’s sports stay on the rise, but said it has been a struggle at times to persuade media outlets to invest their time, resources and attention when the public’s interest isn’t always readily apparent.
Before her keynote address, LaVoi polled an audience to ask whether they believed 2015 was a tipping point for women’s athletics. About 20 percent raised a hand. So, LaVoi dived into the data for an hour, then asked the same question again. Only two hands raised. LaVoi grinned.
She agrees — there’s been progress made, but there’s still plenty to be concerned about, plenty of questions left unanswered.
“There are some flickers of hope,” LaVoi said. “But I think it's a little too soon to tell.”
Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and on Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.