The Penguins’ four big stars — Marc Andre-Fleury, Kris Letang, Evgeni Malkin and captain Sidney Crosby — all played well this past regular season.

Fleury, 30, had one of his best campaigns, racking up 10 shutouts and a .920 save percentage, the second-best mark of his career.

Letang, 27, challenged for a Norris Trophy, awarded to the NHL’s top defenseman, before going down with a season-ending concussion in late March.

Malkin, 28, was productive if limited by injury at times in finishing with 70 points, and Crosby, 27, just missed out on winning a scoring title.

Advertise with us

By any measure, they individually lived up to the value of their big contracts.

But this playoff season will be a big test of whether those expensive deals, which take up almost half of the team’s salary cap space, are tenable as a package.

Letang’s absence this postseason will mark yet another in which one of these four has been injured for the playoffs in some way. Last year, for example, Crosby played through a wrist injury and wasn’t very productive in finishing with just eight points, including one goal before the Penguins were bounced by the New York Rangers in round 2.

Should Letang’s absence play a big part in another early exit, then, it’s fair to question whether the club is too invested in the idea of these core four winning more Stanley Cups together.

With Crosby, Malkin, Letang and Fleury all set to exit their respective primes in the next few years, it seems increasingly unreasonable to count on their collective health. Their 20s have shown that’s already a dicey proposition, and there’s no reason to expect that to change in their 30s.

Advertise with us

With that in mind, it could be prudent to shed one of those big contracts and use the cap space to sign two or three good-if-not-great players for the same price.

This will make the Penguins a deeper team and thus more able to compensate for an injury to one of the key guys.

Of course, it would be nice if the Penguins had a useful farm system to accomplish this goal. Then, perhaps, the cheap talent surrounding them would allow for the luxury of having all four around.

But that ship sailed under former general manager Ray Shero, who passed out draft picks like raffle tickets to the rest of the NHL in rental deals at trading deadlines.

The Penguins are paying for that lack of depth now, with just one top 12 forward drafted since 2006 on the roster, and will continue to do so following new GM Jim Rutherford’s deals this season that sent away most of Pittsburgh’s 2015 picks.

Advertise with us

Instead, they’re probably going to have to rely on outside help to fill out the roster, either via more trades or free agency acquisitions.

That won’t be cheap, and it means that even productive seasons by Malkin, Crosby, Letang and Fleury can be liabilities in the event of season-ending or even nuisance injuries.

Perhaps this group can get hot without Letang and reel off enough playoff wins to justify the current approach.

But the Penguins sure looked like a depleted team without him down the stretch of the regular season, when they went 4-9-2 in their last 15 games. They looked that way with a hobbled Crosby last year, too. And who can forget that 2011 season that ended without Crosby or Malkin skating in the playoffs?

So they’d be bucking the trend to upset the Rangers this year and keep chugging toward a Stanley Cup, especially now that they’re already in an 0-1 series hole after Thursday night’s loss at Madison Square Garden.

Advertise with us

Having Crosby, Letang, Malkin and Fleury healthy for the playoffs is very tempting in theory. But as it’s becoming increasingly elusive in reality, it could soon be time for management to give up the idea as a fantasy.

Adam Bittner writes sports commentary for The Pittsburgh Press, our afternoon electronic edition. He can be reached at abittner@post-gazette.com or Twitter, @fugimaster24.