Ten games into the season, things appeared to be spiraling for the Washington & Jefferson College baseball team.

“We had a lot of doubts,” said senior center fielder Dante Dalesandro, a Mt. Lebanon High grad.

And ...

“We didn’t have confidence.”

Advertise with us

Understandable, given the team sported a 3-7 record after enduring a seven-game losing streak. The stage was being set for a forgettable three-plus months.

Or, so it seemed?

It was then that these proud Presidents, led by 15 seniors (many WPIAL alums), stared down adversity and did not flinch. They rattled off 16 consecutive victories and went on to win 34 of 38 en route to a Presidents’ Athletic Conference championship, NCAA Division III regional and super regional titles and a spot in the College World Series. Their season eventually ended Sunday with an 8-4 loss to No. 6 Chapman University in Cedar Rapids, Iowa.

Prior to being eliminated, W&J (38-13, 21-3 PAC) had gone a stunning 9-0 in the postseason before losing twice to Chapman.

“They showed a tremendous amount of determination and resilience,” said coach Jeff Mountain, whose team was within a game of winning the 2017 national championship. “We try to teach our guys to try to remain even-keeled and play through adversity. Adversity can come in many forms, but our players did a good job of maintaining a consistent approach.

Advertise with us

“In our eight regional, super regional and World Series games, we were either winning by three runs or less or losing by three runs or less in 69 of 72 innings. This is an incredibly high number of tight ballgames and situations. Each pitch mattered because of the tightness of the games.”

A “Sheriff” led the way for W&J. Junior right-hander Ben Marsico, a North Allegheny High grad, was named the PAC Pitcher of the Year after finishing with the fourth-most victories in Division III. He went 11-2 with a 3.27 ERA, 56 strikeouts, two complete games and two shutouts in 88 innings. His 2-1 record in the NCAA postseason featured back-to-back wins over favored Salisbury (which he held to a run and 5 hits in 7 innings) and Misericordia (3 runs, 7 hits in 5.1 innings).

Oh, and about that “Sheriff” nickname. Marsico explained.

“There isn’t much to it ... a senior on the team, Cole Reese called me it and it just stuck,” Marsico said.

That said, Marsico embraced his Sheriff-like status on the team.

Advertise with us

“Being seen as a leader gave this World Series run a completely different feel to me compared to when we went two years ago,” he said. “It felt like it was my first World Series in a lot of ways. Having so many seniors made this a special run. A majority of our lineup knew this was their last shot, and, overall, guys wanted it far more than last year.”

A perennial contender under Mountain (W&J has qualified for the NCAA tournament seven times since 2009), the Presidents relied on former WPIAL stars such as seniors Dalesandro, Mitchell Taufer (Bishop Canevin), Clay Martin (Canon-McMillan) and Santino Platt (Our Lady of the Sacred Heart).

Dalesandro finished near the top of the PAC with a .355 batting average, while producing 12 doubles, 4 triples, 41 RBIs and a .464 on-base percentage.

Taufer and Martin formed one of the top bullpen tandems in Division III. Taufer appeared in 27 games, going 3-0 with 46 strikeouts and a 1.23 ERA in 36⅔ innings. He yielded just five runs and 20 hits this spring.

A team captain, Martin was an incredible 12 for 12 in save opportunities.

Advertise with us

“He was always at his best in high-leverage situations,” Mountain said of Martin, whose 13 career saves is tied for tops in W&J history.

Platt, the Presidents’ No. 2 pitcher and PAC All-Championship Tournament Team selection, finished 6-4. He also served as a captain.

Other WPIAL alums who contributed to this memorable run were: sophomore Joey Bolick (Pine-Richland, 42 starts, .282 average); junior Adam Jaworski (Peters Township, 28 games, .226); senior Cole Reese (Greensburg Central Catholic, 41 games, .226).

“The WPIAL has been, and will continue to be, our main source of recruiting,” said Mountain, who hails from western New York. “The kids are generally tough, hard-nosed kids.”

Mountain then opined on the PIAA.

Advertise with us

“I wish the PIAA would increase the number of games schools are allowed to play so players that do play at the next level come in with more experience and understanding of what it is like to play a heavy number of games in a week.”

The 2019 Presidents played their final 41 games at a season-changing .853 clip.

“I did not expect this team to make it to the World Series,” Dalesandro said. “But our goal every year was to make it back to the CWS. We knew we were good enough, though, and had a lot of heart.

“ We found a way to become the sixth-best team in the country due to the disrespect from the [NCAA selection] committee. The committee placed us in a region where we thought we would have no chance of winning. We sure proved them wrong as it led us back to the CWS.”