Tyler Garbee was looking for a “change of scenery” when he transferred from Division I Pitt to Division II Mercyhurst in 2018.
He ended up with a whole lot more.
“It was,” said the Quaker Valley High grad, “the best thing I ever did.”
Who can argue?
Garbee, along with a number of fellow WPIAL alums, has helped Mercyhurst to back-to-back College World Series appearances. And it was Garbee, a senior right-handed pitcher, who faced third-ranked Tampa in the opening game of the CWS Sunday in Cary, N.C.
“How many people get to say they’ve been to the College World Series once, much less twice,” said Garbee, who twice pitched in a WPIAL final at Quaker Valley. “This was the second time I was on the mound for the CWS, so I was comfortable.
“Tampa is a known powerhouse, one of the best in Division II ever. So, it was cool to go out there and throw against them, underneath the lights in Game 1. In that situation, you get to be, ‘The Guy,’ because you were the one who was chosen to pitch in that first game. And that’s all I’ll ever ask for, a chance to compete.”
Compete he did — against a loaded Tampa lineup. He struck out 12, giving him 104 for the season, and allowed only four hits in 7⅔ innings. The downside? After leaving with two outs and the bases loaded in the top of the eighth, Garbee watched from the dugout as Tampa used a three-run triple to turn a 2-1 deficit into an eventual 4-2 victory. It was a bitter pill after such a potent performance by the former Quaker Valley star.
“It’s baseball,” said Garbee, who has received numerous postseason accolades, while posting a team-best 8-3 record with three saves and a 3.08 ERA. He and All-American Matthew Minnick give Mercyhurst one of the top starting tandems in Division II. “You have to be ready for the next one.”
Mercyhurst (36-15) staved off elimination Tuesday by defeating Catawba, 8-5. The Lakers faced UC San Diego Wednesday and rallied from four runs down, with Matthew Schneider hitting a home run with two outs in the top of the ninth for a 6-5 victory.
Mercyhurst was scheduled to face Tampa at 1 p.m. Thursday. It would take two wins against Tampa to earn a spot in the national championship round, scheduled to begin Saturday.
“This has been awesome,” said Garbee, who had an April to remember, after pitching a no-hitter and a one-hitter, while recording a combined 23 strikeouts, in back-to-back wins against Slippery Rock and Clarion. “It’s really hard to describe.”
While Garbee is a star on the mound for Mercyhurst, Central Catholic grad and Oklahoma transfer Domenic DeRenzo has provided an offensive boost. A former freshman All-American for the Sooners (for whom he played 113 games in three seasons), DeRenzo leads Mercyhurst with 38 RBIs and is second with 10 home runs. The senior catcher also boasts a .968 fielding percentage.
In the third and deciding game of the Super Regional versus Charleston, W.Va., DeRenzo went 2 for 3 with 2 doubles, 2 runs scored, a stolen base and 4 RBIs. He also went 2 for 4 with a double, a run and an RBI in Tuesday’s win against Catawba.
“It’s great to see another guy from the WPIAL doing well for our team, or, seeing WPIAL guys doing well in [the Pennsylvania State Athletic Conference],” said Garbee, one of 14 local products, including 13 from the WPIAL, on the Mercyhurst roster. “When I started playing in our league, I didn’t realize how many WPIAL guys were out there. The running joke on our team — from guys who aren’t from the Pittsburgh area — is that the WPIAL is like some Class AA baseball league because they hear so much about it.”
Some other offensive contributors from district schools include sophomore Matthew Gibson (New Castle, .284 average, 10 doubles, 4 homers), junior Luke Baranchak (Butler, .269, 4 triples) and senior Kenny Robinson (Allderdice, .226).
Six former WPIAL pitchers dot the roster, notably Garbee and sophomore reliever Adam Jeannette (Riverside, 4-1 with a 2.87 ERA, 5 saves, 36 strikeouts in 31⅓ innings). The 6-foot-5 Jeannette had not allowed a run, while registering 11 strikeouts in 10⅓ innings, in his four NCAA postseason appearances entering Thursday’s action. He pitched four scoreless innings to close out Garbee’s 6-5 victory against Charleston in a Super-Regional elimination game, and picked up the win against UC San Diego, recording three strikeouts in the final 1⅓ innings against six batters faced, not allowing a hit.
“We’ve come together as a team,” said Garbee, who left Pitt after appearing in 14 games as a freshman and playing sparingly as a sophomore. “To be here at Mercyhurst and to be in so many big ballgames, it’s been great. I’m glad to be a part of this program.”



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.