There once was a men’s college basketball team in Pittsburgh — in the Oakland neighborhood, actually — that went winless in its conference while breaking in a team full of freshmen who were brought in to lay a foundation for the long term.

No, not the 2018 Pitt Panthers. We’re talking about the 2015 Carlow Celtics, just a few blocks down Fifth Avenue where four seasons ago, 19 players and 10 freshmen rolled the dice on their college careers. Four years later, the first group to ever start and finish at Carlow celebrated its senior day — all three of them.

A common phrase in sports is that you always want to leave a program better than you found it. In the case of Zach Bryan, Charlie Scharbo and Miles Sunder at Carlow, “founded it” would be more accurate. Those three were freshmen on Carlow’s inaugural team that won two games, and the only seniors on this year’s squad that reached the postseason for the first time in school history before its season ended Feb. 21.

“It’s certainly extremely special,” said Bryan, a 2014 graduate of Norwin High School. “It’s just kind of a goal reached, a big step forward for the program, and it’s kind of slowly — hopefully — setting a standard of where we should be every year.”

Advertise with us

Carlow finished 6-21 overall under coach Tim Keefer, but 6-11 in the River States Conference, a Division II member in the NAIA, a separate entity from the NCAA. A 76-70 home win against Rio Grande (Ohio) in their final regular-season game qualified the Celtics for the conference tournament, where it lost to nationally ranked Indiana University Southeast, 105-53.

The steps forward for Carlow men’s basketball might be baby steps, but for a program still in its infancy, improving its conference record each year is a good start.

“It was definitely important, just because we’re trying to build something, you know?” Scharbo said. “We’re trying to build a culture, you could say — a winning culture, that is.”

You could call Scharbo the embodiment of the Celtics, whose humble beginnings are highlighted by using Oakland Catholic High School as their home venue. At Thomas Jefferson High School, Scharbo wasn’t a starter until his senior year, then blossomed into the Jaguars’ leading scorer.

He was a driving force from the get-go at Carlow, and despite being an undersized 6-foot-4 forward, he was named second-team all-conference this season and last. Oh, and of course, he’s the leading scorer in school history with 1,435 points.

Advertise with us

“It came down to his toughness, and every possession, he was going at you,” said Bryan, Scharbo’s point guard. “It was just constant throughout the year, every game, even if he was worn down. It’s just how tough he was and how hard he played.”

Scharbo averaged 16.6 points, 8.8 rebounds and 3 assists in 31.9 minutes per game, while Bryan also started in every game he played and averaged 7.7 points and 4.1 assists. At 5-10, Bryan will be the first to tell you he wasn’t ready for college basketball coming out of Norwin, which made sticking through that initial season all the more difficult.

“Without a doubt, and I’d be lying if I said I didn’t feel that way,” Bryan recalled of wondering if he’d make it all four years. “I definitely had thoughts of transferring, but at the same time, that’s not the type of person I am and not the character I have. I just try to never quit on things and stick it out.”

Which made it all the more sweet as Carlow pulled itself up out of the cellar of its league. Or when it beat Point Park for the first time in 2017, then swept its crosstown rival in both matchups this year.

Sunder, a 6-6 forward from Jeannette High School who averaged 6.6 points per game, will never forget finally getting over the hump against Point Park in a 75-74 overtime thriller on Carlow’s home floor Feb. 7 of last year.

Advertise with us

“The highlight for me was probably just how that game was so exciting,” Sunder remembered. “It was packed at the gym.”

When Bryan, Scharbo and Sunder look back on their college careers — 5, 10, 15 years from now — will they immediately recall their 18-95 mark over four seasons? Not likely. But they’ll remember the excitement and the good times, ones they hope will soon be surpassed by the Celtics who follow in their footsteps.

“I know sometimes the record doesn’t show for it, but we had to build something from scratch,” Scharbo said. “A lot of guys didn’t stay, a lot of guys transferred and left, but we just stuck it out and stayed the course.”

Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.