Rogelio Solis, Associated Press
Alabama defensive end Wallace Gilberry, right, congratulates linebacker Juwan Simpson after a fourth-quarter interception Saturday against Mississippi State quarterback Michael Henig. No. 3 Alabama defeated Mississippi State, 17-0.
Click photo for larger image.More Coverage:
When the bowl championship series standings are released on Monday afternoons it sets off an internet frenzy across the country. Fans and media create so much traffic on the BCS' official web site (www.bcsfootball.org) that the site often crashes or, at the very least, slows to a snail's pace.
The bcs was devised to pit the top two teams in the country in a national championship game. But it has developed into so much more for the college football consumer.
In addition to determining the two national championship participants, the BCS decides which two teams earn at-large berths and hefty paydays for their universities and conferences.
And because there is no real way to settle the barroom arguments for conference supremacy, it has become a quantitative way to measure the strength of the six leagues that are involved in the BCS.
In this week's BCS standings, the SEC has four teams among the top 15 in the country. The Pac-10 has three and the Big Ten, Big 12 and ACC have two apiece.
It has been this way for much of the previous seven years of the BCS. In the final BCS standings last season, the SEC had four teams among the top 15, two more than any other conference. In 2003, the SEC and the Big Ten each had four in the top 15.
But what does the SEC have to show for being the best conference in the country?
Yes, the league has produced two national champions since the BCS came into existence, LSU in 2003 and Tennessee in 1998. But those are the only two teams from the SEC to play for the title.
Three inferior leagues have played for more titles. The Big 12 has had four title-game participants and one winner -- Oklahoma in 1999. The ACC, probably the worst BCS conference until recent expansion, has had three title-game participants and one winner -- Florida State in 1999. The Big East also has had three and one winner -- Miami in 2001. Only the Big Ten and Pac-10 have played in fewer. Ohio State of the Big Ten won the title in 2002; Southern California of the Pac-10 won the title last season.
It's looking as if the SEC will be left out of the national championship picture again this season, even if Alabama, its only remaining undefeated team, keeps winning. It was a similar case last season, when Auburn was unbeaten and finished third in the standings behind USC and Oklahoma. This season, it's USC and Texas in front of Alabama.
The Big 12 is unusually weak this season, giving the Longhorns an easy road to the national championship game in Pasadena. The Pac-10 is more difficult than it has been in the past, but USC has proven to be heads and shoulders above the competition. Oregon, the No. 10 team in the BCS this week, lost to the Trojans, 45-13, in September.
"When you have a lot of great teams in your league, usually no one team is going to stand out," said Georgia coach Mark Richt, who had his perfect season and national championship hopes ruined by Florida two weeks ago. "People will say, 'Geez, no one is great.' But, in reality, we may have six teams that if you stick them in other leagues around the country could be the dominant team in that league. Maybe I shouldn't say that, but that's what I believe."
Here's a little snapshot of the depth the SEC has to offer this season: In the span of 35 days earlier this season, Tennessee played four games against opponents that were ranked among the top six teams in Division I-A -- Florida, LSU, Georgia and Alabama.
All four teams are still ranked among the top 13 in the BCS standings. Alabama, LSU and Georgia are among the top nine.
Alabama's road to the SEC title is only slightly less difficult. If the Crimson Tide want to remain in contention for the national championship, it must beat No. 5 LSU and No. 15 Auburn in consecutive weeks and then play another highly ranked opponent in the SEC title game. In the final eight weeks of the season Alabama will have played five games against teams that were ranked at the time it played them.
"The competitiveness we have in the SEC week in and week out, great athletes and great programs ... you might not have a great won-loss record when it's over," Alabama coach Mike Shula said. "But that's also what makes our league so exciting. It also helps with recruiting. We tell them: 'If you want to be the best, you have to beat the best.' "
The Big Ten can make a case for being the top conference this season. The Big Ten has five teams in this week's BCS top 25. The SEC is the only other league with five teams in the top 25.
The Big Ten could make a case in years past as well. It had four teams in the BCS top 15 in 2002 and '03 and a record five teams in the top 15 in 1999. No other conference has accomplished that.
But like the SEC, the depth of the league has made it difficult to qualify teams for the national title game.
Ohio State is the only team from the Big Ten to go through a conference season unscathed and play for a national championship.
"Our league's depth is tremendous and it's only going to get harder," Ohio State coach Jim Tressel said. "I don't know if we have a solution for it."
Penn State is fifth in this week's BCS standings and could suffer the fate of many other one-loss Big Ten teams that came before it.
Penn State's only loss came on the road at Michigan on the final play of the game. Nittany Lions coach Joe Paterno does have a solution. And it's something that's always not far behind when the subject of the BCS is up for debate.
"The Big Ten is at a disadvantage because so many of the teams are good," Paterno said. "That's why I disagree with our commissioner, Jim Delany, who pushes for the BCS. I think we ought to have some kind of playoff. We'd have three or four teams from the Big Ten this season that would make it."
Alas, that's not the system the BCS commissioners want for determining a national champion. They would rather have the controversy that reigns after almost every season.
And, as far as the BCS goes, it's why you're better off being the best team in a bad conference. In most years, at least.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.