Chris Dell is the founder of BettingPredators.com, fantasy football lead analyst on ESPN 97.5’s “Late Hits,” and a member of the annual FantasyPros expert accuracy competition. He’s also our new sports editor at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. In this new weekly fantasy football series, Chris will cover his top strategies for winning your upcoming leagues — and gaining an edge over the competition in your drafts.
To quote a famous scholar, fantasy football is the game that “surrounds us and penetrates us; it binds the galaxy together.” OK, maybe Obi-Wan Kenobi wasn’t a scholar or talking about fantasy. Still, the force and popularity surrounding this marvel of a game cannot be understated.
Therefore, as we approach this next NFL season — and fantasy football draft season, for many — it’s imperative that we discuss the unwritten rules of this game. From draft strategies to trade etiquette and everything in between, these are “The 10 commandments of fantasy football”:
I. Thou shalt know thy league rules
Fantasy football leagues come in all shapes and sizes. Still, no matter where or when you're drafting, it’s vital to know your league’s scoring format, roster settings, and starting lineup construction.
An individual player might not be affected too much by this at the end of the year, but remember that even the slightest of scoring margins can make the most significant difference in fantasy. Whether you’re playing in leagues that do half-PPR (half-point per reception), PPR (full point per reception), or Tight End Premium (1.5x points per tight end reception), it will always affect how you rank players on your draft board. “Standard” scoring (zero points per reception) was the mainstream format of the past, and it vaulted running backs into elite territory. However, PPR has become the de facto scoring format for most leagues across the industry, which places a premium on pass catchers. In most cases, it also vaults pass-catching running backs above your traditional three-down “grinder” backs, those who see most of their touches on first/second downs and between the 20-yard lines. We don’t want those guys, plain and simple.
Roster settings are equally — if not more — important. Knowing the starting lineup format of your league will play a significant role in your draft strategy, especially in the early rounds. Most default roster settings in leagues include a standard lineup consisting of 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1TE, and 1 FLEX, which are filled typically by an RB, WR, or TE — we’ll get to kickers and defenses in a minute, don’t worry.
But many leagues these days are adding a third receiver into the starting lineup and, in some cases, multiple flex spots, which may or may not be able to be filled by a quarterback (e.g., “Superflex” formats). Covet your bench spots, too, as churning the end of your roster can often play a pivotal role in maximizing your team’s output throughout the slog of the NFL regular season. In most cases, the more bench spots you have, the better you are.
Case in point: Prepare for your draft. Know your scoring formats and roster settings in and out, and don’t be “that guy” (or gal) who doesn’t realize until Week 2 that your league awards an extra 10 points for defenses that hold their opponents scoreless. Don’t go whining to your commissioner about the league rules you technically agreed to sign up for (and likely paid to play in) after the fact.
Remember, there’s no crying in fantasy football.
II. Thou shalt not idolize players — only prices
Don't draft players. Draft their prices. And always keep in mind their average draft position (ADP), which is where players are currently getting drafted, on average, across the fantasy football industry. This type of “value-based drafting” isn’t cut and dry for every pick of every round, but it helps you avoid reaching for players a round too early. Believe it or not, the hardest thing to do in fantasy football is to predict how the players will play on the field.
No, I’m serious. The more you reach one full round early for “your guys,” the more draft capital you will spend. The more draft capital you spend, the quicker your entire team will go broke. One note that my great-grandmother always told me right before bedtime is that “You can’t win your league in the first few rounds of your fantasy draft, but you can certainly lose it.”
OK, I never had a great-grandmother who said that, but it sounded kinda cool.
Remember, the mid-to-late rounds can win you your league, not the early ones. Everyone is a darling at the ball in the first two rounds, where every manager boasts about building their fantasy superteams of the future. Don’t be that fantasy manager. Price shop, draft for value, and take advantage of discounts in player ADP. Just because Jalen Hurts goes in the second round of most drafts with a top-25 overall ADP doesn’t mean you have to draft him there.
You could certainly say Hurts is overpriced in this spot, too. Justin Fields, on the other hand, is undervalued. Fields is being taken with an ADP of 47 overall, nearly two rounds after Hurts, despite closely matching Hurts in fantasy points per game over the second half of the 2022 season. Give me two elite WRs and two bell-cow RBs early with my first four picks, then give me the same archetype of Hurts with a monster rushing ceiling, just like Fields profiles this year.
III. Thou shalt not take thy commissioner's name in vain — unless, of course, you have a really solid joke
Fantasy is supposed to be fun, remember? Therefore, we shall abide by the 10 commandments and honor our league mates and commissioner. But we also must still talk trash at every point humanly possible. Keep it respectful, and know your league mates. I’ve made lifelong friends because we competed in the same fantasy football league for years. Don’t take things personally when you lose a match or miss out on a trade opportunity. Fantasy is a game of passion and emotion for dedicated managers. It’s what brings us together, but it’s also what can divide us. Talk your trash while also maintaining respect for your opponents. It’s a (fantasy) game, after all. The more camaraderie we build and the more fun we have together, it’s a win.
IV. Remember the waiver wire day, to keep it holy
The “holy day” of the waiver wire always helps keep us one step ahead of our competition — often one week ahead. This principle goes back to commandment No. 1, where we must know every league setting ahead of our draft.
For example, most leagues run waivers on Tuesday evenings and process pickups on Wednesday mornings. Some of these leagues process those pickups at particular times in the morning. Suppose you’re out of your free agent budget (FAB) dollars and know that your league processes waiver claims at approximately 7 a.m. every Wednesday. In that case, you can pick off free agents most weeks free of charge by knowing when to hop on your fantasy league’s mobile app or website before your opponents do. The same goes for submitting waiver claims (or bids) on Tuesday.
Remember Carlos Hyde? Believe it or not, he was the Cleveland Browns' starting running back less than five years ago, ahead of the once-inexperienced NFL rookie Nick Chubb. Chubb sat on waiver wires in most leagues for the first few months of the season, waiting for someone to swing by and scoop him up.
Then Hyde was traded, and Chubb, waiting in the wings, was the priority pickup of the season.
The same thing happened when the Saints traded away Adrian Peterson, which paved the way for the infamous Alvin Kamara fantasy era in New Orleans. Sometimes fantasy news breaks for these trades late at night or early in the morning when your fantasy league mates are asleep. Whether it’s waiver day or not, the wire itself is a holy place. Always have your notifications turned for the big guns like Adam Schefter and Ian Rappaport, who sometimes drop these fantasy “Twitter bombs” at 3 a.m. on Sunday mornings ahead of big-time fantasy moves to be made. The more you’re on top of these Twitter bombs and working the waiver wire with every spot on your bench, the closer you’ll be to making the playoffs and competing for your league’s fantasy football championship. The waiver wire is your best friend. There’s no way around it.
V. Honour thy running quarterbacks and thy receiving running backs
Gone are the days of bell-cow, 25-plus touch running backs who play every down and are the focal point of their team’s offense. On the other hand, running backs who catch passes are what we now value most and honor accordingly in our fantasy leagues.
One running back target (i.e., a single pass thrown his way, whether completed or not) is worth nearly three times more than an actual running back carry, where he’s guaranteed to touch the ball, in fantasy. A running back who carries the ball a whopping 20 times and gains 100 yards would’ve been praised to the high heavens just five to 10 years ago. In fantasy leagues, however, that “workhorse” running back scored us only a measly 10 points assuming he didn’t catch a pass or score a touchdown.
Predicting touchdowns is also one of the most challenging endeavors we, as fantasy managers, can do. This is why we must covet “high-value touches” (HVTs) from our fantasy running backs. These HVTs come as targets and carries inside the 10-yard line. Give me the guy who carries the ball seven times for 50 rushing yards but also tallies five catches for 60 receiving yards on seven targets. That’s 16 fantasy points on 12 actual touches, more than 1.5x times what our aforementioned “grinder back” scored despite more than double the workload. Furthermore, our pass-catching running backs stay fresh and avoid the wear-and-tear of these early-down running backs, and they became more valuable - and available - down the stretch run.
The same strategy applies to rushing quarterbacks, who add points with their legs via rushing yards and increase their potential for scoring rush touchdowns with every scramble. In most leagues, those rushing scores are worth two points more than the standard four-point per passing touchdown. There’s no coincidence that all 10 of the top quarterbacks in fantasy points per game last season rushed for 250-plus yards, and five of those top 10 rushed for 700-plus yards, including a quarterback who many claim to be below-average in “real-life football,” Daniel Jones. The much-maligned Jones, due to his underrated wheels, averaged 18.4 fantasy points per game compared to some of the most elite “pure passers” in the game — 17.9 for Trevor Lawrence, 17.8 for Dak Prescott, 17.1 for Justin Herbert, and 16.5 for Tom Brady.
One of my few hard-and-fast rules every year is to draft a quarterback with elite rushing upside, and this season that includes one of the following: Jalen Hurts, Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson, Fields, and Jones. Unless you pass on that group and miss out on picking a truly elite passer like Patrick Mahomes or Joe Burrow — who are very expensive in drafts right now, mind you — then consider taking a flier on the rookie Anthony Richardson, who has a legit chance at leading all quarterbacks in rushing yards this season no matter how bad he might look in as a passer.
VI. Thou shalt not draft a kicker — until the last round
It’s 2023 y’all. No matter what some of the “experts” in this field might say, trust me: there is no real strategy for drafting kickers. In fact, most leagues have dropped kickers altogether and instead emphasized skill position players by adding flex spots and Superflex spots with multiple quarterbacks in the starting lineup. If your commissioner insists on being archaic and still forcing you to start kickers, keep it simple and, dare I say, be a rebel: don’t draft one.
Most fantasy apps and websites now allow you to avoid drafting a kicker, even if your league requires you to start one. In this case, you are better off using your final bench spot for a flier on a running back, wide receiver, or tight end, possibly a rookie who has the chance to earn new opportunities based on training camp performance or an injury or trade ahead of him. Hold these stashes tightly at the end of your bench, wait out the news, then 10 minutes before Week 1 kicks off on Sunday, you can drop your least valuable stash and add your starting kicker. No harm, no foul.
This same commandment applies to your D/ST, too. Fantasy defense scoring varies wildly from year to year, no matter how impressive a team looked the previous season (here’s looking at you, Philly). A lot of this hinges on free agency changes, draft picks (or lack thereof), and, most importantly, changes in the team’s strength of schedule or turnover margin, the latter of which is one of the most significant NFL variables from year to year and is most times based on pure luck.
VII. Thou shalt never get married ... to a draft strategy
This one is simple: We draft based on value and must always remain flexible to what opportunities and information arises in our drafts. Just because the consensus says not to draft multiple quarterbacks in a one-starting quarterback league doesn’t mean this is a strict rule for us. Suppose you miss out on one of those top-five rushing QB options above. In that case, it’s more than reasonable to take multiple mid-to-late-round options — like Geno Smith and Richardson, for example — to see which one pans as out as your primary starter for the long haul.
Just because you went into a draft wanting to go “robust RB” and take two elite rushers with your top two picks, always be prepared to pivot. If elite WRs start flying off the board early, make sure you don’t miss on grabbing at least one of those premier pass-catchers. The opposite can apply to wanting to go WR-heavy early, then pivoting to taking at least one elite RB before they’re all off the board.
VIII. Thou shalt not collude, cheat, or disrespect thy fantasy gods
Thou shalt always respect and honor thy fantasy football gods by practicing the following:
- ALWAYS set your lineup (we’re all busy, and no, you’re not that busy, we’re sorry)
- ALWAYS be active on waivers each week, even if your team stinks (it’s OK, we’ve all been there)
- ALWAYS respond to your opponents’ trade offers and send counter offers, if and when possible
- NEVER show up late to your draft (for thou shalt be stricken down with wicked fantasy wrath)
- NEVER veto a trade unless there's clear and present evidence of collusion (read more on this below)
- NEVER have your league’s championship in Week 18 (really, what are we doing here, people?)
IX. Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy lineup
NEVER forget to set your lineup, even if you are intentionally “tanking” to secure a specific playoff seed or to have another team secure a playoff spot over someone else. The fantasy football gods don’t take these tactics kindly, and it sets a bad precedent for your league. The NFL punishes teams severely for outwardly tanking, although there are admittedly loopholes. Preserve the integrity and longevity of your leagues, and try your best to keep out these “strategic” tanking methods.
X. Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's trade
Do not complain about “unfair” trades unless there’s evidence of cheating, as we mentioned above, or as the fantasy football GOAT Matthew Berry put it in 2010, “Thou shalt not veto.” We all have different opinions of players and employ different strategies. Therefore, we shouldn’t force those opinions onto others just because we disagree with their player takes on a specific trade.
Remember to always abide by these fantasy commandments set forth above and, most of all, HAVE FUN. The NFL season is here, and for a brief moment after our collective drafts, we’ll all be fantasy football champions in our minds, having just constructed the sweet symphony of the most superstar-laden fantasy roster ever assembled. We will bask in the glory, talk trash, and proclaim our victories before ever stepping onto the fantasy football field.
Unless you drafted a kicker, that is. Then you’re finishing dead last. Don’t say I didn’t warn you.
Make sure to check back here every Friday for Chris’ “Fantasy Favorites” weekly column, where he’ll break down his top quarterbacks to buy and sell and go position by position on his top guys to draft — as well as his “do not draft” list — through Week 1 of the 2023 NFL regular season. Have a current fantasy football draft dilemma or an early start/sit question? Email Chris (cdell@post-gazette.com) or ask him on Twitter (@MaddJournalist)
Chris Dell: cdell@post-gazette.com and Twitter @maddjournalist




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.