LAS VEGAS — At this point in the NFL calendar, all eyes are on a few cities in between Cincinnati and Los Angeles leading up to Super Bowl LVI. So why was Cyrus Mehri calling Pittsburgh “the epicenter” of the league Wednesday afternoon?
Mehri, a civil rights lawyer who helped Dan Rooney write the NFL rule that bears his name, was referring to the incendiary discrimination lawsuit filed Tuesday against the NFL and three of its teams by recently fired Dolphins coach Brian Flores. Amid copious details that scrutinize league-wide hiring practices and questionable organizational decisions, the Flores report intersects with the Rooney Rule, established in 2003 with heavy influence from the late Steelers team president — and the fact that Mike Tomlin is now the only Black head coach in the NFL.
“One thing I know from my work is that discrimination is a tenacious foe,” said Mehri, co-founder of NFL diversity watchdog the Fritz Pollard Alliance, which on Wednesday supported Flores publicly. “It doesn’t go away easily, and progress is fragile.”
Mehri’s point is that he doesn’t believe the Rooney Rule is ineffective, as Flores states, but rather it’s not being applied fairly by at least some of the 32 teams. He thinks the real failure has come at times in enforcement by the league, or lack thereof, and cites one occasion in particular. In 2018, Raiders owner Mark Davis hired Jon Gruden as his team’s head coach, a coup he’d been eyeing long before firing previous coach Jack Del Rio. The NFL claimed to have investigated that process but levied no penalty after finding sufficient interviews with minority candidates in addition to Gruden.
Since then, the past four NFL hiring cycles (including the current one) have produced four minority head coaches out of 24 openings. There remain five vacancies in the 2022 cycle, which has yet to see a minority coach hired in an offseason when two were fired (Flores and Houston’s David Culley). That stands in contrast with moves made at the executive level, where two of the four new general managers in the league were minority candidates.
“There’s only so much the league office can do. There’s only so much Art Rooney can do,” Mehri said of the current Steelers president and son of Dan. “I think it has to come from true, genuine commitment from the 32 [organizations]. Litigation is not good for the clubs, the league or coach Flores, so I’m hoping people will take this as an opportunity for getting more serious about this.”
Read More
The Flores story certainly is a topic of discussion in NFL circles as the offseason (for all but two teams) churns toward the Super Bowl. There’s no doubt it’s being discussed at the Senior Bowl in Mobile, Ala., where most of the league’s heavy hitters are assembled, and the East-West Shrine Bowl in Las Vegas, another showcase for draft prospects. Organizers for both college All-Star games have put an emphasis on diversity in their appointed coaches. The head coaches for both Shrine teams are Black, and more than half of the 30 assistants are minorities.
“Everyone has their own philosophy on how [improving diversity] can happen and how it can happen better,” said Robert Saleh, who just finished his first season with the Jets as the league’s first Arab-American and Muslim head coach, on Wednesday from the Senior Bowl. “I could sit here for hours and talk about our experiences here with the Jets and what we try to do, but I do think [the league office is] working diligently to try to rectify and thrust minorities into prominent roles. Is it tough right now? For sure. But I know the NFL is trying hard. And, eventually, it’s going to get there.”
Given that it comes from one of just three minority head coaches in the league currently, Saleh’s answer won’t satisfy those who see a systemic problem. He had little choice but to come up with something during a news conference as a coach of the National Team in Mobile.
“I don’t have an answer for you as to how to make it better,” said Tomlin, who’s also in Alabama but hasn’t met with reporters, to the Post-Gazette in February 2021, the last time he spoke publicly on the topic. “The optimist in me says things will get better, but there’s been no evidence in the recent cycles to back that up.” In 2020, he called the lack of diversity in new hires “a joke,” though he never has had a minority coordinator on his staff.
Several coaches at the Shrine Bowl declined comment, as one would expect. After all, most assistants in football want to make it to this level, stay there, or climb the ranks. Their paychecks have “NFL” at the top, which is what makes this measure from Flores so significant. Mehri views it “an act of courage” and would love to see more within the league stand behind him.
McDonald native and longtime former Bengals coach Marvin Lewis (now an adviser to head coach Herm Edwards at Arizona State) supported Flores’ contention of doing token interviews with little chance at a job. But Lewis is 63 and has had a long run of coaching at the highest level, something many rising stars in the business still aspire to do.
“I was surprised that the lawsuit was filed, just because there is a chance Flores won't work in the league again. There’s a substantial career risk,” said N. Jeremi Duru, a sports law professor at American University who has studied the Rooney Rule and its implications extensively.
“I was not surprised at the underlying statistics that Flores laid out in his complaint about the double standards faced by Black coaches, nor was I surprised at the allegations he made about enduring a sham interview. Because in the work that I’ve done over the course of many years, there have been many prior allegations about sham interviews and situations just like this. People just weren't prepared to go public with them, and certainly not to bring a lawsuit.”
That’s where Duru spins this forward, wondering how many other current or former NFL coaches will join Flores in his class-action suit. He has been told that there are assistants — perhaps those who are more “risk averse” — asking confidantes whether they should team up with Flores in a legal sense.
One of those considering it, reportedly, is former Cleveland head coach Hue Jackson, who alleges that Browns ownership tried to pay him to lose on purpose in 2016 and 2017, much like Flores accused the Dolphins of offering him $100,000 to tank the 2019 season. Duru also doesn’t want to overlook the impact those revelations could have across the NFL, which staunchly clings to integrity above all else.
There will be much that the league and its owners have to answer for, though the push-back has begun in earnest. League commissioner Roger Goodell categorized the claims made by Flores “without merit” in a statement disseminated swiftly upon the filing of the suit. Just as quickly, the Browns called Jackson’s comments “completely fabricated.”
Like two teams struggling for field position, Flores and his lawyers appear ready to battle it out with the NFL in court, as well as the three franchises named in the suit — the Broncos, Dolphins and Giants. Expansions of the Rooney Rule in recent years, from requiring more minority interviews to including more positions (general manager and coordinator jobs) have gotten some results, but has it been enough?
What the Rooney Rule can’t account for is a team’s front office having their sights set on a particular coach who’s best for the job, and if it happens to be a white person, their conversations with minority candidates won’t feel quite right.
A complaint in the lawsuit, for example, states that the Giants decided to hire Brian Daboll — who is white — as their new head coach before even conducting their interview with Flores.
“It’s tough when you’re going into a job, and [people] go, ‘This guy is a favorite for a job’ and before you ever walk into an interview, you’re fighting an uphill battle,” Steelers secondary coach and senior defensive assistant Teryl Austin, who is Black, told the Associated Press in October. “That’s something that has to change.”
“One thing I hope people should recognize is that the Rooney Rule works, but it has to be operationalized in good faith, and it has to have some teeth behind it,” Mehri said. “It has worked and will work. But I think it kind of fell off track because [teams] thought, ‘Hey, we don’t have to worry about this anymore.’”
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.