CLEVELAND — People doubting him, shortchanging him and questioning whether he belonged — T.J. McConnell had been through this before in his basketball career, going back to his high school days.

But this time it was especially hard to take.

It was last October, the day before McConnell was to begin his ninth NBA season, when Indiana Pacers coach Rick Carlisle called McConnell into his office to grudgingly inform him that he wouldn’t be part of the team’s player rotation and might not play much. Then, in the first nine games of the season, McConnell never got off the bench in four of them.

“There were some tough days obviously,” McConnell said. “It’s a long season, but doubt does creep in and you think about maybe being out of the rotation permanently. I just tried to stay positive as a teammate, kept working my butt off and controlling what I can control.”

Advertise with us

A half-year later, McConnell has proven once again how to survive and thrive.

The Pacers and McConnell are getting ready to begin the NBA playoffs Sunday for the first time since 2020, and McConnell has authored one of the bigger turnaround stories in the league this season. A former Chartiers Valley High School star who played for his father, Tim, and was one of the WPIAL’s best players in the past 50 years, McConnell has gone from a possible afterthought with the Pacers this season to having the best regular season in his career.

McConnell’s unlikely story of suburban Pittsburgh kid making it in the NBA was already interesting but has gotten even better this season. His statistics are at an all-time high, particularly since late February. He has been called the best backup point guard in the NBA by a few players. He is a finalist for the NBA Teammate of the Year award. He has become a fan favorite in Indianapolis and a treasured teammate in the locker room. And get this: Even LeBron James has noticed. Last week, on James’ “Mind the Game” podcast with former NBA player JJ Redick, James used the “favorite” word to describe Timothy John McConnell.

“One of my favorite players in the NBA right now is T.J. McConnell,” James said. “T.J. McConnell is like Draymond [Green of the Golden State Warriors] as a point guard.”

So McConnell has gone from maybe not playing much this season to getting kudos from the King. McConnell got a signed jersey from James years ago after a game when McConnell asked for it. When asked if there was a jersey exchange, McConnell chuckled and said, “No, I don’t think he asked for mine for some reason. ... For him to say what he said about me, especially from a player of his caliber, I obviously was humbled by it.”

Advertise with us

But humility is evident in McConnell every time he takes the court. He and his wife, Val, now have two young boys, ages 3 and 6 months. When McConnell enters the game, he touches a small tattoo on his right wrist with his wife’s name. Then he touches a tattoo under his right bicep that has the names of his two sons, Trace and Mack. Then he touches under his left bicep that has a tattoo with the names of his brother and sister, Matty and Megan. Then he points up to the sky before reaching down to touch the court with both hands.

“I reach up to the sky,” McConnell told the Post-Gazette before a game at the Cleveland Cavaliers last Friday, “and then touch the floor just to thank God for everything and for just letting me touch an NBA floor.”

Changed player

Only nine players in the history of the WPIAL, City League or old Catholic League have played longer than McConnell in the NBA or old ABA. But McConnell has been doubted at many places in his career, even before college. Too small. Not good enough. Will never make it. They were all thrown McConnell’s way over the years. The basketball court has been one big proving ground for McConnell.

When T.J. McConnell was a freshman at Chartiers Valley, many thought he would be too small to ever make it big in basketball. He's now in his ninth NBA season. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

He spent his first four years in the NBA with the Philadelphia 76ers, but then went to the Pacers as a free agent. He has had plenty of good moments in his career, like a couple triple-doubles and setting an NBA record for steals in a half of a game a few years ago. But then came the beginning of this season and the crushing news that he probably wouldn’t play much, if at all. But with some movement of players and the way McConnell performed when given a chance, Carlisle found he couldn’t keep McConnell off the court. His energy was infectious as the Pacers finished as the No. 6 seed in the Eastern Conference and will play the Milwaukee Bucks in a seven-game first-round playoff series.

But McConnell has transformed into a different player this season, especially in the past few months. He’s not a pass-first point guard as much anymore. He shoots with regularity, and his mid-range jumper is money. For his career, he has averaged 7.5 points and 5.1 assists per game. But these facts tell you he is a different player.

Advertise with us

• In 26 games after the All-Star break, McConnell averaged 13.8 points while attempting 11 shots per game.

• He shot 58% since the break, and his overall shooting percentage of 55.5% for the season is 17th best in the NBA. That percentage also was No. 1 among the league’s point guards.

• He was second in assists by a bench player at 5.5 per game, behind only future Hall of Famer Chris Paul.

• McConnell’s 3-point shooting percentage also rose. He doesn’t take many but made 60% (15 of 25) in the final 26 games.

“It’s not like I never scored in my life,” said McConnell, who scored 2,404 points at Chartiers Valley. “I changed my game a lot over the years, from high school to college and obviously to here [in the NBA]. But I know how to score. It was just a matter of getting to my spots and finding ways to be creative to score. I think my teammates deserve a lot of the credit. Obviously, the confidence is there, too. But when you’re empowered by the coaching staff and players to shoot more, that certainly helps.”

Advertise with us

Jenny Boucek is in her first year as one of the Pacers top assistant coaches and has been overly impressed with McConnell.

“This [scoring and shooting] is in his roots,” Boucek said. “The thing is: Did he ever think this is what a team wanted from him? No. But he’s in a place now where he’s developed another level of confidence in his shot. It’s been reinvigorated and it’s good for the team.”

Boucek has worked extensively with McConnell on his shot. She is one who believes McConnell’s talents are often overlooked because of his hustle and intensity.

“To me, humility is not you thinking less of yourself but thinking about yourself less. That’s what he does, but he understands and accepts what his strengths are,” Boucek said. “He has loads of talent. He’s super quick, he jumps, he’s smart and he anticipates things. He’s always been super tough, but there has been another level of toughness that has emerged from his year — mentally and emotionally because of what he went through. I think that’s another reason for his jump. He’s continuing to prove people wrong. He’s done it his whole life.”

T.J. McConnell has become a fan favorite with the Indiana Pacers. McConnell signs autographs for fans after last Friday's Pacers game at the Cleveland Cavaliers (Mike White / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

‘Everyone loves T.J.’

It’s not uncommon for McConnell to talk to fans in the stands during a game and also opposing players, usually with a smile. McConnell is one of 12 finalists for the NBA’s Twyman-Stokes Teammate of the Year award. Doug McDermott is in his second go ’round with the Pacers and McConnell.

Advertise with us

“I think he should be up for Sixth Man of the Year, in my opinion,” McDermott said. “He’s like a microwave scorer off the bench now.

“Everyone loves T.J. He has a great ability to connect with people. He can be hilarious. He’s an easy target for us, but he can give it back, too.”

McDermott said he could see McConnell being a coach someday. McConnell isn’t so sure about that.

“You’ll have to ask my wife at my retirement party,” McConnell said with a smile. “As players, we are away from our families a lot. I obviously want to raise my kids and spend a lot of time with them. It’s something we have to think about.”

McConnell, who has one year left on his contract with the Pacers, was asked if he would ever consider returning to Pittsburgh and coaching high school basketball.

Advertise with us

“Honestly,” he said, “I might do that.”

But for now, there are NBA playoffs.

T.J.’s tenure

T.J. McConnell is in his ninth season in the NBA. Only nine players ever from the WPIAL, City League or old Catholic League have played more seasons than McConnell in the NBA or old ABA (Source: basketball-reference.com)

YRS - NAME, SCHOOL - YEARS

15 Brad Davis, Monaca 1978-92

Advertise with us

14 Maurice Lucas, Schenley 1975-88

13 Armen Gilliam, Bethel Park 1988-2000

11 Billy Knight, Braddock 1975-85

11 Freddie Lewis, McKeesport 1967-77

11 Jack Marin, Farrell 1956-66

Advertise with us

11 Jack Twyman, Central Catholic 1956-66

10 Dan Fortson, Shaler 1998-2007

10 Norm Van Lier, Midland 1970-79

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and @mwhiteburgh on X