ATLANTA — There had been 94 MLB All-Star games played prior to Tuesday evening. None of them featured an ending similar to what unfolded in the 2025 mid-summer classic.
Tied at six after nine innings of play, the event went into its first-ever swing-off, ultimately resulting in a victory for the National League.
So what exactly is a swing-off?
A tie-breaker format that became available in 2022, managers from both the American and National leagues select three players on the roster to participate in a post-regulation home run contest. Each hitter gets three swings, and the team with the highest combined home run total at the end wins.
“It was a lot of fun,” Dodgers manager Dave Roberts, who managed this year’s National League All-Star team, said. “The cool thing is we got to see the players were all into it, too, which was fun.”
The National League won the first-ever swing-off by a final of 4-3. Roberts selected Kyle Stowers (Marlins), Kyle Schwarber (Phillies) and Pete Alonso (Mets) as his trio, which was opposed by Brent Rooker (Athletics), Randy Arozarena (Mariners) and Jonathan Aranda (Rays).
“You pick your guys yesterday and you kind of run it by them and you don't really think it's in play,” Boone said when asked about the process after the game. “All of a sudden, here we go, and you're running through the rules with them. It's just the three swings. So first time of it, a lot of pressure. Rook got us off to a great start, but I thought it was pretty exciting.”
Read More
The showdown’s turning point came in the second round when Schwarber, a Home Run Derby finalist in 2018, mashed a long ball in all three swings, putting his side ahead for good. Aranda had a chance to respond, but failed to leave the yard in his round, securing the National League victory. Schwarber was named the game’s Most Valuable Player for his efforts. Due to the game’s unique outcome, there was no winning or losing pitcher.
“I was just saying there's a lot of guys who are way more deserving of this award, but just happy that it's going to be — we get a win with the National League and it's going to come home with us to Philly,” Schwarber said afterward.
Earlier in the evening ...
Plenty of entertaining baseball also occurred before the swing-off.
The game started with some hometown flavor. Pirates’ right-hander Paul Skenes struck out the first two batters, Gleyber Torres and Riley Greene of the Detroit Tigers, before getting Yankees superstar Aaron Judge to ground out, concluding a perfect frame. Skenes’ efforts were rewarded in the bottom half of the frame, via a two-run double from Diamondbacks second baseman Ketel Marte off American League starter and Tigers ace Tarik Skubal.
“Just a little bit more comfortable, it was hotter and it was later,” Skenes said when asked how his second All-Star game start differed from the first. “And the hitters were different. That was about it.”
The National League extended its lead in the bottom of the sixth inning, thanks to a pair of home runs — the first being a three-run bomb from Alonso and the second being a solo shot from Diamondbacks outfielder Corbin Carroll. But a six-run lead was not enough to put the American League away.
Boone’s boys came storming back in the seventh, scoring four runs in the top half. Three of those tallies came on a home run from Rooker. The fourth was driven home on a groundout by Royals shortstop Bobby Witt Jr. Witt Jr. struck again in the top of the ninth, driving home his team’s fifth run with a double off Padres closer Robert Suarez. He then came around to score later in the frame on a two-out infield hit by Guardians outfielder Steven Kwan.
Mets closer Edwin Diaz prevented any further damage, keeping the score tied at six heading into the bottom of the ninth. Former Pirate and current Red Sox Aroldis Chapman then threw a scoreless frame, setting the stage for Schwarber’s heroics.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.