ATLANTA — With narratives of significant financial change potentially on the horizon for MLB, Tony Clark, the executive director of the MLB Players Association, made a few pointed statements Tuesday — the most notable being his clear opposition to a salary cap.

“Let’s be very clear,” Clark said during a private brunch with members of the Baseball Writers Association of America (BBWAA). “A cap is not a partnership, it’s not about growing the game. That’s not what a cap is about, as is what’s been offered to the public. A cap is about franchise values and profits. That’s what a cap is about. A salary cap, historically, has limited contract guarantees, literally pits one player against another, and is often what we share as the definitive non-competitive system.”

“It doesn’t reward excellence,” he added. “It undermines it from an organizational standpoint. That’s why this is not about competitive balance. It’s not about a fair versus not. This is institutionalized collusion.

“That’s what a salary cap is. And so, we don’t know what it is they’re going to propose, we know what it is they’re saying. We’ll get in a room and see what they propose. But once you are in that system, history suggests that whatever players may be receiving on Day 1, they may not be receiving on Day 2. The history is more lockouts, more work stoppages as a result of that system being in place.”

Advertise with us

Unlike other major sports leagues such as the NFL, NBA and NHL, MLB has no hard limit on what a franchise can spend on player payroll.

While the league currently has a luxury tax system in place which aims to prevent big-market clubs from dramatically outspending others located in smaller cities, a notable portion of baseball fans still believe that a large financial divide exists, one that prohibits teams from small-to-medium media markets from having a true chance of being able to afford a consistently competitive roster.

MLB commissioner Rob Manfred echoed as much Tuesday when he spoke at the same brunch after Clark’s availability came to an end. Although the commissioner did not openly endorse the idea of a salary cap, he did express his desire to change the league’s economic structure.

“When I talk to the players, I don’t try to convince them of a salary cap system,” Manfred said. “What I say to them is that I identify a problem in the media business and explain to them that owners need to change to address that problem.

“I then identify a second problem that we need to work on together, and that is there are fans in a lot of our markets who feel like we have a competitive balance problem. I never use the word ‘salary’ within one of ‘cap.’ What I do say to them is, in addressing this competitive issue that’s real, we should think about whether this system is the perfect system from a player’s perspective.”

Advertise with us

Per FanGraphs, there are currently six teams — Dodgers, Mets, Yankees, Phillies, Blue Jays and Rangers — that boast a payroll three times the size as the league’s lowest spender, the Miami Marlins ($70 million). The wide gap between the haves and have nots serves as the key area of contention between the players union and league owners as the league’s collective bargaining agreement is set to expire on December 1, 2026.

Clark argues this issue can be resolved without a salary cap.

“We have a lot of confidential information that I recognize most don’t have, that nobody has,” Clark said. “So when we say that all teams can compete and they’re choosing not to, it’s based on the information that we have.

“And based on the information that we have and the proposals that we made, in this particular revenue-sharing area, we believe there are ways to incentivize and provide support to those who are in a different market than LA or New York. There’s an opportunity to do that, and do so in a way that benefits the group and doesn’t require a restriction on player’s salaries.”

However, Clark also contends that the league is not open to alternative suggestions, which he believes will ultimately lead to a lockout come December 2026.

Advertise with us

“There are no illusions of grandeur here in regard to what it is we’re hearing and what it is the other interest of the other side seems to be,” Clark said. “As a result, players are being told as much. Players are working through ... making sure they understand and appreciate what the issues are and what the concerns are, and making sure above and beyond everything else that we get their feedback in regards to what’s most important to them.

“ ... We may find ourselves in a work stoppage at 12:01 a.m., December 1 of next year. They’re preparing for that while hoping that is indeed not the case. I mentioned a good, fair and equitable deal. Our job at the bargaining table and our goal at the bargaining table never changes. What changes is the rhetoric that is out there. In this instance, when they are highlighting what they are interested in, you should believe them. … It begs the question of whether or not we’re going to have a good faith negotiation. That remains to be seen. If somebody tells you they’re going to lock you out a year-and-a-half out, rather than sitting down at the table and seeing if we can figure our way through that, those are two different conversations. So players know that, hear that and understand that.”

Manfred refuted Clark’s claim that the league desires a cap, saying his only hope heading into next year’s negotiations is that players enter without a preconceived result.

“My only goal is not to convince them of one system among others,” Manfred said. “It’s to convince them to actually go to the table with an open mind and try to address a problem that is fan-driven, which leads to a better collective bargaining process and a better company.”