ATLANTA — Major League Baseball’s All-Star game gives fans plenty of reasons to tune in each year, and this edition is no different. The 2025 mid-summer classic will feature the use of the automated ball-strike challenge system (ABS).
Similar to what became available this past spring training in the Grapefruit League, both teams start each game with two challenges. If a challenge is successful, a team gets to keep its challenge. If it’s unsuccessful, the challenge is lost. No extra challenges are provided if a contest reaches extra innings.
Only a batter, catcher, or pitcher can issue a challenge, which must be issued immediately after the pitch. Upon issuing the challenge, the game will be paused, and a video graphic will be displayed on the stadium’s video board, either confirming or overturning the call.
The ABS system has been present in the minor leagues for years, working its way to Triple-A in 2024. Per USA Today, 51% of the challenged calls in Triple-A were overturned last season.
A handful of the game’s top stars weighed in on the review process Monday, during the All-Star media day. Below is a summary of their comments.
Aces aren’t invested
Tigers’ left-hander Tarik Skubal and Pirates’ right-hander Paul Skenes, the two starting pitchers in this year’s All-Star game, were asked for their thoughts on ABS during a press conference Monday afternoon. Neither ace seemed overwhelmingly enthralled with the concept.
Read More
“I don't plan on using them,” Skubal said of the challenges available in this year’s mid-summer classic. “I probably am not going to use them in the future. I'm going to let the catcher do that. I have this thing where I think everything is a strike until the umpire calls it a ball. With how good guys are behind the plate, Cal will be really good behind the plate. I don't know the strike zone a ton.
“But I guess there are some pitches that you think are strikes and you want them back, but I also think it's part of the game, and I love the human element of the game. I think maybe some other guys don't. But, yeah, those are my thoughts on it. I don't plan on using it, though.”
“Pretty much want to echo what Tarik said,” Skenes said. “Pitchers think everything is a strike. Then you go back and look at it, and it's two, three balls off. So we should not be the ones that are challenging it. I really do like the human element of the game. I think this is one of those things that you kind of think umpires are great until they're not. And so I could kind of care less, either way, to be honest.”
Other arms interested
While Skubal and Skenes had little to say, another All-Star pitcher had a different outlook. Padres’ reliever Jason Adam offered the following on the challenge system.
“I’m good with it,” Adam said. “I think there are pros and cons. You don’t want the game ending on a challenge, obviously, but if you’re the beneficiary, I guess you do want it. It’s good to get it right.
“The amount of times where I’ve thrown a ball right down the middle and thought ‘Oh, that was a ball,’ or vice versa where I’m thinking ‘how did you miss that,’ and I go and look and see it was like two balls outside the zone, tells me that I would be a terrible umpire.”
When asked if he was concerned that the implementation of ABS would change how baseball is played, Adam seemed OK with such sacrifices.
“It will change things for catchers,” Adam said. “Obviously, there will be a lot of unintended consequences, but it’s coming, so like it or not, we’ll just have to adjust.”
Hitter’s POV
So how do the hitters feel? The Post-Gazette spoke with a pair of All-Star designated hitters — Kyle Schwarber from the Phillies and Ryan O’Hearn from the Orioles — to learn how ABS would impact their efforts at the plate.
Schwarber, drafted as a catcher out of Indiana, was very receptive to the review system, noting that it would provide additional strategy to the game.
“I feel like on the pitching side, you’re probably going to want your catcher to be the one challenging pitches, just because they’re so good at making things look like strikes,” Schwarber said. “I think that’s now another added thing on the catcher, where they’re gonna have to understand who’s hitting and what their zone is. You could have Aaron Judge or Jose Altuve at the plate, you’re gonna have to know their zone up and down.
“I feel like it will be a different challenge, and it will be that way for hitters, too. I think what you’d see, too, is the emotional challenge, the strike three that you think is probably not there, but was a strike, and you lose your challenge. I think there has to be a balance there, where you have to be strategic with your challenges.”
As far as catcher development is concerned, Schwarber wasn’t willing to go as far as Adam, saying he feels pitch framing will still have a future in the game, even when ABS inevitably arrives.
“You have to think when those calls do come out, those umpires do have full reign over the balls and strikes again,” Schwarber said. “So, you don’t want to lose that value with the catcher, just for the fact that you have an automated zone. I don’t think it should change the way that they view the position, just because there are still going to be aspects that can come up and help impact the game.”
No robo umps
O’Hearn, similar to Schwarber, was a fan of ABS. But the Orioles’ slugger was quick to express that the strike calling technology should remain a challenge-based system, rather than replacing umpires entirely.
“I think the challenge system is a good happy medium,” O’Hearn said. “I don’t want to completely take out the human element. I think there is something to be said for that. But at the same time, if there is a big spot in the game, where one strike or ball could change the game, I think the player should have the ability to challenge a call. The challenge system is a great compromise."
Schwarber echoed O’Hearn, also expressing the importance of maintaining the game’s human element.
“I like having an umpire,” Schwarber said. “I like having the human error part of the game. Obviously, it’s unfortunate when it impacts a big situation, a big pitch, but I guess I’m just a classic baseball guy, right?
“It’s just the way the game has been played.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.