Chris Holtmann had heard the question before, from friends, family, other coaches. Often it was accompanied by a quizzical look.
So when he was asked Wednesday why he left a head coaching position at Gardner-Webb, a Division I school, for an assistant job at Butler two years ago, he had his answer ready.
"Butler's Butler."
The name, the brand, the school had a special meaning to Holtmann, even though he had no direct ties to the Butler program before joining in 2013. Holtmann, 43, will coach his first NCAA tournament game as a head coach today as the Bulldogs take on Texas at Consol Energy Center.
His closest tie was serving as an assistant at Ohio University under John Groce, who was an assistant for the Bulldogs in 2000-01 under former coach Thad Matta.
"When you get hired at Butler, that's what everybody looks for: Are you a good guy?" said assistant Terry Johnson, who has been with the team since 2007. "He's a good guy, and he works. It's not about him."
Holtmann's nature allowed him to fit in with a program that has become defined by "The Butler Way" over the past decade, a set of principles that led to back-to-back NCAA title game appearances under former coach Brad Stevens in 2010 and 2011.
But things got a bit more challenging in October, when head coach Brandon Miller, who replaced Stevens in 2013, took a medical leave of absence to deal with an undisclosed condition.
Holtmann was appointed interim head coach and led the Bulldogs to a 10-4 start to the season, complete with wins against North Carolina and Georgetown.
On Jan. 2, Miller's leave from the university became permanent, and Holtmann had the interim tag removed. In his first game as full-time head coach, Butler beat then-No. 15 St. John's, 73-69, on the road.
"It was tough," senior forward Kameron Woods said. "We went into the season with a lot of uncertainty as to who was going to run the program and lead us. I give a lot of credit to coach Holtmann and a lot of the staff because he came in as an interim up front and really got us going in the right direction."
The Bulldogs, who ended last year ninth in the 10-team Big East, exceeded almost every expectation this year. They finished tied for second this season and earned a No. 6 seed in the NCAA tournament.
Along the way, Butler players watched their coach grow into his new role.
"At the beginning, he was kind of shaky," Woods said. "He led us in a great way, but you could see there were some days there was just a lot on his shoulders.
"After we got a couple early wins, he settled in, really started to coach with a lot of passion, the way he wants to, and we've responded well to it."
For his part, Holtmann credited his players -- particularly guard Roosevelt Jones, who returned from an injury that cost him the 2013-14 season.
"I think our team chemistry is significantly better, and sometimes that's hard to put a finger on," Holtmann said. "We were able to, this year, win some close games in the guts of the season that we lost last year."
The man orchestrating that chemistry, though, is Holtmann. Today will mark the first time since 2007 the Bulldogs will play in the NCAA tournament with someone other than Stevens on the sideline.
Johnson, though, insists Stevens doesn't cast a shadow on the program.
"With all the coaching changes, the one thing that hasn't changed is the foundation," he said. "The values that this place has been built on. It's still the same no matter who's the head coach, and that's what keeps this thing going in the right direction."
Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.