Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Larry Foote and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him at @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Skip Bittman, @skip_bittman: Will Steeler Nation be satisfied if next week the Steelers play a close competitive game but lose?
Starkey: Man, what a great question, Dr. Bittman. And I’m wavering. In some ways it already feels like a successful season because of that phenomenal win over the Ravens to clinch the division. You’ll remember where you were for that one.
What might be lost there is that the Steelers were 4-1 at one point, while the Ravens were 1-5. Also, all the Steelers had to do was beat the Cleveland Browns — who just fired their coach — to clinch the AFC North a week earlier and not have to go through all that.
So when you really think about it, the least they could have done was win a largely broken AFC North. Any other result would have been somewhat disastrous, considering the circumstances. The real season starts now.
The idea here — as far as I know — is to win playoff games, or at least come close for once. The Steelers have been outscored 73-0 in the first quarters of their current six-game playoff losing streak. Think about that.
Read More
And one could argue that the closest they have come to winning any of those games was cutting a two-touchdown Bills lead in Buffalo to a seven-point lead with 10:32 left in regulation. The Bills then marched 70 yards in eight plays — without ever reaching third down — to go up 14 again. They then missed a 27-yard field goal, or the final would have been 34-17 instead of 31-17.
If you call that competitive, great. No clear-thinking person thought the Steelers were going to win that game at any point. The other “close” one was a 45-42 loss to Jacksonville, but that was a 10-point game before the Steelers scored a junk touchdown with one second left.
So yes, while I cannot speak for “Steeler Nation,” I’d love to see a game where they actually threaten to win. That would be an improvement. But in order to call this a successful season, they need to actually WIN a playoff game.
The irony in all this is that while Mike Tomlin does indeed have a 19-year non-losing streak, his all-time playoff record is 8-11.
Win a playoff game (and I think he will).
J, @Crossland895: Hello, Joe, How far could the 2nd half version of Aaron Rodgers take this team? Bonus: Is there still time for the Tyler Loop missed field goal to be called The Acri-shank?
Starkey: I prefer the “Looper Blooper,” but your idea isn’t bad, Dr. 895. And this version of Rodgers could take any team on a run. Aside from the Cleveland game, he has been that good of late, and he is now comfortable with his receiving group. He has two good running backs, a good offensive line and adequate enough weaponry now that DK Metcalf is back.
Nolan in New Ken, @nolan_in_NK: Blessed Morning, Joe! The Browns and possibly Ravens having openings at Head Coach guarantees (among other things) nothing happens to Tomlin no matter Monday's outcome, correct?
Starkey: I’m not sure those things are related, Dr. Nolan, but it seems certain that Tomlin will return as coach for his 20th season no matter what, yes. And it always did. A better question might be whether Art Rooney II will trigger the option on Tomlin’s contract for 2027. The smart bet there is yes, as well.
Also, the reporting out there seems to indicate that while John Harbaugh might be forced to make some big staff changes, he is likely to return as coach.
Big Sam 2003, @Big_Sam2003: In the 4 major sports, at the highest level, where does coaching have the most impact? My non-expert guess is (1) football, (2) hockey, (3) baseball, (4) basketball. What do you think?
Starkey: I’d put baseball behind basketball, Big Sam, but otherwise we agree. Football coaches can literally choreograph the game, to some degree. Hockey coaches are constantly looking for the right matchups and right situational units to put on the ice.
In baseball, it seems setting the day-to-day culture is the most important task for a manager. Obviously, managing a bullpen is a big part of it, too.
With basketball, and with all coaching, setting the culture is a huge deal, but so is having a knack for getting the rotation right and putting the right groups on the floor — plus changing defenses at the right time, hunting matchups to exploit, etc. There might be more to it than you are thinking.
Ed Helinski, @MrEd315: In your opinion, where does Sunday night’s win against Baltimore rank in the Mike Tomlin era in Steelers history?
Starkey: It’s up there, Mr. Ed, in terms of regular-season wins. I think of Santonio Holmes at the goal line in Baltimore, and Antonio Brown at the goal line against Baltimore, and Ben beating the Ravens late with a broken nose.
Seems like a lot of his biggest wins have come against the Ravens, yes?
There have been plenty of others — a 52-21 smashup of the defending NFC-champion Carolina Panthers in 2018 springs to mind, as does the Ben Roethlisberger-Andrew Luck shootout, plus a couple of bone-crunching early season wins in Cincinnati against Joe Burrow and in Buffalo against Josh Allen, not to mention the win a few weeks ago in Detroit. That was an incredible game.
Perhaps we should put together a list, yes?
PittHeel, @BuStA607: With the lack of outrage at the state of Pitt basketball and dwindling attendance, should athletic director Allen Greene be concerned that people are losing interest in the program and make a change?
Starkey: Greene should definitely be concerned, Dr. 607. The program seems to be running in place and has yet to reach any hint of consistent excellence under Jeff Capel, who is now in Year 8 with just one NCAA tournament appearance.
It’s hard to tell with attendance thus far, because of the holidays and students not around, but there were fewer than 7,000 fans present for the ACC home opener against Clemson and just 8,191 for the Penn State game. This feels like a big stretch for Capel.
Papillon, @Captn_Pap: When Skenes met with Allen, who was the superior athlete in that moment? Why?
Starkey: Yes, Paul Skenes did meet Josh Allen, Dr. Pap, and this is a difficult question.
I’d say Skenes right now. I think he’s the best pitcher in baseball and on his way to maybe becoming a top-five pitcher in history. Allen isn’t far behind, though, and neither one of them has a ton around him in terms of star power (although Allen does have James Cook).
ed dice, @ediceman: Had boz made the extra point would the ravens have tried harder at the end of the game and won or tied?
Starkey: You don’t think they tried hard at the end, Dr. dice? It was kind of odd that Lamar Jackson gave up two yards on the final clock-stop play. I would have run another play and called timeout just to get closer (as opposed to farther), but I doubt the Ravens would have had time to go for the win there if the score had been tied.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.