Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Larry Foote and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him at @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions ...
Adam, @ak100892: Do you believe the Pirates are “in” on all of these guys or are their PR people working overtime? Hopefully for Nutting’s sake, they’re not paid by the hour!
Starkey: Great question, Dr. ak100892. And I can’t help but wonder if what is actually happening is more like this: Say I’m at an auction, and I know for a fact Mr. Smith (a very rich man) is going to bid $10,000 for a precious Juan Thornhill photo (one of the best photos in history, I might add).
If I keep bidding up to $9,000, am I really serious about wanting the photo, or am I just trying to impress people?
So yes, I’ll believe the Pirates are serious about Kyle Schwarber and any other high-impact free agent when they actually deliver the baby. It’s wonderful that reports tell us they might have gone over $100 million in their offer to Schwarber.
Problem is, we all know it could take $150 million to sign him.
Read More
Deliver the baby.
And by the way, there are plenty of much more affordable bats out there.
(Editor’s note: After publishing, Schwarber reportedly agreed to a $150M deal with the Phillies)
Adam, @ak100892: Every AFC team, including the Steelers, have massive question marks. Dare I say, I may have a sliver of hope that the Steelers may win a playoff game? Or will I end up like George Costanza? Picking myself up, dusting myself off, and throwing myself right back down again?
Starkey: I think your feeling is perfectly understandable, Dr. 892. As I wrote Monday, if you give me a functional or even good quarterback, plus healthy playmakers on defense, the Steelers are absolutely capable of winning a playoff game in this weakened AFC.
Dave Mikesell, @mikesell_dave: If the Steelers hold onto the 4th seed, who are the best and worst WC round matchups? I don’t want any part of Houston, they might shut the Steelers out.
Starkey: The Steelers also could shut out Houston, Dr. D, but I do believe the Texans have the best defense in the NFL. It seems right now like the best bets to visit for a playoff game, assuming the Steelers win the AFC North, are the Chargers, Bills, Texans or Jaguars.
Best matchup: Jags.
Worst matchup: Bills.
I usually go by quarterbacks, and I wouldn’t want any part of Josh Allen in a rematch. I know Justin Herbert is really good, but the Chargers are banged up. Trevor Lawrence doesn’t frighten me, and as I said, Houston’s offense just isn’t good.
Scoops, @Scoops1616: Dr. Starkey, you have so many incrinculent words. Please bless us with a new term to describe the propaganda and pure fiction of the Pirates being “this close” to signing a real free agent!
Starkey: I still think they might sign a real one, Dr. Scoops — depending on your definition of “real.” But it won’t be Schwarber. And as I mentioned, I’ll believe any “real” signing when I see it.
I’ll try to think of a term for you.
J, @Crossland895: Many blessings, Joe How far can the version of Aaron Rodgers we saw on Sunday take this team?
Starkey: See above, Dr. 895. I’m not betting on it, by any means, but the version we saw Sunday — as opposed to the previous three games — could win a playoff game.
Thing is, great athletes often show flashes of their previous selves late in their careers but cannot maintain it.
Dom DiTommaso, @DomDiTommaso: Who's the best in-game analyst in the NFL?
Starkey: Tom Brady by far, and thank you for asking, Dom. How is your 11th year at Syracuse going?
james hoey, @JhhoeyJame: Do anthem singers get paid? I like Jeff Jimmerson and to answer Dom I think Cris Collinsworth is good even though everyone hates him.
Starkey: Good morning, Dr. Hoey. My understanding — and I’m still making phone calls — is that anthem singers do get paid. I do not know how much. Collinsworth is annoying but good. Maybe it’s his voice. But a lot of people hate my voice, too.
Burke O’Toole, @BurkeMan513: Dr Starkey if you had to bet your life savings on the Pen, Steelers, Pirates. Which one would you bet to win a playoff game/series this season?
Starkey: Gotta be the Steelers at this point, Dr. 513. They are closing in on a home playoff game. That’s not a prediction, by any means, but you asked a question and I gave you the obvious answer.
PittHeel, @BuStA607: Would Philip Rivers be the first grandfather to ever play in the NFL?
Starkey: According to Yahoo Sports, he’d be the second, Der. 607. Brett Favre was the first.
PaulSkenesSzn, @PaulSkenesSzn: What does holy horse milk mean?
Starkey: There is no meaning, Dr. Szn. It’s like “gadzoots” or some other such word or phrase. It’s more about the sounds than the meaning. Like a great piece of art, it means whatever you want it to mean. Same with incrinculent and “holy ostrich milk.”
Thank you for asking.
Fred U., @FredUlmer: Why is Tony Romo the worst in game analyst?
Starkey: He was great at first, then unbelievably annoying, now less annoying, Dr. Ulmer. That’s how I see it. I don’t think he’s the worst analyst by any means. It seems like either Romo or J.J. Watt is on every Steelers game — and that’s not so bad. Watt has a good sense of humor and knows the game. I think he’s pretty good. You?
BondJBond, @aintthequestn: Joe, Why is it that over the past year and a half we notice Offensive Tackles moving early… to the point that very few penalties are called on them??
Starkey: I think the trend started way before that, Dr. Bond. Go back and watch highlights of the Rams-Bengals Super Bowl, and you’ll see it on many snaps. I haven’t seen anybody officially acknowledge that tackles have been granted leeway there, but, like you and millions of others, I think it’s obvious.
And the obvious explanation would be that the league wants to give a tiny bit more protection to its biggest stars — quarterbacks.
Here’s the story of one tackle who wants us to believe he wasn’t jumping the gun.
Ed Helinski, @MrEd315: What should the Steelers, Pens and Pirates be asking for Christmas from Santa?
Starkey:
Steelers — a playoff win (or least a competitive game)
Penguins — a playoff spot
Pirates — Kyle Schwarber (and he won’t fit in a stocking)






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.