Remember the disastrous Pitt coaching searches that resulted in Michael Haywood coaching the football team (for about 10 seconds) and Kevin Stallings coaching the basketball team?
Those look like strokes of genius compared to what is happening at Penn State, where athletic director Pat Kraft has been rejected more times than Steve Carell in “The 40-Year-Old Virgin.”
The situation has devolved to the point where Brian Daboll is being mentioned as a candidate.
Who’s next, Freddie Kitchens?
You might have seen the headlines Wednesday, the first day of college football’s early signing period, as Penn State’s Class of 2026 disappeared into thin air. It ranks last in the Big Ten and toward the bottom in the country. At one point, it consisted of two players. Maybe they could start a pickleball team.
I guess this is what happens when you don’t have a coach.
Read More
To make matters infinitely more embarrassing, 11 of Penn State’s recruits wound up at Virginia Tech, where fired Nittany Lions coach James Franklin now works.
As ESPN put it, “The fall of 2025 began with Franklin poised to lead Penn State to the mountain top. It ended with him on a campus 366 miles away signing nearly 50% of what was supposed to be the Nittany Lions' 2026 class.”
Mortifying as that might be, let’s stop here and get one thing straight: A lot of people think Pat gaffed when he fired Franklin back in October — assuming it was Kraft and not powers above him — but that situation had become untenable. Franklin had to go.
In a year where Franklin himself said he had the best roster and staff of his 12-year tenure — including $3 million defensive coordinator Jim Knowles — the Nittany Lions became the first top-10 team in 40 years to lose to an 0-4 team (UCLA).
If you don’t believe that was a fireable offense, then tell me what losing at home to Northwestern the next week was.
I’ll tell you what it was: The first time in 30 years that an FBS team lost back-to-back games as a 20-point favorite (24.5 against UCLA). And those losses came after yet another big-game setback for small-game James — the 30-24 loss to Oregon.
By any definition, the stretch marked one of the worst collapses of any preseason top-five team in college football history. That’s all. Combine it with all the other sordid Franklin numbers, and the Mike Greenbergs of the world can go fly a Kraft.
This is what ESPN’s Greenberg tweeted the other day, echoing the sentiments of many as Penn State remains unable to land a coach: “The lesson of what appears to be a disaster at Penn State is simple: Don’t react emotionally in times of trouble and make decisions that you don’t know where they may lead. Because right now, James Franklin would be their best option.”
Yes, well, their “best option” was 1-15 against AP top-five teams, 4-21 against top-10 teams, 16-29 against top-25 teams, 1-10 against Ohio State, 3-7 against Michigan and 1-8 against top-10 teams at home. Then came UCLA and Northwestern.
Franklin had lost the fan base. I can’t imagine donors were far behind. It was time. Franklin deserved to be fired, in October or later. Kraft has mangled the replacement process. Both can be true.
Most of us — meaning the entire football world — assumed Kraft had a Plan A. He didn’t. Nor did he have a Plan B, C, LMNOP, X or Z.
What is this man doing?
Penn State figured to get a jump on the new hire, well before the early signing period and the transfer portal season, which begins in January. Kraft and his bosses likely figured Penn State’s prestige would have big names knocking on their door.
Instead, prospective candidates left and right seemingly used Penn State as leverage for more money at their current schools. Indiana’s Curt Cignetti, Nebraska’s Matt Rhule, Texas A&M’s Mike Elko, BYU's Kalani Sitake and Missouri’s Eli Drinkwitz all got extensions after being rumored as Penn State candidates.
Louisville's Jeff Brohm told his school he’s not leaving, Georgia Tech's Brent Key got extended and Ohio State offensive coordinator Brian Hartline wound up at South Florida. And while it’s difficult to sort out who was a real candidate and who wasn’t, that’s still not nearly a complete list. Some wonder if Franklin’s powerful agent, Jimmy Sexton, has been poisoning the well.
At this point, interim coach Terry Smith might be the best option. I suppose it's always possible Kraft is holding an ace. Maybe he’ll get a coach still at his current school, like Alabama’s Kalen DeBoer. Maybe Kraft is playing chess instead of checkers.
At the moment, though, he appears to be playing charades — and doing a terrible job of impersonating an athletic director.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.