UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — When Penn State fired James Franklin just six games into the season after the team’s loss to Northwestern, it was evident it was a move made to get the next head coach in as soon as possible.
With the goal of keeping any continuity the former No. 2 in the nation had intact as the top priority, the Nittany Lions named cornerbacks coach Terry Smith the interim head coach. And while he would be considered for the full-time role, Penn State athletic director Pat Kraft ensured they would conduct a “national” search for the next person to lead Penn State.
Fast forward to the day before Wednesday’s national signing day, and Smith remains the interim head coach with names like BYU’s Kalani Sitake, Ohio State’s Brian Hartline and Indiana’s Curt Cignetti all off the board and the direction in Happy Valley as unclear as ever.
In turn, Penn State has lost nearly its entire recruiting class.
From Franklin’s firing to Wednesday, 25 recruits have decommitted from Penn State to bring an incoming class that was once nationally ranked in the top 20 to No. 134, according to 247 Sports, with only two committed recruits — four-star edge rusher Jackson Ford of Malvern Prep and three-star quarterback Peyton Falzone of Nazareth.
Some of the most notable recruits that decommitted from Penn State in the past few weeks include five-star and No. 1 running back in the Class of 2027, Kemon Spell; four-star safety Matt Sieg, who flipped to West Virginia; and four-star linebacker Elijah Littlejohn, who flipped to Georgia.
To add salt to the wound, 11 of the 25 decommits decided to join Franklin at Virginia Tech. The players joining the Hokies are as listed: four-star LB Terry Wiggins, four-star RB Messiah Mickens, three-star WR Davion Brown, three-star IOL Benjamin Eziuka, three-star LB Tyson Harley, three-star QB Troy Huhn, three-star TE Pierce Petersohn, three-star OT Marlen Bright, three-star OT Roseby Lubintus, three-star LB Mathieu Lamah and three-star cornerback Amauri Polydor.
Before Franklin’s dismissal, the Nittany Lions had eight four-star commitments. Now, Ford is the only four-star that didn’t flip amid their collapse, and with Polydor committed to Virginia Tech, Penn State has no more remaining commits waiting to make a decision.
It was clear Penn State was going to struggle to regain its footing after moving on from Franklin. While he may have struggled to bring home the ultimate goal of a national championship, his brand as a “player’s coach” in tandem with the legacy of Penn State ensured that dozens of recruits would want to call the program home.
However, there is still a chance that the Nittany Lions are able to regroup and get things back on track, and it starts by Smith being named the full-time head coach of the program. With Smith ending the regular season with three consecutive wins to secure bowl eligibility, the support in the locker room for Smith has grown loud.
At a time like this, where the future of the program is dependent on the current players in the building, it’s imperative to make the decision that will mitigate as much turnover as possible. Bringing in someone like Smith, who was able to unite the team during one of its lowest moments in the past decade while representing what made players want to come to Happy Valley in the first place, won’t fix everything. But it would be a real first step toward Penn State returning to its former glory.
With a decision of who’ll lead the Nittany Lions right around the corner, the future of Penn State football — and as Wednesday proved, its recruiting capability — hangs in the balance.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.