Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Larry Walker and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him at @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions, which this week were laced with Cam Heyward rage …

MartyMcfly_, @Whitaveli_: Cam needs to be traded, he’s 37. He’s not worth any more than the 14 million he’s getting. Ship him out for a 4th rounder. I’d do it.

Justin Belback, @AKAFloyd: Does Cam realize this team is “all in” for him? To make one last big run with a Vet QB? Is Cam just playing the game, how it’s played now? Will this tarnish his career, the way he’s handled his contract last two years? Or, as I think, none of this matters.

sports Nostradamus, @RevD98: Does Cam know that fans are being pretty harsh about his sit-in and threats of missing games?

Advertise with us

Jim Williams, @steelerbeam: What happens if Cam sits out a couple of games and the defensive line performs stellar? Then what?

J, @Crossland895: Good Evening, Dr Joe. I simply ask, in your not-so-humble opinion, what will Cam Heyward’s Steeler legacy be?

Starkey: I’m sensing a bit of Cam Heyward upset here, and I will certainly address it. But I’m reeling at the moment. I just heard Mike Tomlin talking crazy about the defense again. I feel like I’m hallucinating.

I wrote last week about all the self-generated hype coming from the Steelers about their defense, up to and including DK Metcalf saying it’s the “best defense I’ve ever seen,” Payton Wilson calling himself “one of the better cover linebackers in the world,” and Tomlin saying the Steelers can match and cover “anyone” in the NFL.

I joked that before camp was out, somebody would compare this defense — which was last seen giving up 300 yards rushing in a playoff game — to the ’85 Bears. Literally three hours later, somebody did. Juan Thornhill, cut by the Cleveland Browns, claimed the Steelers could be “one of the best defenses of all time.”

Advertise with us

That quote was relayed to Tomlin on Tuesday on the team’s flagship station. He was offered a chance to “cushion it.” He lit a match to it, instead.

“We got enough talent, enough schematics, to do big, big things,” Tomlin said. “And when I say big things, I’m talking about historic things.”

Again, am I dreaming? And again, I say: How about the defense plays its first competent playoff game in nearly a decade before we go comparing it to the greatest we’ve seen?

OK, now to the Heyward rage.

In a vacuum, this is not a big deal. Really good player is underpaid and will likely get a sweetener put into his contract, the way Antonio Brown did a few times all those years ago. But this is not happening in a vacuum — and Heyward, for the second straight year, is not handling the matter all that well.

Advertise with us

Rule No. 1: Don’t play with the fans’ heartstrings. Heyward did that last year by threatening to play elsewhere, noting he has family in Cleveland. This year, he is threatening to sit games, which puts a damper on all the good vibes emanating from Steelers camp. (And how are they supposed to top the ’76 Steelers, ’85 Bears and 2000 Ravens if Cam sits games?)

On top of that, Cam took pretty much all of what the Steelers owed him this season — in the form of a spring bonus worth around $13 million — and then decided not to work. Take the money and skip work? That’s probably not going to sit well. Neither is trying to do the skip-work thing in secret. I’m guessing the Steelers leaked the story to Adam Schefter.

Let’s get one thing clear here: The Steelers have treated Cam Heyward like a king.

Back in 2020, they gave him a four-year, $60.5 million extension that included the highest per-year average of any defensive player over 30 in NFL history. Last year, they apparently approached him about a pay cut — Heyward said so — and that turned into a new deal.

Hey, sometimes when you sign a contract, things work your way one year and the opposite another year. Two years ago, Heyward was injured and still collected paychecks, right?

Advertise with us

So give him the sweetener, I guess, and then go be the ’85 Bears.

Joe Starkey, @JoeStarkey1: Are you going to answer the questions above, Joe?

Starkey: Great question. First, let me get one other thing clear: People are tired of watching the highest-paid defense in football fall flat on its face in the biggest games every single year. The words “money” and “Steelers defense” are triggers for an entire fan base. That is why I could tweet out a fan poll asking if people would be OK with trading Heyward — I did just that Tuesday morning — and the results would read like this, with nearly 300 votes in 40 minutes:

Yes: 53.4%

No: 46.6%

Advertise with us

One of the questions was, will this tarnish his career? I don’t think so. I just think people are sick of hearing about guys on a chronically disappointing defense wanting more money all the time. Heyward has participated in nine playoff games. The Steelers are 1-8, and he has one sack.

T.J. Watt is 0-4 with one sack.

Having said all that, trading Heyward simply is not a solution to anything. Even with him, the line is a question mark for me. Derrick Harmon is a rookie. Keeanu Benton flatlined last year. Heyward is 36. The depth is highly questionable.

D n em, @WhoMe42069: Joe, my question is: when you began getting into the sports writing industry/radio, who was the biggest influence on you to pursue your career? Sorry if it’s not the right topic, but you are my influence and I’d love to hear from you!

Starkey: Well, Mike White is the one who hired me to take high school football scores on Friday nights at the Post-Gazette a million years ago, so if you’re looking to blame somebody, he's culpable.

Advertise with us

But you asked about influences: I’d say anybody writing for Sports Illustrated in the 1970s and Buffalo News columnist Larry Felser. I also enjoyed Miami humor columnist Dave Barry. I figured out pretty early that if I didn’t get paid for writing, other options might be limited.

As for radio, I decided real early I’d just be myself on the air, and if that worked, great. If not, oh well. Fifteen years later, it appears to be working — at least in my not-so-humble opinion.

Bean, @ItsMe_Thatguy: Should Aaron Rodgers start 1 series for the preseason home game since the steelers want fans to pay full price for a ticket and the fans are paying for entertainment they should be rewarded with something for having to pay more than $100 per seat?

Starkey: Hmmm. Interesting question, Dr. Bean. The fact that NFL teams rob their most loyal fans for exhibition games is pretty sickening. But I have to ask: How entertaining would it be to see Rodgers go out there, hand off twice and throw a quick out?

Burke O’Toole, @BurkeMan513: What percent chance do you give the Pirates for signing Paul Skenes to a longterm deal this offseason?

Advertise with us

Starkey: If by long-term, you mean one year into unrestricted free agency, I’d say 5%. I think it’s way more likely that Skenes will flee this pathetic organization the very second he is eligible for free agency. The only reason it’s not 0% is that the Pirates control Skenes for four more years.

If they make a deal where they pay him more than he would have gotten in arbitration for those years (he’s still pre-arbitration next season, which means the Pirates could make him play for next-to-nothing), they might get him to sign a year into his free agency. But he’d likely be traded before that year, anyway.

Nolan in New Ken, @nolan_in_NK: Professor Starkey, Does the Cam Heyward hold-in reveal anything about the current culture of the Pittsburgh Steelers? Many thanks for your incrinculent thoughts!

Starkey: No, no, thank YOU Dr. Ken. It seems in some ways the Steelers have become an organization that caters to players’ wishes more than ever before. You want out? OK, we’ll trade you. You want a new contract, even after we asked you to take a pay cut? OK, here you go!

I find it comical that the last time — off the top of my head — they took a hard stance on a contract was with Le’Veon Bell, the one guy WHO ACTUALLY WON THEM PLAYOFF GAMES.

Advertise with us

The last time the Steelers won a playoff game, Bell carried 30 times for 170 times against Kansas City. The week before, he ran for 167 on 29 carries against Miami. That was the only time in the past 14 years that the Steelers have won consecutive playoff games.

John Marlovits, @john_marlovits: Why the hell is Heaney still on the Pirates roster?

Starkey: Don’t even get me started on this, Dr. John. Ben Cherington was asked the other day when Bubba Chandler will be promoted and said, “We’re not going to force someone out of a spot just to do it, unless there’s a reason to.”

I have a reason: HEANEY STINKS!

Polish Yinzer, @TruthYinzer: Joe, athletes bet on themselves all the time. Why did Cam not do the same? Seems to me like his agent was asleep at the wheel, Joe!

Advertise with us

Starkey: Yes, Dr. Yinzer, that would have been an option, I suppose: Play on a one-year deal and then take your chances, especially considering none of the money beyond the first year was guaranteed.

Tom Mosser Design, @tommosser: Joe. I believe that we love playing sports because of one word: creativity. Every play on a field, court, rink and course are based on a series of rapid fire reactive ideas. The best athletes are the most creative ones. Thoughts?

Starkey: Well, I know many of my favorite athletes fit into that category, Dr. Design. Which is to say, unbelievably creative. My two favorite basketball players, for example, are Steph Curry and Caitlin Clark, and they are like incredible musicians making it up as they go along. You never know what’s going to happen next because they don’t know, either.

John Columbus, @cooljerdoc: Do we hate the Brewers or are we sinfully jealous of them?

Starkey: Let’s be fair, Dr. C: The Brewers are only better than the Pirates in drafting, development, free agent signings, international signings, fundamentals, pitching, hitting, coaching, baserunning and defense.

Advertise with us

Other than that, they’re even.

Seriously, every time this team pops up on the schedule, it’s just a total embarrassment and a total indictment of Bob Nutting and everything he has done to ruin baseball here — that a team in a smaller market kicks the Pirates’ behinds so thoroughly, all the time, and wins the division nearly every year.

Tim, @tim_pfadt: Can the Steelers just pay up so all these fans bashing Cam can go back to being his biggest fans?

Starkey: Yes, Dr. pfadt. They can.

And thank you for asking.