If you can name a coach who experienced great success early in his career, stayed with the same team for at least five presidential terms, morphed into some combination of Jeff Fisher and Marvin Lewis for eight years and then recaptured the early success, please tell.
Mike Tomlin is attempting to do that.
Likewise, if you know of a quarterback not named Tom Brady who flourished in his age-42 season, identify him.
Aaron Rodgers is attempting to do that.
I’m not saying it can’t happen. I’m just saying it never has. We have never seen a coach-quarterback combo quite like this — their stars fading — join forces and shock the world.
Both men have been to the NFL’s mountaintop. Both will have busts in Canton. Both have earned enormous respect. But make no mistake: Their stars are fading.
Read More
More on that in a moment. First, a question: What would constitute a successful season for the "all-in" Steelers?
A Super Bowl championship?
A Super Bowl appearance?
An AFC championship game appearance?
A playoff win for the first time in nine years?
A competitive playoff loss for the first time in nine years?
I guess I’ll go with a playoff win. That would be different.
Can you imagine if this proud franchise goes a ninth consecutive year without a playoff win? Nine years is literally a lifetime in the NFL. Some of the greatest coaching careers in history were fashioned in about that time. Bill Walsh, John Madden and Vince Lombardi only coached 10 years, Jimmy Johnson nine.
Tomlin is 0 for his past 8. What follows is the list of coaches who actually have won at least one playoff game over the past eight seasons.
Read it and weep: Mike Mularkey, Doug Marrone, Anthony Lynn, Brian Daboll, Jason Garrett, Mike Zimmer, Bill O’Brien, Todd Bowles, Kevin Stefanski, Zac Taylor, Bill Belichick, Sean McDermott, John Harbaugh, DeMeco Ryans, Pete Carroll, Mike Vrabel, Dan Quinn, Sean McVay, Kyle Shanahan, Matt LaFleur, Sean Payton, Doug Pederson, Bruce Arians, Andy Reid, Nick Sirianni, Mike McCarthy and Dan Campbell.
Did I miss anyone?
Oh yeah, Frank Reich. He won a playoff game, too.
I suppose you could even include Mike Priefer, a Browns assistant who stood in for an ill Stefanski in a 2020 wild card game and presided over a 48-38 shredding of the Steelers.
OK, now the list of coaches who, while not having registered a playoff win, have at least one playoff appearance more competitive than any Tomlin has put together in the past eight years. Which is to say, they had an actual chance to win in the final minutes: Matt Nagy, Brandon Staley (although his team did blow a 27-0 lead), Mike McDaniel, Ron Rivera, and, yes, Rich Bisaccia, the interim coach for the Las Vegas Raiders when they went into Cincinnati for a playoff game in 2022 and might have won if not for a controversial Bengals touchdown.
The closest score of Tomlin’s five playoff losses in the past eight years — in which his teams have been outscored 63-0 in first quarters — was 45-42 against Jacksonville. But that comes with a major caveat: Tomlin butchered the end of the game, refusing to kick a field goal that would have made it 45-38 and given him time for an onside kick and possible Hail Mary attempt to Antonio Brown or Martavis Bryant.
Instead, the Steelers kept trying to score a touchdown and finally got one with ONE SECOND LEFT!
Rodgers has just two playoff wins since 2016 and never made it back to a Super Bowl after beating the Steelers in 2010. Age and injury have robbed him of his ability to avoid defenders behind the line and create time for big plays.
I’m imagining we’ll see a lot of late-stage Ben Roethlisberger in Rodgers. Meaning, we’ll see flashes of greatness in a reduced version of his once-dynamic self, and a quarterback eager to unload the ball within a split second of receiving it.
Late-stage Roethlisberger and Russell Wilson were restricted from changing calls at the line under Tomlin. Will Rodgers be granted more freedom?
Like older Ben, Rodgers surely has the football acumen to win games. He also still has that golden arm. But does he have enough to make the Steelers a bona fide contender?
Like I said, that feels like a pipe dream. Rodgers is walking into a new environment with new personnel and a new playbook. He apparently has familiarity with the Arthur Smith system — the connection being LaFleur — but that system has really only flourished when a guy named Derrick Henry stood in Smith’s backfield.
Listen, I’m open to anything, and it will surely make for great theater.
It all begins Thursday when the 2025 Steelers practice in earnest for the first time — and if Tomlin and Rodgers make it work, it’ll be one of the most incredible football stories ever told.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.